New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

Posts

Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#1

Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

Has anyone successfully straightened an old boxwood four-fold rule? What is the best way to go about this?

Last week, I picked up a Stanley Works number 66 1/2 A, (three feet, four fold, bold numbers, 1923~1933) whose boxwood parts are warped. Because of its condition, it was inexpensive enough I can experiment on it, and if I can straighten it, it will meet my specialized needs. It lays flat, but the ends won't meet because the wood curves away from the rule joint, in the wide direction (technically, a "crook" http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cd/Wood_warping.png). Obviously, over many years, the outside edges have shrunk more than the inside edges. All four sticks have about the same amount of crook. When fully closed, the hinges are about 3/16" apart. When half opened (V-shape) the tips are about 5/8" apart. As expected, there is a lot less patina on the inside faces and edges.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#2

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

CJ in MPLS

How about cutting a slot in a block of wood that has a straight bottom, heating the boxwood sections on an iron and then quickly clamping the wood to the straight surface? If you prefer patent speak, I've provided a translation below. 8)

CJ

A straightening jig according to one embodiment of the present invention may include a platen, an abutment, a forming member, a fixing structure, and a heat source for heating the work piece. Together these elements form a jig that facilitates the straightening of a work piece such as a boxwood ruler section having a crook therein. The platen has a surface geometry that approximates a desired shape for one dimension of the work piece, in this case planar, and has a lateral extent somewhat greater than the work piece that is to be straightened. The platen may be heated, such as by applying an iron to a reverse side thereof though other sources of heat such as torch are contemplated.

The platen has associated therewith an abutment that may be fixable in relation to the platen or which may form an integral part thereof. The abutment extends above the surface of the platen and limits movement of the work piece across the surface of the platen. The abutment has a face that is oriented toward the platen so as to define two sides of a volume that will accommodate the work piece. The abutment face has a shape that is flat to convex along its lateral extent with respect to the volume, depending on need. The abutment face has a geometry that is complementary to the work piece, in the present instance, flat and perpendicular to the plane defined by the surface of the platen. In some embodiments the abutment face along the lateral extent of the platen may have an adjustable geometry and in others the abutment face has a fixed geometry.

The fixing structure is positioned above the platen to capture the work piece therebetween. The fixing structure permits movement of the work piece across the platen but limits and prevents rotation of the work piece out of the plane of the platen. The fixing structure may be affixed to and extend from the abutment in a parallel relation to the platen at a distance that is sufficient to receive the work piece between the fixing structure and the platen. In some embodiments, the fixing structure may be an integral part of the abutment that extends therefrom. While it is desirable to include a fixing structure, it is possible to omit this element or to deploy an independent fixing structure after the work piece has been addressed to the straightening jig to prevent rotation. One such independent fixing structure is a rigid body having a lateral extent of at least 1/2 the length of the work piece and preferably greater than 3/4 the length of the work piece that is set upon a top surface of the work piece and then forced into contact with the work piece as by clamping. As such clamping force may inhibit movement of the work piece across the platen, it may be desirable to employ such a fixing structure after other straightening operations. Alternatively, one may apply minimal clamping force to the fixing structure to permit relative motion between the work piece and the platen.

The forming member is used to press the work piece into the abutment to achieve the goal of changing the shape of the work piece. Where the work piece is of a uniform width, it is desirable to utilize a forming member that has substantially the same shape as the abutment face. In other applications the forming member will have a form that is complementary to the desired shape of the work piece but not necessarily the same as that of the abutment face.

In use the work piece is heated to a temperature between 356°-392° F. At about this temperature the lignin in dry wood will flow in a thermoplastic manner, permitting the shape of the work piece to be modified without removal of material. (Inoue et al. 1993) While this temperature range is ideal in that the work piece will retain little, if any, memory of its former shape, at temperatures above 392° F wood will begin to undergo pyrolysis, which is to be avoided. (White, et al., Encyclopedia of Matls., 2001) Accordingly, where it is difficult to control the application of heat to a work piece, it may be desirable to use lower temperatures to avoid pyrolysis. Where lower temperatures are used, it will be necessary to utilize an abutment with a convex shape to deform the work piece beyond its desired final shape to overcome the shape memory of the work piece. Where the more ideal temperature range may be obtained, a more linear abutment face shape will be suitable.

Heating of the work piece may be accomplished by direct conduction or by radiant conduction. In either case the end goal is to ensure that the work piece reaches a substantially uniform temperature that is high enough to permit permanent thermoplastic deformation of the work piece without damage. Control of a heated platen or of another suitable independent heating device is accomplished using suitable existing thermal control systems including thermocouple sensors or infrared monitoring. In other instances the work piece may be closely monitored for color or odor changes associated with pyrolysis and periodically tested to determine whether and to what extent the work piece has become deformable.

