New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Salt during glue up?

Posts

Salt during glue up?

#1

Salt during glue up?

Jerry Gibbs

Watched a show called "A Craftsman's Legacy". During the glue up of some small pieces, the worker sprinkled some salt on one of the pieces. He said the sharp salt crystals kept the pieces from moving while applying the clamps. Anybody else try this?

Re: Salt during glue up?

#2

Re: Salt during glue up?

Kees

Salt hasn't been in my repertoire yet, but I do use grit. I have a bucket full of 80 grit silicone carbide and just a few corns are enough to prevent the parts slipping around under the pressure of the clamps. My clamps always seem to want to move the parts, and sometimes that is quite iritating. I guess coarse salt works just as well, or sand. I have also used nails, clipped of just above the surface, but that is just a bit too much of a good thing.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Sounds risky

Ellis Walentine

I'd hate to run my smoothing plane over a grain of carbide. Salt would have the advantage of dissolving in the aqueous adhesive.

Ellis

Re: Salt during glue up?

#4

It does at that...

John in NM

Salt would be better than carbide in my view, but I would also be a little concerned about it's effect on glue strength. Maybe that is a non-issue.

I believe salt can also be used to gain open time with hide glue, that may be the context in which I got the impression that it weakens the glue slightly.

Honestly, I've not found this to be much of a problem since I started treating glue joints to a bit of a rub joint technique just before clamping - but then I've also been doing just one kind of glue up lately, and rubbing the parts together under hand pressure may not be feasible for every case where clamp induced slipping is a problem.

Come to think of it, I have some ground walnut shell around - used for gentle vibratory polishing. If the grains are small enough, that is something that could do the trick as joint grit and be at least a little less nasty on tooling.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#5

craigd

Re: Salt during glue up?

craigd

I do it often, I found the tip in The Glue Book by William Tandy Young.

Really helps when doing edge glue ups - prevents the boards from scooting around as you tighten the clamps.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#6

Re: Yeah, but the truth is...

TomD

The best way to do it with skiddy glues is to apply moderate clamping pressure for a period, then bottom out the clamps. The reason the boards skid is like hydroplaning with a car. There isn't enough time to move the water off the tires. In the glueing case, it takes a while for the squeeze out to get out. So the two stage method is very effective.

I have used the sand method, and the trimmed copper brad method, but I never bother since learning the overholtzer 2 stage method. Just a few minute or less is all it takes for the first stage.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#7

sand not salt, salt dumb idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Recall that glue like Titebond is a latex- mushy solvent swollen polymer balls suspended in water. The balls stay suspended because they have a surface charge on them so they repel one another. A latex is similar to an emulsion which is defined as liquid droplets suspended in water. An excellent way to break (cause to separate) an emulsion or latex is to add a salt. The ions from the dissolving salt cancel out the repulsion between the particles or droplets and the particles or droplets will clump together. One can be sure that the glue in the vicinity of the salt crystals will be useless.

But will it even work as advertised? Doubtful. The salt will dissolve and there will be no more particles to provided friction. Maybe the screwed up glue will provide friction.

Tiny brads with their heads cut off work much better, as I have illustrated in my discussion of cock beading drawers.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#8

craigd

Re: sand not salt, salt dumb idea

craigd

But will it even work as advertised? Doubtful. The salt will dissolve and there will be no more particles to provided friction. Maybe the screwed up glue will provide friction.

Experience says different, it works fine, as does "double" clamping, rub joints, double ended brads, etc. The salt stays crystalline plenty long enough (in PVA) to get things clamped. If glue becomes doo-doo where the salt is, you only a very slight sprinkle or two so it is not enough to cause any problems.

The nice thing about salt is you CAN adjust during clamping, can't do that with brads.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#9

Re: Sounds risky

Kees

I love living on the edge :D

We are really talking only a few grains, far enough from the edge to never become a problems for your smoothing plane. And I only use it for really critical glueups were nothing else is keeping stuff in position.

Tom's idea of gradually pulling up the clamps is a good one to try too. I guess the rub joint works in a similar way, but it might work better with hide glue. The slipery joint is really mostly a problem for white/yellow glue.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#10

Clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I imagined this technique being used in rare situations like applying a molding where one wants the position to be fixed while diddling with other issues in the application.

But apparently some are using it, or thinking of using it, for panel glue up? I would never advocate brads or anything else for panel assembly. There is no need.

If anyone has become dependent on salt to be able to glue up a panel I will not be able to convince them to abandon this approach. But, I would encourage anyone learning to not travel this path. Only a tiny fraction of panel gluers (I would have thought none) rely on this aid which has the real risk, if overdone, of screwing up the glue.

Skidding boards results from some combination of improper alignment of clamps, too much glue in the joint, or inexperienced clamp tightening procedure. Learn how to position the clamps straight, apply just enough glue to get a tiny amount of squeeze out and tighten the clamps a little at a time while adjusting board position and keeping boards in position to get the glue to make the initial tack. Once tacked, and this is quick with the proper amount of yellow glue, the clamps can be tightened with abandon.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#11

Slipery glue discussion and quick tack

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The slipery joint is really mostly a problem for white/yellow glue. "

Not if the optimum amount of yellow is used. Yellow glue makes dandy rub joints because it has fast tack, seconds. It has fast tack if the glue layer is thin.

To get fast tack the water from the glue line must migrate into the wood quickly. As the water leaves the glue the glue viscosity shoots up in a highly non-linear fashion. If one slathers on a thick layer of glue the wood becomes saturated before the joint closes and the water in the final glue line can't migrate into the wood quickly to establish the fast tack.

Re: Salt during glue up?

#12

Re: Slipery glue discussion and quick tack

TomD

I am sure it is all relative, but one needs enough glue to get the piece moving, and not so much that squeeze-out is a major problem. If one observes those guidlines the amount of water in there will not be a problem.

There are other slippery glues, like hide, and worst of all, epoxy. With epoxy the addition of microballons can help. This is basically like very small salt, and it may also be already present in, say, titebond. Microballons are used in a ton of stuff from post-it notes to make-up and explosives.