New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT flooring finish type recommendations?

Posts

OT flooring finish type recommendations?

#1

OT flooring finish type recommendations?

John Aniano in central NJ

Hello all,

In a bit of a quandary - I'm going to be refinishing the wide pine flooring in our ca. 1765 living room. The last room in the house! We will be stripping the finish as we always have, using CitraStrip-type remover. Has always worked well for us. A light sanding with a random orbital sander is what I usually do next. These floors were once sanded in the 1960's. The problem is the finish. Over the years of doing our home's floors, The VOC levels for Minwax polyurethane for floors has constantly dropped and I find that the first coat of finish no longer penetrates the wood coat - it just sits there on top. Years ago, the final finish looked better and the color more even. Now with VOC's so low, the finish looks like, well polyurethane.

What are other options? I've used Southerland-Wells tung oil finish, but it takes many coats to build up a wear resistant layer. Poly takes maybe 3 coats and I'm done. How about spar varnish or other more traditional products. Or will they all have super low VOC's? This is a living room floor that will have a large area rug in the center of the floor. Do the commercially available products have higher VOC's?

Thanks in advance,

John

Re: OT flooring finish type recommendations?

#2

Thinner

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I always thin modern varnish of any kind. The solids content is just too high to brush and level well.

Practice on a test piece to get it right, but about 1 part solvent to 3 of varnish is a place to start. The more you thin the more a "close to the wood" look you will achieve.

Note: viscosity drops in a highly nonlinear way when adding thinner. That is, 1:3 dilution may reduce the viscosity by half, or more.

Re: OT flooring finish type recommendations?

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT flooring finish type recommendations?

Jesper, Denmark

Spar varnish is too soft and also requires many coats. I would looks for finishes intended for basketball courts and the like.

Re: OT flooring finish type recommendations?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

In my experience, only polyurethane will resist abrasion well enough for floors. I know a lot of people use Waterlox and other soft finishes, but they get worn-looking quickly. Harder pine species will hold up better than white pine, regardless of what finish you apply.

Ellis