New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

Posts

PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#1

PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

William Duffield

By now, I think you know I'm a fan of PEC machinist squares, from Harry Epstein, for their accuracy and their very reasonable prices.

Last night, however, I experienced a problem that I have seen reported a couple of times on the woodworking forums. I was working in a very cold shop (high 30s Faranheit) in a heavy coat, and my coat sleeve managed to brush my 6" double square off the bench and onto the concrete floor. The ping when it hit was at a higher pitch than I wanted to hear, and the blade and head were laying separately on the floor. The end of the blade clamp, which was obviously more brittle than optimum for the application, had snapped off.

Harry Epstein carries replacements and I immediately ordered one. There is a link to the square itself at the bottom of the page in the link below.

http://store.harryepstein.com/cp/ProductsEngineering/SQUARE-PIN-6.html

Not unexpectedly, shipping was more than the cost of the blade screw assembly. Curiously, while Harry Epstein notes that the squares themselves are made in the USA, the replacement clamps are labeled "import."

When the new one arrives (being practical, I ordered two so I would have a backup) I would like to lessen the chance that it meets a similar fate. (No, I don't think a wooden shop floor is in the near future.) I need some advise, because I don't know much metallurgy. I know that some steel can be tempered to increase its toughness and decrease brittleness, but how do I figure out how long to cook it in the oven and at what temperature? Do I need to leave it in the oven after I've turned it off, to cool slowly? Should I wrap it in foil? Do I need to plunge it through the heart of an enemy?

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#2

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

david weaver

We don't know what the original one is made of. It may be a piece of casted material, or it may be overhardened steel.

If you have a file on hand, can you file the original one in some rounded area and see how easily the file digs in? If the file skates off, then you could probably temper it to dark brown temper and hope for the best.

If it's hardened to a specific level, there may be a reason that it's at that level (for long-term accuracy, etc), and you risk having to buy another.

Order time may have been a good time to get two of them, one to experiment and a second as a backup.

Anyway, if the thing files easily, I doubt there's anything you can do for it other than to try to harden it and then I would torch it until it's spring temper (purple/blue) and then quench it. That's complete guess work to do something like that, though - you can also try to harden it (the broken one) and then spark test it on a grinder wheel to see if it looks like high carbon steel.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#3

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

TomD

Examine the snapped one, you can usually tell at a break what it is but if in doubt:

http://www.shopfloortalk.com/forums/showthread.php?p=187220

Or call the maker

If it is steel and not cast, and you think it might be too hard. Put the broken one in the oven at 400 for an hour, and see if it files less hard. Sometime you can put something in with already in process baking, wrap in foil tightly. Also, it needs to be dead clean, no oil, or paint, etc...

In general I would get a pad on the floor, for your legs if nothing else, and try not to knock it off.

I use wood squares, they are just as accurate, and they are not usually damaged by a fall. I have a machinist square that has made the trip a few times, and it just got dings I could file out.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#4

I don't know about steel problems, BUT

Bruce, a MN Galoot

your shop is not "very cold." Mine is very cold, -3F. In yours at that temp, I can work with bare hands. Hah!

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#5

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

AlanWS

It's possible the pin is designed to break in order to protect the head from damage in a fall. If that's the case, you probably don't want to make it stronger.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#6

craigd

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

craigd

I think you made the best choice by buying replacements; the part isn't steel, my guess is cast zinc; it isn't repairable. I don't know if the Starrett/Lufkin/etc part will fit, that might something to check if you find something at the flea market. If you have access to a lathe & mill, it looks like a easy part to make.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#7

Re: An alternative for a cheap square..

david weaver

..I, too have the PEC square that you're talking about. Mine is a second and it has a slight alignment issue that doesn't make it out of square, but it makes the square not as smooth as one would like.

I followed george's advice sort of. He always says "if you want the square to be square indefinitely, get one with a hardened head". I set up a search on ebay for "hardened combination square" and after you wade through the ones where people think the square is hardened because the rule says that on it, you will find some older defunct names (like lufkin) with hardened heads for cheap enough that you can take two shots if you need to to find one square.

(mitutoyo and starrett hardened squares, even used, still sell for high $$ amounts).

The lufkin square I found for $25 is more square and much smoother than the PEC square I got, and it's more likely to stay that way because of the hardened head.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#8

craigd

Re: An alternative for a cheap square.. *LINK*

craigd

I'm not so sure (about hardened heads although mine is dense); I have an old Lufkin that is wonderfully smooth but I attribute that to it well used and worn in.

The old, but nicer [condition] Starretts aren't as smooth. The old, very nice condition Union also feels wonderful. BTW, Starrett uses a nice brass spring under the nut.

Also, the heads on combo square are made to be adjustable, ie it is expected they will go out of adjustment after a lot of use. There are two nibs cast in the head that can be filed to square it up.


How to square an adjustable square

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#9

Re: An alternative for a cheap square..

david weaver

Thanks for the illustration on squaring a cast head.

I've got two old starretts (they do not have hardened heads), and like you mention, they are not very smooth. I think one of them was thrown together from parts by a dealer, though - it doesn't lock up correctly at all with the rule that came with it, so I took it apart and bought another one.

The old hardened head lufkin is dreamy, though.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#10

Re: Thanks, Everyone!

William Duffield

Aha! That's why the broken surface is so sparkly! I should have guessed. Yes, it appears to be zinc or something similar, like pot metal. It cuts very easily with a file.

As AlanWS suggests, it looks like PEC did their homework, and made the cheapest part the weakest link, so that the more expensive parts would not be damaged in cases like this.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#11

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

William Duffield

I have pads for the floor, around the bench, but I had filled the bench with parts and tools for the project I'm working on and had moved over to the table saw for a simple layout. I need to move the TS around depending on whether I'm cross cutting or ripping long stock, so there aren't foot mats at the table saw. Also, the pads I use are open, and the holes are larger than the width of a rule. The holes do help with limiting the bouncing and therefore the search time for dropped parts.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#12

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

William Duffield

No, the Starretr clamp is not interchangeable with the PEC clamp. I checked that a while back when someone had a problem with a lost Starrett clamp.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#13

The weakest link

Bob Hackett

As you guessed the part that locks the square down also serves as a shear pin to protect all those more expensive parts.

Another reason that this part is not made of hardened steel is that if it were it would effectively wear the most expensive part on the assembly, the scale itself. The piece your`re replacing has always been the sacrificial piece as it`s both relatively cheap to produce and easy to replace.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#14

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

TomD

As I say, I have dropped mine. :) If you haven't tried wood, it is worth the try, it will surprise you. It was one of the first joinery projects I built, back in the 70s.

Re: PEC Square Accident, Tempering Steel ?

#15

Buy a floor mat (Re: PEC Square Accident)

Alex Grigoriev

Better for your tools and for your feet, too.