New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

experimental plane

Posts

experimental plane

#1

bridger

experimental plane

bridger

I'm modifying a broken block plane to be a low angle bevel down with chipbreaker one handed mini smoother. The build notes and pictures are at https://bridgerberdel.wordpress.com

Re: experimental plane

#2

Re: experimental plane

Lars Parrington

Cool project. I like that you are repurposing your old broken plane into a new tool. Also i'm curious about how the 35 deg bedding angle works out.

Re: experimental plane

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: experimental plane

Ellis Walentine

I'm curious as to how you will sculpt the infill and wedge so they are the optimal shape and angle. I'll be interested to see the outcome.

Nice project. I liked the walnut totes, too...

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: experimental plane

#4

Re: experimental plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have a woodie, bevel down plane that beds at somewhere around 35 degrees, on a skew. I've never had time to test it out for function, so I'll be interested to see how yours performs.

Re: experimental plane

#5

bridger

Re: experimental plane

bridger

So far it's cutting pretty well. The sloppy fit of the temp/trial infill and wedge means it doesnt adjust very well and I'm not done with shaping the edge yet. Plenty more to do yet....

Re: experimental plane

#6

Re: experimental plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

There shouldn't be a problem with 10 degrees of clearance (from a 35 degree bed and a 25 degree bevel).

I have a strike block plane I built that has a 38 degree bed and a 25 degree bevel ...


Closer to the configuration in question is a Veritas Custom Jointer with a 40 degree frog and a 30 degree bevel. This has performed well on both face grain (with the chipbreaker closed up) and shooting end grain ..


As far as I am aware Leonard Lee wrote that only 7 degrees of clearance was needed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: experimental plane

#7

bridger

Re: experimental plane

bridger

Im not looking to build this thing hanging off of the edge of practical usability. The fussiness of maintaining an edge where a couple of degrees off one way or the other means that the plane either stops working or breaks is not my idea of a fun plane to have or use.

Re: experimental plane

#8

Re: experimental plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Im not looking to build this thing hanging off of the edge of practical usability. The fussiness of maintaining an edge where a couple of degrees off one way or the other means that the plane either stops working or breaks is not my idea of a fun plane to have or use.

Hi Bridger

You have no choice but to be fussy with your bevel angle as you have too little leeway for clearance. A degree here-or-there should not matter, but 5 degrees will likely do so.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: experimental plane

#9

bridger

Re: experimental plane

bridger

A 25° flat bevel isn't too hard to do freehand as long as you're not too picky about a little rounding. Just keep the heel ground back. Pushing the cutting angle down does narrow the window of course, but it's not so tight as trying to hit the minimum. Let's see, 7° clearance, probably 20° bevel if we use one of the tough wear resistant steels, build that as a 27° bedded plane and you've got a plane that you have to get the sharpening just right to use it at all. It would be very interesting to see how such a beast would perform, but I'm not up for the constant maintenance.

Re: experimental plane

#10

bridger

Re: experimental plane

bridger

I've uploaded a few new pictures and notes tonight.