New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

Posts

Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#1

Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

John Aniano in central NJ

Greetings all,

Was wondering, might anyone have a copy of a circa 1982-83 Japan woodworker catalog? I have an ebony handled chisel set I bought back then that I'd like to identify.

I could take a picture of the chisel brand and/or box calligraphy if anyone thinks they could identify the maker from those markings.

Thanks,

John

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#2

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

david weaver

If you can get the stamp that the maker put on the chisel, you have a better chance of identifying it from that.

Who knows what's written on the box, as that could've been made in another shop.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#3

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

TomD

Anything like this?

http://www.permies.com/t/36535/a/17454/IMG_4741.JPG

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-RmERp_oxgFg/UtbfsCjRiAI/AAAAAAAAFjI/aQnncVWTKLs/s1600/IMG_2318.JPG

I got a set of ebony chisels back then from Ouchi, from another store, but JW was a pretty relentless advertiser of that brand. It was virtually their trademark at the time.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#4

permies!!

david weaver

I read that sometimes, but don't post there.

Ouchi is what I was thinking, too.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#5

Re: Pics of of old Japan woodworker chisels...

John Aniano in central NJ

Wow, I knew folks might have some knowledge about these...

Here are some pics of the chisel set. The label came from one of the handles and I guess I saved it. The calligraphy is from the wood box. Maybe they might jar someone's memory and provide info on these.




FWIW, I practically never use these. Only the two smallest and the largest chisels have ever been sharpened. They still have the Vaseline I put on them (to prevent rust) from, oh, maybe 1985.

Thanks,

John

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#6

Re: Pics of of old Japan woodworker chisels...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

No help here about the ID but what a beautiful set of chisels...

I'd fondle them all even if I didn't use a size or two.

JR

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#7

Re: Pics of of old Japan woodworker chisels...

David Wong (in Cupertino, CA)

I believe the maker is "Yoshitora" (善虎). The center kanji is a description of "master tools" (or something like that), bench chisels (追入鑿), and the name of the blacksmith. The left side describes the wood in the handles, the multi-hollow back, and a set of 10.

I am not a japanese speaker. This is just my poor translation.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#8

Re: Pics of of old Japan woodworker chisels...

wilbur

Hi John,

Yoshitora was a chisel maker that Japan Woodworker carried back in the day. I found an image from an expired eBay listing for Yoshitora chisels, and although the picture is small and blurry, the writing on the box does seem to match the writing on yours.


If you can, bring them to a CJWA meeting. I’d love to take a look at them.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#9

Yoshitora

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Here is a page from the Mahogany Masterpieces catalog of 1984, reproduced on the daikudojo website:

http://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/20070110_mahogany_masterpiece_catalog/

On page 20, in the discussion of Iyoroi Master Chisel Set, it is stated in the catalog text that Iyoroi-san for years has marketed his chisels under the Yoshitora brand. John's look like the early-80's vintage Iyoroi to me.

Wiley

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#10

Re: Yoshitora

TomD

That is interesting Wiley, when I saw them I thought Iroyoi right off the bat. I have quite a few of those, mostly from when LV used to carry that stuff back in the 80s. Didn`t know the other name though.

If you want to sell those chisels, you might consider buffing the handles. Though don`t the worng way it can be dangerous, so maybe buffing them with a rag like shoes.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#11

Re: Yoshitora

John Aniano in central NJ

Wow Wiley, you are amazing! To know of and/or find such a catalog is astounding to me! I do remember that you like Japanese tools, so I'm not too surprised that you might have helped me here.

So, from what all you and the other posters have said, these chisels are probably Yorishita "brand" made by Iyoroi-San. What is the maker's full name? When did he live, and is he still alive?

In Toshio Odate's book on Japanese tools, he mentions about certain tools too good for their owners. He mentions having a special plane he saved to purchase only to have the plane taken from him by his master (stepfather too, I think) as the tool was "too good". Sometimes I feel that these chisels may be too good for me, maybe that is why they have seen such little use.

