New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Order of Operations

Posts

Order of Operations

#1

Order of Operations

CJ in MPLS

I was helping my 12 year old with the old order of operations algebra problems (PEMDAS anyone?) and in the back of my mind the fact that I didn't explicitly know the order of operations for fitting tenons to mortises was kind of silly.

I've been making a small step stool that was written about in FWW by Mario Rodriquez. This stool has legs with tenons that are received in angled mortises in the top, three for each leg. The mortises were cut first. The legs were cut by marking from the actual mortises. The tenon faces were established using a shoulder plane.

The first attempt seat the tenons revealed that they were a bit too big. Not unreasonable as I am a bit phobic about removing too much, which as it turns out is a touch ironic. After a lot of faffing around I've got one side to well enough and the other is going to be OK, but will need a bit of cosmetic surgery.

So, what is your order of operations to ensure that the tenons that don't fit, do fit and fit neatly?

Thoughts?

CJ

Re: Order of Operations

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: Order of Operations *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I looked up the article for Mario's footstool, and I think the link posted here is the one you're talking about. In the article, Mario says to make a story stick to mark both mortises and tenons, and that would seem to be a good way to get the tenons in the right place, assuming you cut the mortises accurately. If you cut the sides of the tenons accurately, just some slight trial-and-error paring should be all you need to get them to fit nicely.

You certainly could mark the tenons from the existing mortises instead of using the story stick. For that matter, you could cut the tenons first and then mark out the mortises from the tenons. Seems to me the order of work isn't crucial.

Ellis


Footstool

Re: Order of Operations

#3

Re: Order of Operations

CJ in MPLS

I did use the story stick, but in double checking the mortises, they had naturally changed a bit. Cest la vie.

So any tips on where to start the process of fitting multiple mortises?

CJ

Re: Order of Operations

#4

Re: Order of Operations

David Charlesworth

The best tip I know of is to cut mortices first. These should be from the width of the chisel and sides not pared.

If you plane up a test stick to fit mortise width, and you have callipers, you will be able to judge exact tennon thickness.

I like to bandsaw one face first, in exactly the right place.

Cut second face slightly full and use router plane to achieve fit.

The test stick is very helpful!

David

Re: Order of Operations

#5

I don't understand the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know if the question is about how to make multiple M&T joints or the steps to fit the height, width and length of any one of them.

In general I have never been successful in mass producing a M&T joint. As a curiosity I measured the difference between getting too tight and too lose and it was only 0.005" so the accuracy of getting this joint right is not trivial to achieve.

I make the mortise first. Measure tenon height off the result and cut tenon one way or another. Typically I saw the faces of the tenon, lop off the cheek waste short of the baseline and chisel back to the base line. For what ever reason the mortise thickness always vary a small amount and I have to plane some tenon faces to get a good fit (or rarely shim a tenon face, an annoyance to be avoided).

To avoid problems with assembly in the dry state the joint should be able to be assembled with hand pressure and no pounding .

Re: Order of Operations

#6

Re: Order of Operations

John in NM

I cut mortises first, only in a production shop did I find advantages to cutting tenons first and those advantages had nothing to do with fitting.

Of course, I cut both with machines on the whole, so I doubt I can really address your question in anything but a theoretical way. In principle, one should be able to get pretty close hand sawing a tenon and then take a few swipes with a plane to get right to proper fit. In practice, I believe that would take a huge amount of practice.

I have noticed significant variation even making them on a table saw with a tenon jig. The reason is that the blade deflects some even with a carbide blade, but with carbide you often don't notice just how dull it is until you start having deflection problems in precise work.

Re: Order of Operations

#7

Re: Order of Operations

CJ in MPLS

The question is really about defining a logical approach to correcting an error. The error in my case was cutting too wide of the line. Avoiding this error is a matter of practice.

In the current project the goal is to have a solid MT structure in which the visible portion of the joint is presentable. So in correcting things it became apparent that I had to avoid removing material from the distal ends of the tenons to get the entire thing to fit. Doing so would all the joint to fit together, but would result in more gaps when everything was seated. Therefore my first step was to ensure that the show portions of the joints were more or less correct.They were, but there was error in each of the tenons. Adjustments were made iteratively and mostly to the bottom portion of the mortises at first. As the tips of the tenons began to protrude from the mortises, the tenons themselves were trimmed to achieve a closer fit.

What I think I might do, as I am a glutton for punishment, is to dig up some scrap and try this entire process once again for educational purposes. I am not going to do it in teak.