Once the work piece has reached its desired temperature, the work piece is placed on the platen and the forming member is actuated to force the work piece into contact with the abutment, thereby deforming the work piece to its desired shape. Generally it is desired to force the fixing structure into contact with the work piece to prevent relative motion of the work piece with the platen and to force the work piece to conform to the shape of the platen as the work piece cools. As the work piece cools, the lignin and other cellulosic materials that make up the structure of the work piece to form a fixed structure that is ideally of the desired shape. Once cool, the work piece will no longer deform in a plastic manner.

Cooling may be facilitated by the use of an independent heating device to raise the temperature of the work piece and a room temperature straightening jig that may act as a heat sink. In such an embodiment it may be necessary to minimize the amount of time necessary to actuate the forming member and/or the fixing mechanism to ensure that the work piece is deformed while it remains in or near the aforementioned thermoplastic temperature range.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#3

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

TMI! :)

Whoever wrote that just wanted to help too much, or maybe not at all?

If clamping it to a flat surface is enough to bring it to flat, I could just fold it up and clamp both ends, since all the crooks are symmetrical. I was wondering about springback, and whether I would need to put a small block in the middle to bend it a little past straight while it cools.

Having never done this, I'm also concerned with the possibility of ruining the finish (patina), but I should be able to correct that.

Another issue is the joinery between the boxwood and all the brass parts. Is it all mechanically riveted, or does it also rely on glue which might be upset by the heat? Oh, wait a minute. I have a copy of "The Rule Book" which just might have some explanation of the method of making these rules. I'll go read it and see what I can find.

How hot do I get the iron? poly? linen? cottton? wool? If I leave the iron right side up and place it on the ruler, I could maybe take advantage of the steam function as well. Is my iron 9 inches or more long? Do I risk engendering warp while removing the crook?

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#4

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

Warren in Lancaster, PA

William, I remember you have used dogwood for a mallets. You might try cutting similar strips of dogwood and experimenting with them.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#5

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

Good idea, Warren. I think I even have some english boxwood, but it is still in log form, and it hasn't been seasoned for 90 years, so it might not work the same. The same experimental stock will also come in handy when I get around to figuring out how to mark divisions.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#6

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

CJ in MPLS

William:

I wrote that as a bit of a lark. I'm a patent attorney and I read and write that kind of stuff all day. Both passages refer to the same thing; one description includes more options and pays better than the other. I'm fairly certain its obvious which one is which. :)

One thing that I did find when I was writing that is that you do want to get the wood up to between 356°-392° F. These numbers weren't made up on a lark and were taken from the article I cited.

This temperature range assumes that your wood is dry, which I presume will be the case for the boxwood.

A household iron may get you to where you want to be. A quick search shows that iron temperatures for the various settings are approximately as follows:

Linen: 230 °C (445 °F)

Triacetate: 200 °C (390 °F)

Cotton: 204 °C (400 °F)

Viscose/Rayon: 190 °C (375 °F)

Wool: 148 °C (300 °F)

Polyester: 148 °C (300 °F)

Silk: 148 °C (300 °F)

Acetate: 143 °C (290 °F)

Acrylic: 135 °C (275 °F)

Lycra/Spandex: 135 °C (275 °F)

Nylon: 135 °C (275 °F)

Set your iron to between Rayon and Cotton and you should be able to heat your boxwood to the thermoplastic range. Once there, clamp the wood in the shape you'd like to see and let it cool. In theory you'll be sitting in clover. More likely you'll have most sections straight, a couple will remain curved and one of the straight ones will be a bit darker than it started off.

CJ

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#7

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

Thanks, CJ. That's really helpful.

I understand something about what patent attorneys have to do, to "cover all the bases" when weasels try to steal your ideas. I reread what you wrote, and it suddenly all began to make sense. I had to get myself in the right frame of mind, which I did by reading some turn of the century descriptions on graduations and dividing knives. I still have more of that stuff to read and digest before I can fix and extend the graduations on a couple of these rules.

I had thought I was just going to heat it up and put spring clamps on the ends, but in light of your recommendations, I've reconsidered. There will probably be too much variation in the temperatures reached, and I may have to redo one or more sections, so I will use your recommended platen and abutment method.

