New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Some infill progress

Posts

Some infill progress

#1

Some infill progress

CJ in MPLS

I've been busy in tool room at the office after work this week and have a bit of progress to report on my infill project. I've lapped the bottom of the plane flat but for a few pinholes. I may leave them or do some additional lapping. I may be more eager to get after the additional lapping once the muscle stiffness fades.

I've milled the sides perpendicular to the sole and parallel to one another. Who knows whether the nominal mouth cast into the body of the plane is perpendicular to the sides, but I'm not too worried as there is plenty of meat to the casting and a bit of variation is no worry. I've ordered a 4" end mill to help me machine the bed of the plane to a uniform angle. Someone had mentioned a dovetail cutter for this, but I wasn't able to find one that was long enough that wasn't also quite expensive.

I used the disk sander in my own shop to smooth out the front and back of the plane. These surfaces were ground down by eye on the disc sander.

I started to grind the top edges of the plane down, but stopped when I realized that it would be helpful to have that top edge truly parallel to the sole when it comes time to mark out the mouth. Laying out the geometry of the mouth and placement of the pins for the lever cap will take a bit of thought. Anyone got any rules of thumb on locating the axis of rotation for the lever cap? Also, any thoughts on smoothing the interior of the casting in the mouth region?

Finally, I need to think about what to stuff this thing with. A long time ago I bought a chunk of lignum vitae that was intended for a turning blank or for an impulse buyer (me). It is the end cut from a 10" square beam from the look of it and is about 4" deep (measured along the grain). I may try to figure out how to get this wood to work for me.

CJ

Re: Some infill progress

#2

Re: Some infill progress

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi CJ

It is looking very good so far.

I do not have access to machinist tools for this kind of work, so my efforts (with grinders and Dremels) in the past have been quite crude by comparison. By contrast, dovetailing sides together is much simpler as there is no waste to excavate.

What I wanted to ask is whether you have a specific design in mind for the blade: single or double iron, and the bed angle? If you have not considered a double iron set up, I would recommend that you do. Setting a chipbreaker lifts the performance of all BD smoothers. Goind down this route, you can lower the bed angle and you shall need to increase the mouth size to accomodate for the chipbreaker blocking the passage for shavings.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Some infill progress

#3

Re: Some infill progress

CJ in MPLS

Hi Derek:

I purchased this casting long ago, back when the children were small, the student debt was large, and I lusted after infill planes. Since then I've butchered two chariot planes from SJBTCO and a shoulder plane from Bristol Designs. All are salvageable now that I have access to a milling machine, but they have taught me a thing or two about being careful. If you need a bronze chariot with a very large mouth, let me know.

The cap iron/blade set that I had tagged for the plane was a bit of salvage I picked up somewhere and frankly is more suitable for a bailey style plane. So the other day I splurged on a Hock infill cap iron/blade set for this project which made me very thankful that the cars are paid off. This is a parallel blade and so what I planned to do is have a colleague run up the geometry of the blade/cap iron in a CAD program at a 47.5 degree bedding angle and then try to figure out where the mouth is supposed to be located. I may post this drawing to see what the folks around here have in the way of advice.

CJ

Re: Some infill progress

#4

Re: Some infill progress

TomD

I think the number you are after is 1.3563. If you multiply the blade thickness by that number, that is the size of the mouth you would need, forward from the point of intersection with the ramp to have a mouth opening of zero. Assuming a bedding angle of 47.5 deg.

If you take the sin of the bedding angle, and divide 1 by it, you will get the mouth opening ratio. Multiply that by blade thickness, and you have mouth opening to tip of blade.

(1/sin of bedding angle) x blade thickness = mouth opening.

Of course, to get a shaving out of the plane, you need some additional opening, but how much is a mater of how the plane will be used.

Re: Some infill progress

#5

Re: Some infill progress

CJ in MPLS

Excellent! To have the answer be as logical as you describe is gratifying. Woodworking is full of answers and rules of thumb that seem to be dependent upon something such as humidity, whether the tree was happy, or what phase of the moon it is. I feared that the answer would be along these lines, with a digression on how this one other group of expert woodworkers disagreed by about 10%, but that in any case the woodworker should not deviate from the solution one whit, never mind the disagreement between the experts. ;)

Re: Some infill progress

#6

I remember lots of kids in math class...

John in NM

Saying "I'm never going to use this!"

Trig is one of the most useful branches of mathematics for woodworking :D

Nice and predictable too!

Changing gears here, why not solder a bit of sheet material to the bottom of your wide mouthed plane and recut the mouth/sole to get the opening you want? Soft solder would be plenty strong for this and probably super easy if you get that neat plumber's flux called "pre-tinning". Makes a sweat joint stupid simple to do.

Only problem you'd then have is probably needing oxy-acetylene to get the casting hot enough to solder (propane would do it eventually, but it would take a loooooong time! :D )

I'd probably solder on some mild steel to make it look like I intended this all along! :D

Re: Some infill progress

#7

Re: I remember lots of kids in math class...

CJ in MPLS

I am particularly challenged by simple math solutions to woodworking problems as I minored in math in college. Unfortunately I have a habit of complicating things a bit.