Re: Order of Operations

#8

Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi CJ,

Are you making the stool that Ellis linked to?

The one where every tenon is wedged after assembly, to make the final fit?

Wiley

Re: Order of Operations

#9

Re: Question

CJ in MPLS

That is the one.

Re: Order of Operations

#10

Just a thought, not having done that job before...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I think the crucial part of this job is the marking. In particular, the transfer of marks from the first piece cut to the second piece.

Marking is made more difficult by the fact that it's tough to match the tips of the tenons to the show face of the mortise for direct marking. When you marked the tenon tips through the mortise, that may not be an exact match, unless the base width of the mortise was exactly the width of the show face of the mortise.

If I were doing this myself--and I haven't, so take this with much salt--I would make the leg tenons first, making them long as he says. Saw the shoulders, and bevel them with shoulder plane to reflect the 10 degree slant of the leg piece. Then put a 10 degree bevel on the tenons, still leaving them 1/8" or so long--this beveling is for marking. At this point, the tips of the tenons are at final dimension, save for trimming them flush once they're in place.

Now make a template for transferring the tenon tips to the show face of the mortises. Repeat, the show face of the mortises. This can't be done directly. I would use mylar as the template material, because you can draw a baseline on the mylar and a matching baseline on the stool top--and overlay the mylar baseline on the stool top baseline. Place the tenon tips along the mylar baseline and mark with fine pen (I wouldn't knife the mylar directly at this time). I would find a way to clamp or otherwise affix the tenon tips onto the mylar for marking--make absolutely sure there is no movement, once the marking starts, just like with transferring dovetail marks. Double and triple check the mylar marks against the tenon tips. Mark the template A, B, and C where the tips fall (you'll want this later).

Now tape the mylar template onto the stool top, registering the mylar baseline with the stool top baseline. When the template is perfectly set, use a heavy square and a marking knife to knife in the mylar marks onto the stool top, just shaving the inside of the pen marks. This will of course, cut free the little mylar squares marked A, B, and C. Save these as a check on the bottom side of the mortises.

Now make the mortises. Drill first, but not with the exact size Forstner. Use the next one down--drilling has play in it, machine runout or the inherent imprecision of matching the drill center to the work center. And proceed.....

Bottom line: my thought experiment says 'do the tenons first'. And then use a template to transfer the pattern to the mortises.

Wiley

Re: Order of Operations

#11

Ahhhh, I see now...

John in NM

In such a case, I would probably cheat - I'm big on cheating :D

If the mortise is not close in size to the tenon, I have no compunction about trimming the mortise. I find it easier to do than trimming the tenon if much has to come off. Of course, I rarely make through tenons, but I believe I would do the same for one of those. This may not be the textbook correct approach, but I find it the most consistent for results and speed together.

As you say though, the long term solution is practice :D

Re: Order of Operations

#12

Re: Just a thought, not having done that job befor

CJ in MPLS

The thing that is nice about reading these replies is realizing that my struggle to correct the error is not atypical. Basically, it is more difficult to correct an error than it is to do things correctly in the first place.

What does appear to be atypical is the fact that I am not a steely-eyed missile man like the rest of yins. ;)

Re: Order of Operations

#13

Re: Order of Operations

CJ in MPLS

I like the test stick approach. I expect that as with training wheels, I would need it less over time. Thanks.

Re: Order of Operations

#14

Re: Just a thought, not having done that job befor

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

CJ,

Last project I did, I had to destroy, dig out, and replace 4-1/2 square feet of thick quartered satinwood veneer, due to warping of the core underneath it. Shoulda listened to Warren, who said to use solid wood for a core.

Steely-eyed missileman, indeed :) .

Wiley

P. S. And other stuff I can't even remember right now.

Re: Order of Operations

#15

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Just a thought, not having done that job befor

Jack Guzman from Maine

In my opinion,one of the greatest skills necessary for successful woodworking is the ability to recover from mistakes.In a really fine piece,the mistakes can't be detected."steely-eyed mistlemen" Never heard that one before.---Jack

Re: Order of Operations

#16

Re: Order of Operations

Warren in Lancaster, PA

What I do for joints like this is to lay out the mortises on all four sides of the seat with a knife. I use a bevel gauge to mark the edges of the seat with the appropriate slant. and I sometimes measure the distance from one line to the next (thickness of the tenon) on the edges of the seat as well. The lines on the top of the seat are slightly farther apart than the tenon is thick because of the slant. Then I use a marking gauge or a panel gauge to delineate the width of the tenons. Having the mortise marked like this on top and bottom helps insure accuracy.