New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Japanese sawyers

Posts

Japanese sawyers

#1

Japanese sawyers

TomD

Just some ramdom thoughts. I always wanted one of those whale shaped saws the Japanese Sawyers use. Before Ebay. decades went by before I found what I wanted. I find it hard to figure how they balance those trunks at an angle to make their cuts. It isn't easy to do with one person, or at all. Several attempts have not worked out so well. Then after this summer I was wondering whether what inspired them was trees knocked over in wind storms. We got a lot of those over the summer due to the wind storm that hit us. I didn't think of it till now, but I guess I will take a saw down with me when I go this summer. Many of the trees are at a perfect angle.

Has anyone come across a good youtube video of a Japanese sawyer at work. Possibly even a vintage video. I don't expect to be able to get very far, but have saw, will tackle.

Re: Japanese sawyers

#2

Re: Japanese sawyers

david weaver

There was a video online that I cannot find now that showed a very backward looking japanese young man doing what was gruesome manual labor slabbing a large log. I can't remember if there was someone on the other side of him doing the same thing, but I would assume that in order to do tidy work, making it a two man job would be better.

In the case of the video, the user was pulling the saw near perfectly perpendicular to the log and making slow progress (but the log was very large).

I'd assume after watching it that the guy doing the work had done the same thing for probably millions of strokes, and the rest of us would have little chance of duplicating the effort.

If your saw is clean and fresh and sharp, you might have a chance, but a pit saw and a buddy would probably yield a better chance of measurable progress and cutting to a line.

I'll be interested if anyone can find the video I'm referring to.

(I see drawings of men sawing from over a log, but the video I saw was a man sitting next to the log with the saw blade parallel to the ground.)

Stanley Covington sent me what is probably the nicest japanese saw I will ever use, a rip saw that was halfway between a maebiki and a kataba, but at near four figures I couldn't justify having the maker make one for me. I ripped with it standing over the board - I did so relatively incompetently, it would take a day or two to get better mechanics and put a setup together that didn't allow the board being ripped to move. Sawing from over a log puts a lot of strain on your hamstrings and through I probably only cut a total of feet with this saw, and it was a beautiful saw, I was stiff from knee to waist the next day. I wouldn't want to go out and cut logs and be in this position without working up to it.

On this first full cut, I couldn't stay on the line with the saw, but not much experience would've solved that.

Pardon the pajama pants. This was part of something where I wanted to find an affordable japanese saw that could cut with a rip saw that I have sharpened, and I couldn't get this saw even after a few more cuts to cut with the same speed. Stan did say that the japanese pros who used it could cut faster with it than they could with a western saw.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eof0u9k5KQ8&list=UUswplWFmxpdxvepK7zDpcow

Re: Japanese sawyers

#3

Re: Japanese sawyers

wilbur

Here are some pictures and videos of a maebiki being used.

http://youtu.be/0X2t6G6RFjM

http://youtu.be/L0sQYIkarJM

http://youtu.be/aydKaMRjrow

http://giantcypress.net/post/85515296226/woodworker-using-a-maebiki-to-make-a-rip-cut-in-a

http://giantcypress.net/post/14162525018/another-japanese-sawyer-who-actually-knows-what

http://giantcypress.net/post/13964041659/and-here-are-two-woodworkers-that-actually-know

Not exactly a maebiki, but probably worth taking a note of:

http://giantcypress.net/post/52130765608/toshio-odate-ripping-a-board-hell-have-an

And a probably a bad example:

http://giantcypress.net/post/13917086457/heres-a-short-clip-of-me-trying-to-use-the

Re: Japanese sawyers

#4

Re: The video you call "two"..

david weaver

..that video shows the technique I saw on the vintage video. Though the guy in the vintage video was going faster, it doesn't look like entirely unpleasant work, just not fast developing.

(the guy cutting the small piece in the clamp with a saw that aggressive is nuts!! his cat agrees, and vacates!)

I have a lower priced version of the saw that stanley covington sent to me, one that I found for $50 on ebay. Like your maebiki, it (the saw) expects a certain thing at a certain angle. I need to work with it a little bit more to set it up to use it. I miss stan's saw!! I still sort of wish I would've ordered one.

