New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Derek--handle profiles..

Posts

Derek--handle profiles..

#1

Derek--handle profiles..

david weaver

I figured that the angle on my prior photo might have been a bit misleading, my handles are forward leaning a little more than those pictures suggest. So I took some pictures, and here are my thoughts about these things.

A comparison picture to start, the LV most forward-tilted handle compared to my try plane. I kind of wish there was a little more bottom to the LV handle, even though this is the most tilted one, I'd like one that has more angle yet, but I haven't yet made one like that to try. The location of the mouth may make things a little different for the LV plane.


You'll notice on the wood plane handles the handle comes straight up out of the plane and then the amount of tilt is taken care of by cutting the top curve further forward, rather than necessarily making a handle that is cut leaning forward from top to bottom. This may be a bit different for wooden planes because of how far above the mouth the handle is, not sure.

The handle on my jack (this plane is mostly a copy of a matheisen closed handle jack). This handle is way on the back of the plane, and I could've cut the top a bit more in like the original. Not unpleasant, but not quite as good.


The handle on a jt brown jointer (something from the early 1800s). I modified this pattern a little bit to make my three bench planes.


Griffiths of norwich.


My favorite stanley 4:


The stanley compared to the LV (the LV looks similar to the stanley, but I think the mouth location and the way the top curve is chased way up to the top makes it feel more upright):


The mathiesen jack. Radical, but quite comfortable. Very downward leaning, but the handle is way on the back of the plane and might be downward leaning like that to compensate. I may move the top in on mine a little more, the mathiesen feels a bit more like you're walking with it, mine feels more like you're pushing it from behind and it's got to be in front of you a little more. A small difference visually, but really does have an effect:


An old infill I made, the first full sized infill. I have two more infills I'd like to make, but I don't know when I ever will. I don't actually use them, but they do work wonderfully. Keep the wax handy. (I did not know george when I made this plane, and the aesthetics show it. A shame. It would've taken no more work to make a more attactive plane, and this billet of wood was an ULTRA rare piece of vintage bois de rose. A comfortable handle to use nonetheless, and very much out at the bottom and in at the top, more so than the wooden handles.


And an 18" panel infill spiers kit. This handle was poorly cut, this plane is from the near death era of shepherd kits and they did a poor job cutting the mortise. When I got it fit, the handle was left a bit too upright. A very authoritative plane, made from an OK plane into a killer with proper use of the double iron (I didn't know how to use one when I made it, so the mouth is only 9 thousandths on this plane - even with a mouth at that, at common pitch, it still tore out enough to effect the smoothness of the plane in the cut, but not enough to make a surface disaster. It goes any direction with the cap iron and stays smooth). The upright handle encourages you to keep it out in front of you. Also a keep the wax handy plane at just shy of 9 pounds. I'd have preferred it with a more conventional angle, even though such a thing would encourage more downward force. Wax mitigates the effect of that.


Re: Derek--handle profiles..

#2

Re: One might notice the broken LV plane handle..

david weaver

..I dropped it. :\

Not on purpose, but doing so proved what is said about LV planes. I had to file a small burr off of the front of the plane and glue the handle, back in business.

For what it's worth, my very first jointer, I dropped that, too - very luck that it landed on the front and only dented it, and then ran my try plane into something when I was making it.

In 9 years, I never dropped a valuable plane, and then in a span of weeks, I dropped two.

I have a lot of thoughts about handles, and I have a lot more planes I'd like to build. I don't know if I'll get them firmed out or not, it's as if you need to know what works well on each plane design, and it would need to be in a library.

We know I am an amateur making planes, not a pro, so there is no reason I should be that uptight. I want the aspects of each of these planes to be just right, though, and your article may illuminate these things, but a slip up in the location of the mouth vs the handle and handle lean, etc, and what could be a fantastic plane to use becomes ho hum. All of the locations combined with the handle style and angle is a place where random modifications and guesses at aspects without having something proper at hand is not the way to go.

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

#3

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks David. This is all very useful.

My article is still in the collating stage as I struggle for time - reports and more reports to complete before Christmas and before we head off for about 10 days to family in Sydney and Melbourne.

As you may know, I have a strong interest in tool design, particularly ergonomics. An opportunity arose recently with the development of the Veritas Custom Planes: mixing up the plane handles, frog angles, and use of chipbreaker. I have both a jointer and a smoother.

This article is not a review, although it will focus on the qualities of these planes. It occurred to me that the vertical handle of the Veritas is something I have gone back-and-forth with for so many years. I think I have now sussed out what this is about, and decided to write about it. I realised that many woodworkers often talk about the way they hold a plane .... and then do something different when using the plane. I have been examining Youtube videos and DVDs of notable woodies - including one of you! - and it is there to be seen.

There is a continuation (but not a finalisation) of the theme in the last 4 articles here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Commentary/Index.html

More later :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

#4

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

david weaver

Well, if it helps for the article, I did do some copying of older planes to some extent (that goes without saying), but my try and jointer plane are as comfortable to use as any plane I've ever used of any type.

The jack is a bit odd, but that's because the handle is literally on the back. It isn't by any means uncomfortable, just unusual.

