New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Setting a hand saw

Posts

Setting a hand saw

#1

Setting a hand saw

Gary B.

Hello,

I recently "Rescued" a Diston D-23 26" saw from an antique shop. It was quite rusty, and in rough shape, but the blade was straight and the teeth intact. I got it home, and tried cross cutting a 2x4. It did it, but it was obviously in need of some sharpening. I need a rip saw, so I proceeded to sharpen the 8 point saw as a rip saw. When I was done, it cut really well.

OK, I thought, now it's time to clean this thing up. So, I removed the handle, and proceeded to scrap most of the rust off with a razor, then worked up the grits with wet/dry paper and wd-40 from 220 up to 1000 grit. I found the diston etch in the process. Spent some time refinishing the handle and cleaning up the split nuts and medallion. Put it all back together and she looks real nice now...

But she won't cut worth a dang. first few strokes are good, but as it gets buried she binds...So, I get out my old taintors (no7?) saw set, which I've never used, and proceeded to set each alternating tooth down once side, then back down the other side of the blade. Now, after another test cut, I see that he blade is no longer cutting straight, but "curving" to the left as I cut.

The thing is, I'm not sure the saw setting tool is working right. I can't even see the set with any anvil setting. It's almost like the tool is missing some other part to hold against the blade further away from the teeth to keep it straight. I'll try and post some pictures of the saw set when I get home, but I'm open to advice. Should I just purchase a new saw set?

Thanks!

Re: Setting a hand saw

#2

Ellis Walentine

Some advice

Ellis Walentine

Here's what Charles Johnson's Saw Dictionary has to say about using the Taintor set...


I hope this is helpful. Visit the WoodCentral store if you want a copy of the book...

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine

Re: Setting a hand saw

#3

Re: Setting a hand saw

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Gary,

I've got a few of the Taintors saw sets and they do seem to be a bit "dodgy" or at the very least sloppy. The moving parts sort of slide against each other instead of just pivoting. Maybe it is just wear, or it might be how they were made. Of the the three that I have, I would only trust one to do any decent work. I prefer my Stanley 42X (?) and it works just fine. Much more positive and there is a tactile feedback from the Stanley tool that the Taintor simply does not have, at least of the Taintors I own.

Do follow Ellis's suggestion and get the wonderful little pamphlet by Mr. Johnson and support WC at the same time. A good read!

http://www.woodcentral.com/store.php

John

Re: Setting a hand saw

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Setting a hand saw

Jesper, Denmark

Maybe a dumb question:

Are you supposed to set the teeth first, file second or?

Re: Setting a hand saw

#5

Re: Setting a hand saw

Gary B.

Thank you Gentlemen,

I've looked at my saw set again, and decided on buying a (hopefully) better one from highland woodworking tomorrow. I've recently moved to the Atlanta area, and I've been itching to check out the store in person anyways. I've been watching Paul Sellers on youtube, and he mentions that you really only need a fine saw set, as it will do all the finer teeth, as well as the coarser teeth. I'm interested in this, as I have a few back saws that are 14 tpi. I'd appreciate any thoughts on this...

Thanks again, and I'll definitely be looking into purchasing that book you mentioned!

Re: Setting a hand saw

#6

Re: Setting a hand saw *LINK*

John Aniano in central NJ

Hello all,

I found this pamphlet online that describes the Taintor saw sets and their use. Lots of good general info on saw sharpening and setting. Worth a look!

John


http://toolemera.com/pampdf/taintorsawsetPAM.pdf

Re: Setting a hand saw

#7

Re: Setting a hand saw

Steve Voigt

Thanks for posting this, John. I have a Taintor positive no.7 and it's not bad. I do prefer the Eclipse 77.

Re: Setting a hand saw

#8

Re: Setting a hand saw

Gary B.

Thanks everyone for your help. I was able to figure out what is going on based on the information provided in this thread. When I took apart my Taintors No. 7, I realized that the anvil was beat up pretty bad. In fact, on all but the "10" setting, there was VERY little of a secondary bevel that would actually apply the set. I put it back together, and using the "10" setting, got a bit more set then I'd like, so I used the 2 hammer technique to shrink it. It now cuts well enough to be called a user. I'd like to share some photos of the finished project if anyone is interested. How can I attach them on this thread?

Re: Setting a hand saw

#9

Re: Setting a hand saw posting photos *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Gary,

here's a link to one of the WC FAQs about attaching photo's to posts.

hope it helps

Bob in NJ


http://www.woodcentral.com/faq/#photoupload

Re: Setting a hand saw

#10

Re: This is normal, stone the tooth sides

Rum

Happened to every saw I've ever tried to set and more than a couple I just sharpened. Certainly not to say there aren't filers who don't need to stone the sides of the teeth after filing/setting but I sure ain't one.

Anyway what's happening is that the teeth are a bit overset on the left side (the side it pulls towards). What you don't want to do is try to bend them back cause you'll just break them and it's not an accurate way to handle the problem anyway.

The easy way to handle this is to just lay the saw flat, take a medium stone and take two to the light strokes down the overset side. Try the saw again and repeat if necessary.

I usually stone both sides of the saw one or two strokes to knock off the burr after filing just as a normal course of action.

Re: Setting a hand saw

#11

Re: Setting a hand saw

TomD

Jesper, joint, file, set. In the begining you file first because the tooth wouldn't exist to set. When sharpening you could have wear that given that the tooth is part of the equation during setting, would not be the same as a nearby one if you set it first, then filed it.

Re: Setting a hand saw

#12

Re: Saw sharpening Primer *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

I've found the document in this link to be very helpful for learning to sharpen hand saws.

Bob in NJ


http://www.vintagesaws.com/library/primer/sharp.html

Re: Setting a hand saw

#14

Sorry for the Delay Everyone, here are the Pics!

Gary B.

Hello All,

It's been a bit hectic lately, and I'm finally getting around to posting these pictures. Please see attached! This is my first real saw restoration, and I'm pretty pleased with the result. The photos don't do it justice, but after scraping the finish off the handle, it was amazing watching the bare wood (like a hard maple color) turn into a deep rich color it is now. I believe it's Apple.

Thanks to all for the advice given during this. My next resto project is an old Ohio #6 foreplane that is in REALLY bad shape....electrolysis is in it's future!