New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

shellac- after it gets applied

Posts

shellac- after it gets applied

#1

shellac- after it gets applied

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Starting a new thread because the topic emphasis is different.

From the responses below I see that shellac does chemically change upon aging as a result of exposure to oxygen and/or water. This apparent fact kindled more thinking and consulting on the matter. (I eat lunch once a week with some organic chemists and polymer chemists)

What happens to shellac after it gets put on the furniture? Obviously the same as what happens stored in the bag, except faster because it is in a thin layer. So what are the ramifications of this chemistry? Shellac on a 5 year old chest of drawers is clearly not what it was when applied.

Some chemistry. If the molecule is small enough something will dissolve it. Even polymers are soluble in something. The only organic stuff that is insoluble in everything is a cross-linked polymer. At best a cross-linked polymer will form a gel in a solvent that would have dissolved the polymer before cross-linking. With sufficient shear in stirring a gel may disperse and appear to dissolve.

Reactions with water will not polymerize shellac. The reaction with water may form some compound that requires a different solvent mix from ethanol but something will dissolve it.

Looking at the major constituents of shellac there are reactive sites just like in the drying oils (Linseed, Tung, etc) that could react with oxygen. We know that reaction of the drying oils with oxygen "cures" them into tough insoluble films. This chemistry is well understood. The result is a cross-linked polymer.

Hypothesis- The data suggest that shellac undergoes an oxidation that results in a cross-linked polymer. While this result is not good for flake storage, if true, the result would be a tougher more durable film on the furniture after some cure time.

Has anyone ever encountered any discussion of the possibility of shellac "curing" after application?

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#2

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

CJ in MPLS

Assuming that someone, somewhere, and at some indeterminate time has likely done a study on the cross-linking capabilities of natural polymers such as shellac, this information might already be in the literature. A very cursory Google search suggests that such information may already be out there and that it is likely to have been funded by food scientists looking to preserve your apples for a greater period of time.

In the preferred method of preparing, the shellac is cross-linked in a dry, molten mixture with the HPC by heating at 130° to 175° C. for 2 to 15 minutes. The coating compound while molten is dissolved in a food grade solvent, applied to a substrate, and dried. The coating compositions are particularly useful as a moisture barrier in composite food articles having phases in contact which differ substantially in water activity. Effective films range from 0.1 to 5 mils in thickness.
US 4661359 A

I have to apologize, but my irreverent side wants to point out that you may be opening a new front in the war of food safe finishes.

CJ

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#3

Re: shellac

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Ran across (actually tripped over) some stuff being marketed to turners by an Aussie company called "Hardened Shellac" in the nature of a friction polish. Turns out it is a cross-linking shellac and fairly expensive.

One flavor is marketed by U Beaut Shellawax see http://www.ubeaut.com.au/shell.html

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#4

Old finish

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have worked with a number of old surfaces where the shellac was older than a century. Here are some observations.

1. Old shellac can be removed with alcohol. The finish gets soft enough that a cloth with alcohol can remove it. I think it is more work than removing fresh shellac.

2. New shellac will adhere to the old finish. The solvent in the new will soften the old layer and bond with the new just the way shellac bonds with a coating that was put on yesterday.

3. Old shellac can get very fine cracks. These can be repaired with new application of a thin shellac or with judicious use of alcohol alone.

$. Shellac is durable. It does not get gummy or peel.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#5

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

There's a bit of a paradox on this stuff since I pulled their MSDS and it states there is no "polymerization" involved in the cure even though they seem to claim otherwise.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#6

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

E Snow

I've never read anything that suggests shellac cures/polymerizes in such a way that ethanol or some solvent won't dissolve it. My experience so far suggests the no matter the age eventually it will dissolve into 'solution'. Does that solution hide already non-soluble polymerized gel chunks? Maybe, but the shellac itself is not homogeneous so the chemistry that may effect a small portion of will not be uniform anyway. That isn't to say that some local chemistry that occurs in its application or final residence may not have a negative effect on its later solubility. Its make up is dependent on organic processes that are subject to environmental variance.

No matter its resistance I'd say the effect is local. As a general rule shellac is pretty weak sauce and as such its resistance to solvents is also pretty weak. Example water, which is not all that hot (also a polar solvent) can do a number on even the most uniform applications.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#7

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

E Snow

I will note that my worst experience, ruby button which liberon? rarely used to sell never dissolved well when it was new but still did after a week and occasional agitation despite being full of wax and sticks. It still dissolves now ten years later but definitely takes longer. In both cases a hard high gloss finish developed in normal shellac time and seems to still be holding up.

Anymore I just make a mother solution and let it soak for as long as it needs to and then cut it when I need to refill my squirt bottle. I have had no shelf life issues with it.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#8

conclusion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your experience suggests that whatever the reaction is, it doesn't continue forever toward crosslinking the resin, if indeed the gels are cross-linked shellac or some component of it. That is to say, the solubility behavior of my 10 year old shellac stored under favorable conditions of humidity (none) is about the same as a furniture finish film. The reaction may not even be sufficient to add any meaningful improvement to the "cured" shellac film.

Bummer...a reaction that is a nuisance and provides not benefit to the film on the furniture.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#9

Re: conclusion

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I certainly would not want shellac to cure to the point that it could not be reworked at a later time. With shellac you can use the furniture in daily life with children and whatnot and later touch it up without having to strip the finish and make a mess of the color.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#10

Pure & Digestable

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Few people realize how much shellac they've eaten in their lifetimes. Like M&M's? Ever take a shiny apple to your 2nd grade teacher? Take "time release" medication (remember those tiny time-pills in Contac)? You can thank those little bugs for all of that. One estimate I've seen was that the average American eats between 2 and 5 pounds of shellac by the age of 70.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#11

Shellac polymerizes, more Chemistry, Zinser

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Over on the main Forum a question of shellac came up and among the responses is a patent reference that I have been meaning to look up for ages and never got around to it (http://www.google.com/patents/US6348217). The patent explains the process Zinser uses to prepare stable shellac. Reading between the lines the patent describes a process for removing a highly reactive acid component from the shellac. This acid seems to be responsible for making the stored shellac insoluble after some time and also for the reactions with solvent that slows drying times.

From the patent information I conclude:

Typical shellac becomes insoluble after storage through polymerization (assuredly cross linking). Neither Oxygen or water appears to be involved. Temperature accelerates this process. Hence, those that store the shellac in the frig are on the right track. The process Zinser uses removes the reactive component to render it vastly more stable. This component appears to be an organic acid.

Typical shellac reacts with ethanol, likely catalyzed by the organic acid mentioned above, to make an ester that slows hardening (drying) time of the shellac film. The stuff that Zinser removes slows this process substantially.

Shellac films get softer over time. Again, the Zinser material gets softer slower.

While not specifically stated, the Zinser product appears to be 35% solids in 95% ethanol/water with a small amount of methanol and a ketone with a high boiling point. Someone needs to convert that to pound cut but it must be a big number. A bargain at $45/gallon.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#12

Zinsser pound cut

John in NM

As I recall, Zinsser is a 3# cut. I think I got that from the can, but it may have been from this forum 10 years or more back.

This is interesting info you've found, explains why my flake shellac went off in a mere 6 months or so when living in Tucson - temperature. I still have the stuff but I'm going to toss it when I get home this week.

The flip side is that my plastic resin glue keeps forever out here. Not much moisture in the air.

Re: shellac- after it gets applied

#14

Bulls Eye

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

(waxy) is 3 lb. cut

SealCoat (dewaxed) is 2 lb. cut