I plan to sweat new sole plates to the chariots and to the shoulder plane. the shoulder plane has a steel sole already that I need to remove before that can happen. I'll either need to procure or borrow a torch with enough oomph to heat the metal. I've done a very little bit of silver soldering in the past (jewelry and some tool stuff) and it is a fun technique. The gentleman that showed me how to do this and who provided the torch died a few years ago and I neglected to purchase the oxy-acetylene rig from his widow. I couldn't for the life of me imagine why I might need it and wanted his widow to get a few bucks for it (she kept trying to give me stuff).

Anyone know if MAPP gas can be used to brown up a roast without imparting a bad flavor. I've used propane to good effect, but those little butane torches are more cute than helpful with a good sized roast. ;)

Re: Some infill progress

#8

Re: I remember lots of kids in math class...

John in NM

Those butane torches are a good size for creme brulee though :D

The food got me thinking - you could pre-heat your parts in the oven, maybe when making pizza if you want to be efficient and there's no oil on the parts.

Then a propane torch would have a much shorter climb up to the fairly moderate temps required for soft soldering.

Re: Some infill progress

#9

Re: I remember lots of kids in math class...

TomD

I don't know if MAPP is in every kitchen on the Michelin trail, but in my use of it, it has a bad smell, and it leaves a messy deposit, though that is woking with flux, so it might be different in your app. You could easily melt down your plane body with propane, the key to greater efficiency is to use enough, that is where the T-Rex torches come in, you can use them with a BBQ cylinder. You also need to mix in enough oxygen.

Sadly the price on these puppies is up a little:

http://www.hybridburners.com/new-ordering.html

When I bought mine, I found that in Canada I couldn't really source the parts cheaper. The key part being the jet. Zoeller sells those if you want to make your own.

http://www.hybridburners.com/new-ordering.html

Re: Some infill progress

#10

Re: I remember lots of kids in math class...

CJ in MPLS

This is quickly moving towards the tapers at the edge of the bell curve. ;)

Propane it is. I do know some folks with oxy-acetylene setups that might also be willing to lend a hand.

Alternatively, we can enlist the facilities guys where I work. He once hooked up a hose to a large LP tank on his home farm, opened the valve and lit the gas flying from the hose to fashion a flame thrower of sorts. In his defense he was 15, he did survive, and more importantly, his father didn't find out.

Re: Some infill progress

#11

Re: I remember lots of kids in math class...

TomD

I made lot of flame throwers as a kid, normally methylated spirits out of bug sprayers. Parents were fully aware, too late to halt the process. I also tried to make gun powder, and smoke bombs. I guess some of these things are controlled today.

OXY ACET is much much hotter, and a far better choice for soldering. Control is like a sharp tool with these things, might seem more dangerous, but with greater heat, you can concentrate it more precisely.

If what you are planing to do is fashion a tiny piece that can be dropped into a milled out area, then soldered there, if you can get tight fits, silver solder tape is a good way to go. You insert it in the fluxed gap, and when the heat hits the high point the tape melts and everything is bonded together. This reduces the knowledge needed to flow the solder across the repair, and as a result will probably reduce significantly the heat you require, or the need to apply heat precisely.

http://www.brownells.com/gunsmith-tools-supplies/general-gunsmith-tools/solders-flux/silvaloy-355-silver-solder-prod584.aspx

I found some much cheaper on ebay, but it had cadmium in it, however for the one or two times I might ever use it, I don't have to worry about that. Currently don't see that offer on ebay.

By the way, silver solder, the hard stuff, is technically braze, it has 45% silver or more, not the 5% in soft silver solder.

Re: Some infill progress

#12

Re: I remember lots of kids in math class...

CJ in MPLS

If I recall correctly, the process involves "tinning" the steel sole plate that is to be applied to the bronze casting, whereafter the casting is heated until the silver solder braze melts to form the connection. A lot of heat will be required, but hopefully not flamethrower levels. ;)

Re: Some infill progress

#13

Two kinds of silver solder

John in NM

There is soft solder, that melts around 750 F, what is used for electronics (lead-tin solder) and plumbing (silver solder mostly tin with a bit of silver). This is what I was suggesting you use, because though it is not especially strong it should be more than adequate for anything involving planes. In retrospect however, I remember having a lot of trouble soldering to bronze - the alloy additives can cause problems with getting the solder to whet the surface (just a guess).

Then there is hard solder. Melts at around 1100 F or more. This mostly requires something hotter and more focused than a propane torch. I've hard soldered small stuff with a propane torch but it can be fairly difficult to do. Hard soldering is also called silver brazing because it is a similar process. I would say it is overkill for anything you want to do with a plane of the type you're working on, but that's just my opinion - it may well be an incorrect one.

Incidentally, if you want to soft solder a whole sole plate on a plane, look for tinning flux - I like Oatey 95 rather than the water soluble stuff (2095 I think it is). Both will work but the old style plumbers flux is easier to not overheat, at least for me. Nokorode markets similar products but I've never tried them.

Of course, depending on the bronze alloy used for the casting this may all be moot. I doubt it though - SJBT would not likely use an unsolderable bronze - stuff I had trouble with was scrap and probably a piece of bearing bronze.