I'll get "before" and "after" pictures, and hopefully some "during" pictures, too, and post them here. If this works, I have a couple more rules that also need a bit of straightening.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#8

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

Philip Duffy

If you need new wood give a growl as I have just acquired a whole tree that was 150 ++ years old. P.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#9

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

CJ in MPLS

The more I thought about this, the more I've become convinced that burning oneself is the most pressing problem here. Good luck and keep the new "witness marks" on your hands to a minimum.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#10

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

Thanks for the offer, Phillip, but this project doesn't need any more boxwood. If I need scraps, I have a bunch of boxwood pallet knives for burnishing carved surfaces and a friend a couple miles away whose property used to be a nursery with lots of boxwoods. Coincidentally, I picked up this practically worthless ruler in your city last week, for $7. It's valuable only from an experimental point of view.

When I decide to start from scratch and build a sector as Jim Tolpin describes, I'll need some straight grained, light colored, hard wood, but it doesn't need to be boxwood. I coould probably even make do with Baltic birch plywood. :D I've been reading a bit about the rule making industry of a century ago, and the impression I get is that they went through an immense amount of boxwood to turn a minuscule portion of it into rules. I suspect there was a lot of waste because a lot of the stock was not straight grained enough to be stable. It would still be fine for turning and for cutting in smaller pieces as boxing for planes.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#11

The polymer chemistry behind the problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Accept that balls don't roll uphill, which is to say the fix for this problem is not going to defy what mother nature will allow, likely.

Wood is a polymer like any other. To get a structure made from a polymer, in this case a leg of your rule, to permanently deform you have to move polymer molecules around, not just stretching them where they will spring back, but permanently moving them into a new position.

On a molecular scale the molecules are wiggling some even at room temperature. Higher temperature and they wiggle more. Add a plasticizer (in this case it will be water) and they will be able to wiggle more at lower temperature.

So, the task is to stress the wood into its desired position and hold it there until the molecules wiggle around enough to relax in this new position. The process may take months or years at room temperature and dry. It will take seconds hot and wet. The task is to pick a time, temperature and moisture content that the rule will survive and wait for the molecules to wiggle into relaxation.

(Note: you can do it at room temperature with anhydrous ammonia or hydrazine should you have any in the shop)

Also note: The patent describes the essence of the widely used procedure for bending string inlay around a hot metal object.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#12

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

I've got lots of things in my shop, and in my home that could give me bad burns, but I think the familiar things that you handle all the time (like brass bound rules) can be the most dangerous, because you don't imagine that they could be hot. I have a pair of gloves in my coat pocket (that I didn't need for shoveling snow yesterday!).

Some of the things I know to be careful of: For starters, I cook and bake; we have two fire places that we use. There is the BBQ grill that I can also use with a steam box; the gas can and steam box themselves; glue pot; hot plate; cast iron skillet for sand shading; heat gun; small propane forge for heat treating O1 tools; soldering iron; propane torches; and of course the steam iron. There's also a couple camp lanterns and a Primus camp stove.

Sometimes I'm surprised we don't all sooner or later burn our shops down.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#13

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

Bob Hackett

I`d start with dry heat like an oven with an accurate thermometer as an indicator. I`d also clamp everything in the jig in such a manner that the entire assembly would fit in a pyrex pan and then I`d cover everything with clean fine sand.

My reasoning would be; gradual even heat on all surfaces and dry heat is less likely to alter / damage the patina and whatever finish remains.

Perhaps Bill could help you dial in a heat range that would be most likely to plasticize the wood yet not be too damaging to the finish.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#14

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

CJ provided the requisite temperature range, between 356°-392° F. My oven thermostat is a bit low, but only by about 10° degrees, so I think I've got plenty of "wiggle room." While the finish would be important for a collectable rule, in this case, after I've gotten it straightened, I need to scribe some new divisions, and then fill them with black pigment. I also need to renew the pigment in some of the numbers, which have severely faded after decades of wear. I'll probably rub on some vegetable black (basically soot) in a linseed oil binder and then wipe it off the higher background, and seal it in place with shellac. After that, I have some some boxwood chip-out to replace, which is also going to need some finish. I haven't decided whether to replace it with some new boxwood, which will be a lot lighter than the rest of the old boxwood, or do another experiment and fill it with pigmented epoxy.

Yours is probably a better idea than trying to do it with a cheap steam iron in a shop that's going to be mostly below freezing for at least the next few days.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#15

Infringment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You will need to hire CJ to navigate you around the patent claims to avoid infringement. Or you could license. :)

Why this "invention" was accepted is a testimony of how the patent pendulum has swung far in the direction of "inventors".

On a more serious note, nothing about moisture was mentioned in relation to the temperatures. The details of the examples may shed some light. But wood is typically going to have some initial moisture content and it may be important to capture all or some of it to get these molecules to wiggle enough at a temperature low enough to wiggle molecules without decomposing the wood.

Just like the bending, the wood decomposition will be time and temperature dependent.