Is unrelated, but the flip side of the video I made for stanley was this. Cutting the next stick off of the same board with a disston saw - didn't get the cut started quite right, thus the rattle, but I couldn't match this speed with stanley's saw (though his saw felt like a million dollars in the cut)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAK1dA69ayM&list=UUswplWFmxpdxvepK7zDpcow

I don't know that I ever linked the video of stanley's saw anywhere, but at the time, jack accused me of fabricating a story because nobody would ever ship a near four figures saw. Stanley is fanatical about the quality of his tools and he likes to share his fanaticism (he found me a NOS kiyotada chisel, too, a rare treat).

Re: Japanese sawyers

#5

Re: Japanese sawyers

david weaver

The pit saw...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XOp9IbqPT3k

Tom, I guess this is just a video for reference, since these guys are cutting dry oak...not sure why the wood wasn't cut green.

I say I guess just for reference because as well as these pitsaws work, they are not usually found very cheaply (as museums are buying them to use for demonstrations when they are found in good shape - a good indication of what you say, that the hand tool woodworking is coming back in force).

Re: Japanese sawyers

#6

Re: Japanese sawyers

wilbur

How long is that saw, and what was the tpi? Do you have any close up pictures of the saw?

Re: Japanese sawyers

#7

Re: The video you call "two"..

wilbur

The guy cutting the small piece is Tanaka Kiyoto, a fantastic Japanese luthier. From my lousy attempts at translation, he’s resawing a piece of cedar.

He certainly knows his way around tools, so if he’s using a small maebiki to do that cut, there’s probably a reason why.

Re: Japanese sawyers

#8

Re: Japanese sawyers

TomD

Thanks guys, I have about a day's worth of work there, given that one can't just watch Yotube, i am sure to divert down some alley like Ama divers at some point.

I will put up a pic of my saw as soon as possible.

Re: Japanese sawyers

#9

Re: The video you call "two"..

david weaver

For several years, I have done most of my work by hand, which includes ripping lumber, blanks, and often resawing.

The saw he's using is intended for much larger wood. The tooth count and the rake on the teeth is intended to do log work. It's possible that he's using the saw because the saw that sits in between the maebiki and a ryoba is not a common one (it is exactly the type of saw that stanley had made).

Stanley's saw would've resawn the ceder faster, and with much greater comfort for the user. Just as you found sawing a larger (wider) block than that with your maebiki, sawing wood that is smaller than the saw was intended for makes for rough sawing, and not particularly fast sawing.

The other trouble with using too large of a saw (as in one with too low of a tooth count or too aggressive of a rake) is the exit of the cut can end up being very rough.

I could've resawn the cedar shown at least as fast with the disston saw that I prepared for the other videos (and without the danger to blowing out the back side of the cut, or the front in his case, from using teeth of that count and rake), but certainly if it came to sawing larger boards, the maebiki would probably be faster.

(you can see several large slivers of wood break out of the outbound side of the cut in the second video - if those breakouts creep in to part of the wood you want to use, they can be problematic).

Re: Japanese sawyers

#10

Re: I knew I'd seen that handle before..

david weaver

...the poster of those videos has gobs of videos of sharpening with natural stones.

Re: Japanese sawyers

#11

Re: Japanese sawyers

david weaver

I think I put pictures of it on SMC under a thread called "this is a pretty serious saw". I lost the memory card those pictures are on, so that's the only place. You can see on that thread that one of the responders accused me of fabricating the whole story!! (despite the picture proof, and there's the video).

The saw was something like 380mm (maybe 350?) and 5 tpi, and stan commissioned the maker to have it set up to cut medium hardwoods. I can't remember the name of the maker, but stan told me and he's an old world style guy - the forge weld was a scarf joint (plate to tang) instead of a butt joint and the saw was *tough*, a saw you'd have absolutely zero fear of damaging if you were horsing it.

At the time, stan said the maker was making the saws in pairs, and there was an unfinished copy of his saw (the other half of that pair) that was available for $750. Having it made for what we use for wood and having it made tough made it unlike any other japanese saw I've used, and my kataba of a similar style off of ebay is not close in quality (I got a vintage saw for about $50, and will set up the teeth on it for hardwood).

I guess what I'm saying is if you're more into japanese tools than me, it is a saw that would be worth the $750 because it cuts smooth and fast and does not have the fragility of most saws, not in the saw plate nor at the teeth.