New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

Posts

Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#1

Chris Scholz

Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

Chris Scholz

Last week I posted a link to my favorite woodworker, 辛师傅 to Youku. Looks like the link does not work too well, I think it is because this was going to google translate.

Ok, so maybe I'll process this a bit and make it more accessible for us in the West.

First, hand-cut M&T Chinese Style. 辛老師 (as a Professor, we need to call him 老師, i.e. laoshi, the title 师傅, shifu, is more for skilled craftsmen) is doing this a bit different than what Prof. Ecke shows in his book "Chinese Domestic Furniture", joint #10a, #16, and to some extend #25 and #32.

My on sketchup rendering.


Wonder if the two miters are cosmetic or to support the M&T. My limited knowledge in mechanical engineering in general and statics in specific makes me think that the miters help prevent racking. Thinking of it a bit more, this is an ingenious extension of our own M&T joint (or maybe our M&Ts are a crude simplification of the Chinese M&T joint, or maybe Western M&T joints and Chinese M&T joints were developed completely independent from each other).

In any case, here's a link to the original video on Youku (without the google translate part), should work this time...

http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNzc2NzAzMDQ0.html

(Hmm, have not figured out why the link starts t 7:31 min into the video, just scroll to the beginning if you are interested in this)

Enjoy.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#2

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

William Duffield

At least one reason the miter is used is so you can put a radius or more complex molding detail on the front (and back) faces of both parts and have them still meet smoothly at the joint.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#3

There is a practical advantage

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Looks like a great joint for those no longer challenged by a western M&T :D


I see a practical application. If the face is not flat some sort of miter is essential at the intersection of two pieces. I solve the problem by covering up the western M&T with a facing strip with the profile, in this case a section of a circle, and miter the two applied facing pieces together with a "dart". The Chinese joint illustrated would similarly solve the problem without resorting to the applied facing. However, I have no idea how I would approach reliably cutting the Chinese joint.

As an aside I don't see that it has any racking advantage over a western shouldered M&T.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#4

Re: There is a practical advantage

William Duffield

That's exactly what I was trying to describe. Thanks for the photo; I couldn't find one. That joint also works if instead of a curved face, you want a bead on each edge of the stile and blade.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#5

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

David weaver

I like the wall of plane bodies behind his bench. I presume he made those because there's no damage on any of them.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#7

Re: For example

William Duffield

I wonder why he fit it so well at the bottom, but just butted the molding at the top?

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#8

answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

see picture


BTW, the "he" is me.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#9

Re: answer

William Duffield

If I'd seen that picture first, I would have known it was yours because I would have immediately recognized your fine line and berry work, and I wouldn't have needed to ask my question. The way you did the moulding looks good. I think another bead above the top drawers would have looked too busy.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#10

Can`t decide what I enjoy most about these videos

Bob Hackett

It `s either the fact that he never lets anything get in the way of the work (he can pretty much wrestle anything into submission) or the fact that he has such a fine sense of fashion (eclipsed only be his demonstrated skills as a woodworker).

This guy is both incredibly inspiring and also removes all tool related excuses for not getting the job done. A vice chaser of the highest order. :D

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#11

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

Chris

I have no clue what these planes are about. They don't show up in the old videos for sure, will be interesting to see what happens.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#12

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

TomD

Chris, have you ever come across a video on how to make one of those bowsaws, or seen them for sale. I made one out of Purpleheart a long time ago, but have never been all that pleased with it.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#13

Chris Scholz

yes...

Chris Scholz

I remember having seen a video where he makes a bow/framesaw from scratch. The thing that I thought was very different is that he set the teeth one left, skip one, one right, skip one, ...

Will start a new thread when I find the video.

Re: Traditional M&T Joint Chinese Style

#14

Re: yes...

TomD

Thank you.