New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

The science of sharp... *LINK*

Posts

The science of sharp... *LINK*

#1

The science of sharp... *LINK*

Lars Parrington

... is a new-ish blog where the author is using an electron microscope to objectively determine the results of various sharpening processes. As it is just getting started, so there's not tons of info there yet, but it is definitely worth checking out already. Note that the focus is on shaving, rather than woodworking.


https://scienceofsharp.wordpress.com/

Re: The science of sharp... *LINK*

#2

I wish the author was a woodworker

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The ability to make these images would answer a lot of questions about dulling.

Re: The science of sharp... *LINK*

#3

Re: I wish the author was a woodworker

TomD

Didn't LV do all this already. Having personal access would be a plus for sure.

Re: The science of sharp... *LINK*

#4

Re: Razors are a lot like tools...

david weaver

...in that information like that shown in the page is good for a beginner and wows beginners with pictures of this or that.

A sharp tool is a dull razor, to the point of being unusable, the coddling of the edge of a razor (stropping daily and avoiding damage) is something that takes some experience, as does the shaving.

Point being the page provides interesting information for a beginner, but for someone with experience, the score about what makes for a comfortable shave (which is always going to include maintaining and making a sharp edge) was settled long ago.

The virtue of a razor is that the wear or damage to an edge is extremely slow. The honing that is shown in those pictures happens for me about twice per year, and a vintage linen and good horse leather solve anything the hone doesn't.

Re: The science of sharp... *LINK*

#5

Lars, I appreciated the gift of the link

woodburnbob

The whole site at the end of the link is full of a fresh perspective and elegant graphics. I especially like the section titled "What is a burr -- Part 2".

I understand this statement defines me as a "beginner", a boob and a misfit. But I've always been and always will be a beginner, a boob and a misfit, so no great loss in self-esteem.

Re: The science of sharp... *LINK*

#6

Re: Lars, I appreciated the gift of the link

david weaver

Aside from a very few, the rest of us are beginners, too!

Beginners with some experience, but at least I am still a beginner. Any time I do a complicated glue up, I'm reminded of that.

A newbie these days may never learn about a burr. I didn't know much about them when I used shapton stones, so little of a burr is left after the finish stone that I couldn't ever figure out why everyone talked about removing the wire edge.