I could be included with the group of folks who thinks that there is nothing more comfortable on the market in wooden planes than the early 19th century bench planes (not razee) and the stanley metal planes pre wwII (i actually prefer stanley planes from the sweetheart era through and slightly past WWII to the older planes).

My bench height is standard.

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

#5

Re: Thought on angles

david weaver

Derek, I only read the last of your suppositions on your web page, but I'll read all of them once your final capper post comes out to seal the deal.

I went back and looked at the video where I was trying my first bench plane, and you can see that I push the plane straight out from my arm. I am not pushing down on it or any such thing.

That led me to consider what a straight line would look like, like a flashlight, if I placed it in my neutral hand at the table, and I think some folks would assume that at a neutral wrist position, the flashlight would be nearly vertical. In this case, it's not. See the attached picture.


The only difference between this flashlight and my plane handles (which are very similar to those on vintage planes that I found comfortable to use - it's not by chance that mine are comfortable as I had the chance to try them on similar platforms) is the bulge that goes into the middle of the hand.

The angle of the picture of my hand may look funny because it was taken from my seated position, but I would assume that it was somewhere around 65 or 70 degrees.

My try plane handle is one that I prefer, I have no convenient way to measure the angle right now.

These are not items I would mix and match on a lower plane, but as on the stanley plane the profile of the handle is pretty similar to what it is on my try plane.

I also tried the type that george described, which is a short offset handle, on my panel raiser. I haven't yet gotten comfortable with that. I understand the principle of not closing the hand and allowing the bottom two fingers to drape over the side of the plane, but I still have some hand fatigue using it that I don't have using my planes (nor a stanley plane). It's probably due to the urge to grip the plane when lifting it and moving it back to start another cut.

The only handle that put my wrists in pain thus far has been the LV bus, and the effect of that handle would've been in my seated position in the photo above to move my wrist until the flashlight was more upright. That is not a neutral wrist position, but one where it is bent back. It may be more neutral at a height higher than waist height or wherever my bench is, but it was very painful to use the plane heavily (it actually felt like a bruise at my wrist) and I sold it rather than modify it.

The new LV planes are more comfortable than the BU planes, but the positioning of the mouth is a little different for someone like me who is used to vintage plane and stanley plane proportions). I want to try a handle that is more forward leaning and has more of a hump in my palm, but I haven't gotten to it yet. The curiosity will be whether or not the things that I don't prefer about that handle are due to the handle or due to the positioning of the mouth (further back).

Move it back a little more yet (like a continental smoother) and then I am entirely comfortable with those, too, but I consider those a two handled plane where significant force is provided by the front hand in use.

I will make a continental smoother (it is a format that I prefer to a coffin smoother, now having made three of those also) as soon as I deal out a few try planes to friends.

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

#6

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I could be included with the group of folks who thinks that there is nothing more comfortable on the market in wooden planes than the early 19th century bench planes (not razee) and the stanley metal planes pre wwII (i actually prefer stanley planes from the sweetheart era through and slightly past WWII to the older planes).

David, you are going need to qualify these comments:

1. what type of wooden plane - handled or unhandled, long or short?

2. what is it about the Stanley handle you like, and again is this a long or short plane?

Incidentally, I've come to the conclusion that the height of the bench as an effect on planing is quite misleading in how it affects planing. That is for another time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

#7

Re: Derek--handle profiles..

david weaver

Derek - jack plane to jointer for the vintage handle profile, and anything from smoother to jointer for stanley.

I suppose that what I like about the stanley is that it is not much different than the handle profile I posted with my try plane. I like the features of the griffiths of norwich handle that is one of the old ones I pictured, and the JT brown handle. I think there are some visual shortcomings of the griffiths handle, but that the angle is comfortable, and as george described it, on the jt brown, the cut in the top for the web if your hand is pushed far up and the hump is less exaggerated.

So I guess I like a combination of those two things. Stanley handles are almost identical.

I had never thought about why until yesterday, but the reason is comfort - and yesterday is the reason I tried to figure out why that type of handle gives me nothing but fatigue (no soreness and no rub on the hand anywhere). Thus, the picture a post below of the flashlight in hand at neutral wrist position. If my hand is lying relaxed on a table and I don't flex my wrist at all from neutral, that is what's created.

The only thing that I need beyond that flashlight type grip is something that puts a hump right in the middle of my palm (as a stanley handle does) so that I don't get a rub at the bottom and top of my hand.

Coffin smoothers can be difficult if you let your hand ride up into the same position, you run into the back of the iron a little bit. I saw a summary not long ago of someone who had rounded the back side of their iron because they were annoyed with this.

Continental smoothers, those that do have a saddle at the top (which is a more recent thing) almost duplicate the stanley profile by having the body of the plane into the middle of the palm and the web of the hand goes onto the saddle that is tucked in like the curve at the top of a stanley handle. The position of the mouth invites the use of the front horn with the opposite hand a little more. I don't find the older continental smoothers without the top saddle quite as comfortable, the butt of the plane is the only thing you have to grab and it digs into the middle of your hand when it is the only thing.

I'm not sure about bench height, either, as when we joint boards, they are jointed in the vise often at a height as high or higher than a high bench top and I haven't noticed a shortcoming with a traditional handle doing that work.