New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Hollows and Rounds

Posts

Hollows and Rounds

#1

Hollows and Rounds

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Last summer I read in Christopher Schwarz's book "The Anarchist's Tool Chest" about Hollows and Rounds. I've been reading various things and thinking about getting a pair of #4 and #6. A user pair. Something I can learn with, learn to sharpen and so on.

I see them on eBay occasionally for around $25 to $35 on up for a matched pair. Is that reasonable for a user grade matched pair that claims to be in 'good condition'?

Any other sites you'd suggest? Advice?

Thank you.

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#2

Re: Hollows and Rounds

david weaver

I think so, it's probably the going rate. Compare what a made pair is to that.

Probably 10 years ago, they cost half as much.

Good wedge, good clean iron (that won't take too much to prepare), not too much wear and no damage of note, think that's a decent price.

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#3

Re: Hollows and Rounds

William Duffield

Beyond what David identifies, you have to worry about the plane body being warped, usually due to the wedge having been left set and the plane then left to set the warp as the plane expands and contracts with the seasons over several years after it had been retired. Blades can be reground and sharpened, wedges can be refitted, boxing can be reglued or replaced, but a warped body won't cut a straight moulding and is extremely difficult, if not impossible, to correct.

Your sticking board is extremely unlikely to match the curve of any individual warped plane.

http://musingsfrombigpink.blogspot.com/

Matt Bickford's book, Mouldings in Practice, from Lost Are Press, is an invaluable resource. He has a DVD out as well, from Lie-Nielsen, but they misspelled mouldings :D . I haven't seen it.

In your area is another expert on moulding planes, Todd Herrli. If you can find a woodworking organization which is hosting a lecture by him, try to get a seat, or a ticket, or an invitation to attend.

http://www.todherrli.com/

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#4

Re: Hollows and Rounds

joe in a Cleveland suburb

You guys both mentioned things I didn't know or think of. Thank you.

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#5

Re: Hollows and Rounds

don stephan

An Ebay seller may have the best intentions and simply not know how to evaluate the condition of an item for sale. And sometimes the seller's intentions are . . . Of course, sometimes there are great bargains on Ebay. Buyer be ware.

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#6

Re: Hollows and Rounds

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I agree Don. That's why sometimes I ask for opinions here. Maybe somebody would suggest a trusted seller or a site they would recommend.

I personally don't like buying things on eBay. You just never know what is going to show up at the door.

I recently won a bid for a Millers Falls eggbeater drill. It wasn't exactly like what I thought it would be. I'm a little disappointed in what I received...

Like you say, buyer beware.

Thanks.

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#7

Re: Hollows and Rounds

TomD

It is extremely easy and fast to make hollows and rounds, but it is not as cheap as buying second hand ones if you can find good ones. You can make the plane in about 45 minutes, give or take, the blade is faster but few people have the gear, so it tends to be more painful if you don't at a minimum have some kind of power grinder.

Making reproductions ones isn't all that difficult with the excellent DVDs we have, but to do it correctly requires a wide range of materials tools and techniques, all pretty easy, just extensive.

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#8

Re: Hollows and Rounds *LINK*

Hank Knight

Joe,

You might want to subscribe to Jim Bodie's Old Tool List. He sells every imaginable kind of tool, and hollows and rounds appear on the list frequently, both pairs and sets. I wouldn't call his prices bargains. I would characterize them as being a little on the high side of "fair," but he has lots of stuff for sale, things that are hard to find in the wild. I bought a half set of harlequins from him a year or so ago and have been pleased with them. He emails his list daily to subscribers. The subscription is free. All you have to do is sign up to receive it.

Hank


Jim Bodie's Old Tool List

Re: Hollows and Rounds

#9

Re: Hollows and Rounds

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Signed up. Thank you Hank.