New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Deconstructing an old drawer

Posts

Deconstructing an old drawer

#1

Deconstructing an old drawer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Deconstructing an old drawer’s dovetails

I recently gave the part of our club’s program that described hand cutting dovetails. The presumed need for perfection in this joint dissuades some from employing the hand cut version. Hence, the attraction of the “machine cut” part of the program. I brought this 100+ year old drawer to show that functional dovetails don’t have to be made like those flaunted on studio furniture. I may be the first to critically look at the joinery since it was made 100+ years ago.

PIC 1


The drawer is from a family piece, reputed to be from the later 1800’s according to family legend. The drawer front is walnut, the sides poplar and the back and bottom basswood.

PIC 2


Picture 2 shows the dovetails on the back of the drawer. They were over sawn by an amazing amount. Over sawing a bit ensures one is not left with some pesky waste in the corners when the waste is chiseled out, but this sawing seems extreme. Anyone have an idea why they were over sawed so much? The saw kerf is exceptionally fine. The top “tail/pin” is curious. Never seen one like it. The bottom pin was cut too small by part of a saw kerf, the glue failed from lack of gap filling, and it has become loose. Note the chisel hole. Obviously drawers were stacked to chop the waste and when stacked it is all too easy for the chisel to punch through and dent the drawer below.

PIC 3


Picture 3 shows the front of the drawer. Note the over sawn cuts to speed waste removal. These dovetails are smaller than on the back, which is typical I am told. The fit is nice. Again note the chisel hole.

PIC 4


Picture 4 shows the back of the drawer which is of conventional construction for this period except for one detail. The back is cut ½” below the sides. The back is cut low to clear the drawer stop blocks that are installed on the top rail, not the bottom rail as is the normal case. And again, a chisel hole can be seen. I have never been able to chop waste with a chisel this wide (1 ¼”) . A chisel this wide has to be wacked hard to get penetration and in my case a bruised baseline. (more on that in another post describing an evening with a local professional Period Furniture builder)

This drawer was made by someone employing the minimum effort and time to obtain a functional drawer construction. It was presumed that the customer was only interested in the outward appearance of the piece(I presume). Yet it has held up fine, a testimony to the robustness of the dovetail joint. It became a good illustration of my point to not fear less than perfect dovetails where they aren’t part of the design.

Re: Deconstructing an old drawer

#2

Thanks Bill, a good read

John in NM

Especially the pictures and the last paragraph. I see the same on the rare occasion I see vintage hand cut dovetails in antique stores out here (40-50 year old factory stuff is more the norm).

It was clearly all about speed and function, though it does seem that some little effort was made to make the front ones more appealing to the customer's eye. That is the only reason I can come up with for the finer front dovetails.

Perhaps if there were the internet and Antiques Roadshow back then, the customers of the day would have been as discerning as those today. Perhaps though it is the builder more than the customer driving the trend of perfection being the only option that so discourages novices from employing the joint.

Re: Deconstructing an old drawer

#3

Re: Deconstructing an old drawer

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Good show and tell; and that piece is not unique. A similarly sized little cabinet in my parents' house, provenance unknown, and of more utliitarian woods, had dovetails with gaps all around in the drawers; yet it had held up to generations of use, including, I assume, other children before us who were not gentle with furniture (or much else). I wish I'd gotten pictures of it when we were sorting furniture as the house was closed down; I was busy enough that I didn't think of it at the time.

Re: Deconstructing an old drawer

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Good example

Jack Guzman from Maine

That drawer is an excellent example to help make your point. When I do dovetail demos I try to convey the same message.

Dovetails for show are an art form. They have a place these days. But that should not be the rule.When building drawers the important issue is the strength of the joint.Most people don't even look at the dovetails in a piece.---Jack