I would encourage trying this concept with a representative sized piece of maple before subjecting the boxwood to the test.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#16

Re: Infringment

CJ in MPLS

Bill:

In the interest of full disclosure, the following passage (found at NCWoodworker.com) is where I got the information I used above. As you say, moisture should help. And if a bit of blush to the finish isn't too problematic, that would be the way to go.

CJ

It is well known that lignin and the hemicelluloses are amorphous polymers. Cellulose,

on the other hand, is mainly crystalline but does contain regions with amorphous character within the crystalline lattice. Amorphous polymers undergo changes in physical characteristics upon heating resulting in transitions to a glassy and rubbery state (Irvine 1985). The temperature where this happens is referred to as the glass transition temperature or Tg. Transitions from one state to another depend on sufficient energy input to overcome the intermolecular attractive forces with in the polymer and allow a greater degree of flow. Chawla and Sharma showed that once the temperature exceeded 160 C°, there was sufficient flow of lignin to block pores within the wood structure to restrict the reentry of moisture (1972). Hillis and Roza found that a minimum heating of 2 hours at 100 C° plasticized the hemicellulose-lignin matrix.

It is also well recognized that moisture lowers the Tg of an amorphous polymer (Goring

1963). Goring examined the softening temperatures for dry and wet lignin, hemicellulose and cellulose and found that the sorption of water greatly decreased the Tg of both lignin and hemicellulose while the Tg for cellulose only varied slightly from dry to wet. The Tg for dry lignin is approximately 155-160 C° depending on the chemical structure. High syringyl content lignins have a lower Tg as compared to other lignins (Olsson and Salmen 1993). Inoue and coworkers showed that at temperatures between 180 and 200 C°, the lignin-hemicellulose matrix became plasticized and underwent thermoplastic flow (Inoue et al. 1993). All of this data shows that under heat and pressure, the lignin-hemicellulose matrix becomes thermoplastic and will deform to a different stable matrix. If the compressed matrix is cooled under pressure, the newly formed matrix has little memory of its precompressed form. Chawla and Sharma published results suggesting that during the heating process crosslinking of polysaccharide chains could occur (1972). They also suggested that some of the thermal degradation products recombined during heating. Norimoto (1994) and Dwianto et al. also suggested the formation of interlinkages between wood polymers during the heat treatment of wood. Boonstra et al. suggested that degradation products from the hemicelluloses and lignin for reactive intermediates that cross link during the curing stage Finally, it has been shown that heating wood under pressure resulted in an increase in cellulose crystallinity (Inoue et al. 1991). This could also have an influence on rewetting of the cell wall polymers after compression.

Based on the literature review, there are many possible chemical reactions taking place during steaming of wood fiber. Of interest to our research program is the loss of hemicelluloses (to decrease hygroscopicity and increase resistance to attack by micro-organisms) and to convert the released free sugars to furan intermediates (that can be converted to furan resins to increase internal bond strength) and to increase in dimensional stability of fiberboards. The effects of the treatments depend on many variables such as temperature, time of treatment, moisture content, chemical composition of the lignocellulosic, the addition of specific catalysts, and probably other factors which are not yet understood.

see:

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/pdf2002/rowel02a.pdf

CJ

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#17

Thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I expect the 1963 moisture vs Tg data for cellulose as it relates to wood is likely wrong but the rest was an interesting read.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#18

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

Jim Crammond

William,

In all I've read about bending wood for Windsor chairs, lignin starts becoming plastic at 150. The normal temperature range given for bending is between 150-180, and in no case would the temperature go above 212. The difference in the temperature may be attributed to the moisture. To be on the safe side, I think I would start your experiment at a lower temperature. I have scorched would with a heat gun when the temperature did not seem that high.

Jim

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#19

Wandering OT, as I tend to do...

John in NM

I'd completely forgotten that you are a patent attorney. I almost asked some general patent questions here last month, figuring Mark or another legal pro would know at least little bit.

Just goes to show you how broad the expertise is here, any subject and there is likely to be a woodworker who's day job covers that subject :D

I did eventually find my answers with google, but I now wish I'd just asked here :D

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#20

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

William Duffield

Thanks for the sanity check. That means CJ's numbers (for fibers, not wood) are way too high. I guess the fibers in cloth (cotton and linen, at least, most the rest in his list being synthetic polymers) are just cellulose, and the lignin glue gets "wiggly" at a much lower temperature than the cellulose fibers in the wood.

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#21

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Knowing exceedingly little about bending (with the caveat of having done some) it might be that the surface temp might need to be what CJ suggests in order to get the interior temp to the level you cite. Just a guess...

Re: Boxwood Four-Fold Rule Repair

#22

trial run

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

there is little enough information to suggest that trying it on some test piece will be prudent with the expectation that the optimum temperature for this case will have to be discovered.