Again, thanks for the great info on these tools!

John

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#12

Re: Pics of of old Japan woodworker chisels...

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi Wilbur,

Thanks for the added info. I'll bring them to the next week's CJWA meeting.

Do you or anyone else have any idea what these might be worth? I think I paid about $350 or so for the set back in '82...

John

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#13

Re: Pics of of old Japan woodworker chisels...

John Aniano in central NJ

David,

Thanks for the translation! Much appreciated!

John

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#14

Re: Pics of of old Japan woodworker chisels...

david weaver

Japanese chisels are a bit difficult to sell used compared to what their price would be new. Iyoroi still makes some (and I use this term, I know it will rub some people the wrong way because of the maker's reputation as supplying commodity chisels through harima in the US) higher end chisels. Figure those chisels from japan (not from a US seller) would probably be about $60-70 each, but I don't see a similar current offering. I'm basing that on a white steel mokume iyoroi only being about $70 or a little less on average now, and while Iyoroi's mokume isn't highly regarded visually, it is super dreamy on a sharpening stone, and a little more desriable even from a practical perspective than the plain iron backing. I'd call it a draw, trading the cost of the kamaji for the ebony handles.

Just giving you my opinion having bought three sets of four used (two were new old stock) chisels now, from iyoroi, an unknown maker from the 1980s that were labeled "Crysanthemum 3000 (I think they were probably iyoroi), ouchi and miyanaga, I'd guess half of new or just a little more would be a realistic value. So $400 or so.

My advice is to keep them, and I don't know if those are blue or white. My ouchi and iyoroi are white steel, and iyoroi even on their higher end chisels are kind of soft compared to makers like ouchi, but not in a way that affects work. If I were given the two and not aware that ouchi's reputation is better than iyorois, I'd probably prefer the iyoroi because they still hold an edge better than any of my western chisels and they are twice as easy to sharpen as the ouchis.

Maybe someone here can confirm, but I think in the 1980s, rosewood and dressiness was all the rage here, but in japan the flashiness is not as highly regarded. Someone who lives in japan told me that the guy who runs JWW, or who used to, was joked about by dealers in japan because he came looking for flashy chisels and they thought he was foolish.

That's a long way around, I guess, of saying that it's not as easy to unload japanese chisels for a high percentage of the US retailers costs as it would be to do with something like a LN or LV tool, and JWW may stock something like that now, but their prices are far out of line (the last I looked, stu tierney who is based out of japan charges about half as much for tsunesaburo planes, and I know fujibato charges much much less for chisels. Maybe just over half of what JWW asks). So, I'd base value on a percentage of the japanese cost (figure 114 yen per dollar right now) and not what some of the US retailers ask.

One other side comment, it's easier to compare prices when the exchange rate is bad, and right now it's very much in our favor, which makes it easier to track down low prices from people like fujibato, takeshi kuroda (metalmaster) and stu tierney who sell out of japan in yen, but ship to the US. The level of service isn't the same as having a specialist in the US (is there really anyone filling that role any longer?) but the price disparity is so large right now between dollar based retailers and yen retailers that it makes it hard to justify.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#15

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

Alan Pound

The Japan Woodworker catalog shows Yoshitora. The catalog lists JWW part #15.302.00 and price was $282.40.

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

#16

Re: Copies of old Japan woodworker catalogs?...

david weaver

If that catalog was 1985, that's roughly equivalent to about $620 in today's dollars.

Not that a lot of things haven't changed. The Historical exchange rate for 1985 appears to be about 250 yen to a dollar (today it is 117), though it didn't stay at 250 for long, it was closer to the current rate a couple of years later.

At the 117 level, fujibato doesn't have those chisels listed, but he could probably sell that set of chisels (picking them off of his page) for about $650-$700 (in white steel) plus the cost of the box.

Presume that the JWW margin back then had a lot more room than fujibato takes, though, unless they've really changed philosophies (as they have a plain "matsumura" chisel priced at more than fujibato has for an iyoroi mokume chisel).