New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Drawer fitting

Posts

Drawer fitting

#1

Drawer fitting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


A bit over 10 years ago woodworking quality in my machine only shop was stalled. The epiphany came during a visit to the College of the Redwoods (I do get out a bit). The students got precise fits with planes and chisels, not 4" belt sanders. I came home motivated to learn how to use a chisel and plane. It was not an easy adventure without having access to a mentor.

Hand tool enthusiasts learn/know a lot about planing and chiseling, and behind it all, sharpening. Through this forum I learned from them, though their single minded devotion to hand tools made it difficult for me to separate what I could get by with from the whole of it. Thankfully I eventually found that a cheap used plane and quick simple sharpening would suffice, for example. But one impediment remained, dreaded and unexpected tear-out. Knowledge of how to set the cap iron removed this final barrier.

Hand tools are the only way to precisely remove tiny increments of wood to result in a good fit. Hence, some hand tool techniques essential to fitting parts must be mastered. No where does this requirement become more essential than drawer fitting. I assemble drawers to be too tight, then plane the sides and sometimes tops to get the fit that results in a smooth working drawer.


I assemble drawers with grain orientation anticipating planning from front to back, essential in the case of these veneered drawer fronts. In the current case it was difficult to read the grain in some sides. Thankfully, optimum setting of the cap iron made worrying about grain orientation unimportant.

Note: These flexible drawer sides needed a shim under them to enable the plane to get a bite in the center of the sides. I used left over piece of resawed veneer for the shim.

Thanks to all that helped along the way.

Re: Drawer fitting

#2

Re: Drawer fitting

William Duffield

Bill, That's an inspiring message.

Are you showing an assembled drawer hanging over the board in the vise? The photo is a little dark, and I'm not sure I can make out the front, back and opposite side. Others might be unsure as well, as I think you are using walnut as the "secondary" wood as well as primary and veneer.

Also, I have a question: What are the notches in the bottom edge of both ends of the drawer side? I suppose could go back through your other posts on drawer assembly and maybe figure out why they exist, but I don't think I saw an earlier photo that shows them.

Re: Drawer fitting

#3

to answer your questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. What I am showing is a typical drawer side planing set up. I do not recall who taught me. The bottomless drawer is simply slipped over a support board. In the picture the front of the drawer is vertical and facing front; a side is up. One can plane the front the same way. This set up is amazingly secure. It is the easiest planing I do.

2. These drawers are tiny and I do not want to loose any more depth than I can get by with. Some 3 3/2" walnut veneer plywood will be tightly fitted into a rebate in the drawer bottom. These rebates were cut before drawer was assembled. The ends of the rebate show on the side of the drawer. I will probably not worry about this hole in the unseen back of the drawer. I will plug it in the front, something I should have done already. It would have been easier to mow the plug off while planing the drawer side, but it will not be difficult to simply pare it off with a chisel.

Re: Drawer fitting

#4

Re: Drawer fitting *LINK*

William Duffield

I figured out what the notches are, from the more detailed photo on the Messages board. They are rabbets in the front and back, to house the drawer bottom. I should have been able to figure that out. While I was expecting a groove in the front and sides that the bottom would slide into, all the examples of gallery drawers in all the desks that were presented and analyzed at the Colonial Williamsburg "Woodworking in the 18th Century" conference had the bottoms nailed on. They were either in rabbets like Bill's or more commonly just butt jointed and nailed onto the bottoms of the four boards. Even the Edward Evans scriptor from 1710 showed no evidence of any of the drawer bottoms having failed.


Hay Cabinet Shop Blog

Re: Drawer fitting

#5

Re: Drawer fitting

Steve Voigt

Bill, those drawers, and the whole unit, look great.

I can relate to your personal story, too. The first tools I ever bought were two Stanley planes. But reading woodworking magazines convinced me, still young an impressionable then, that router jigs and biscuit joiners were the way to go. It took a long time to work my way back. I should have gone with my gut…the funny thing is those same guys who were writing the articles extolling the virtues of biscuit joiners are now writing books about the joy of using hand tools. The bandwagon is getting crowded.

Anyway, nice work.

Re: Drawer fitting

#6

that was a problem for me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"books about the joy of using hand tools"

During Curtis Buchanan's program he said that he took up making chairs because it was a way to earn a living using hand tools. It took me a long time to realize that for some a hand tool is not just a means to an end. Rather, there is joy and satisfaction from using a hand tool. (Group 1)

Implicit in Curtis's career choice was his conclusion that he could not make enough places to store socks (furniture) with hand tools to make a living at it.

There is another world of wood working motivation. All our local good woodworkers learned the trade to be able to make stuff they couldn't buy. These are the people I mostly interact with and for a time I thought everyone was similarly motivated. I fall into this group too. (Group 2)

To be able to make much stuff one needs apprentices or power tools. But to make good stuff Group 2 needs some hand tool skills.

There is a big gulf between the Group 1's and 2's which hinders communication and learning. To simplify, I regarded the hand tool users as pie in the sky diddlers , and they regarded me as a machine operator too unskilled to prepare a board with a hand plane. I found over time that the hand tool enthusiast had some useful things to teach me. Perhaps I can return the favor by showing that there is joy, and challenge, to be found in making a place to store your socks.