New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Stick that curls right off the saw

Posts

Stick that curls right off the saw

#1

Stick that curls right off the saw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Little problem I need to ask about. I just resawed a small 4/4 stick of boxwood (Buxus) that's short at 12" long, and about 2" wide. The offcut was thin, maybe 3/16", leaving me 1/2" thickness in the piece I'll use.

The stick was dead straight before sawing, but immediately right off the saw sprang a bow of 1/16" amplitude over the 12" length. I believe this wood to be dry.

Question: Is this stick going to equalize tension and straighten itself out, or will I likely need to plane it straight? Any suggestions most welcome!

Wiley

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#2

P. S.--it bowed convex on sawn face.


Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#3

not an uncommon affair

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is tension in the wood that likely got there when the piece was dried. Removing part of the piece removed what was holding it in shape. If this is the case only steaming the piece to plasticize the wood and relax the tension will enable it to become straight again. There are some tricks employing a flat iron that might work easily on a thin piece like you have. I have straightened 3/4 lumber, with patience. If you want to steam it straight email me.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#4

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

Lars Parrington

Since it bowed instantaneously after sawing, we know there was some kind of internal stress in the wood. If it had come off the saw straight, but then bowed over time, that could indicate that there was variable moisture content in the stick, and that it is warping as it comes to equilibrium.

The internal stress could be from multiple sources. I suppose it could actually be moisture related, in an extreme case (like you soaked the stick for an hour first or something like that). More likely it is internal stress from a knot or from growing under tension. It could also be case hardening if it was kiln dried, but then you would also probably see some cupping.

Since it is not moisture related, waiting isn't going to make a difference. Go ahead and plane it straight.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#5

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

you should give some thought as to how this piece is going to be used. There is some chance that the stored stress may manifest itself in this part over time.

I suspect that boxwood is a difficult wood to dry and such woods are easy to get stress during drying, and it doesn't have to be kiln drying to do it.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#6

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

TomD

A lot of the small boxwood of the section you describe is cut from trimings of small limbs that may be reaction wood.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#7

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I agree with Tom that a moisture problem would be expected to show up as cupping, not bowing. I think it most likely that the problem was caused by tension wood. (The tree uses tension wood to correct leaning). The are a few other possibilities, but considering boxwood's density and slow growth I would think them unlikely.

I do not flatten a board at all until after resawing. There is no sense in removing material that you might later wish to have back. You can certainly flatten the piece now, but keep in mind that if you thin the board by an appreciable amount there will probably be more movement.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#8

Follow-up on all suggestions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Big thanks to all! That was very, very helpful. And some great insights offered in the discussion. Some of those glancing comments are the ones I remember most.

This morning, the bow (no cup) was still there, maybe ever so slightly diminished by its night's sleep.

I didn't mention the use of this stick of wood, which is one of the things that turned out in your discussion to be important, since there is likely to be further movement. This piece is being face glued to the fence of an all-boxwood plough--the existing fence wouldn't let you get to within 1/2" of the edge of the board you're ploughing, so I needed to augment the fence. Glue on another piece of boxwood, and mold it to match.

But before gluing, I needed to saw out a fairly big notch, which allows for movement of the depth stop. That notch took half the meat out of the middle of the cross section. Which cuts the resistance to bending in half. The bow is in the right direction, in that a clamp in the middle will force the ends of the glue-up into compression. Which is good because it's an awkward glue up, and difficult to get any clamping onto the front end of the fence. And there will be further planing and tooling of this piece as-glued, which will relieve tension a bit more.

So I just glued it, as is, and let the bow provide the compression at the ends. We'll see what happens.

This plane, a Greenfield all-boxwood plough, handled, is going to appear on this forum as a benefit auction, with two sets of Moulson Bros. irons. For me, the plane is too cumbersome to be really enjoyable. But not everyone agrees, because plenty of handled ploughs were sold. And the Moulson Bros. irons are good in any event. So..... Pictures to follow as I get things ready to go.

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#9

bridger

Re: Follow-up on all suggestions

bridger

As a general principle I figure that if I can pull the board to straight (or to the curve of a laminating form, if that's what I'm doing ) with my bare fingers then it's safe to glue and clamp it there.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#10

Re: Follow-up on all suggestions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Yes, agree, I could straighten it with finger pressure.

Wiley

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#11

Nothing Useful to Add, but..

david weaver

..I remember one of the japanese videos that came up last year (one of the sequences from kotaro tanaka, or one linked when his videos are watched), showed a large heated press where they put every board they were going to work before they worked it.

I have never gotten a piece of wood that relieves itself to un-relieve itself, but that's not that important, I guess.

Has anyone ever tried to flatten small pieces of wood with a pre-heated iron on a flat surface? Does it work? I would've planed the piece of wood in question, too.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#12

Re: Nothing Useful to Add, but..

Larry Barrett

No experience with sawn, dry stock. But when making chair rungs from riven oak I have had some that had a bend and/or twist. These were sticks with an octagonal cross-section and still had a lot of moisture in them. I put some in my microwave for maybe a minute, then while hot clamped one end in a vise and bent/pulled to relieve the tension. It worked.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#13

I have described the process before

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The requirement is to plasticize the wood, a process that can be achieved with heat and moisture(or noxious chemicals). The moisture already present in the wood can be sufficient.

It is a common practice to pre-bend stringing using a heated piece of metal. Scale the process and one can straighten a 3/4" piece of lumber with clamps to provide pressure, a wet cloth and a steam iron. The picture shows my desperate(and successful) effort to rescue a piece of rare mahogany for a case top. It had sprung when resawed like in Wiley's case.

The result. There was a second result. Red stuff bled from mahogany to wife's iron, then fused. Not good.


Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#14

Re: Second Result

William Duffield

That's why I keep my own steam iron in my shop. They're not expensive. I use distilled or deionized water in mine, because the iron in my tap water would give me results like that even if I were flattening holly veneer.

If one eschews the slaughter of electrons in their shop, here are some alternatives: :D

http://images.google.com/search?tbm=isch&hl=en&source=hp&q=antique+iron&gbv=2&oq=antique+iron&gs_l=img.3..0l10.2614.5712.0.8145.12.11.0.1.1.0.171.1068.1j7.8.0.msedr...0...1ac.1.34.img..3.9.1073.Zm9wMQHs7AY

I seem to remember we had another thread a while back regarding kitchen and other household items that we had repurposed as woodshop tools.

Re: Stick that curls right off the saw

#15

Re: Various things.

TomD

The result was great. But I doubt very much you plasticized the wood, just balanced out the moisture. I sometime throw pieces on the lawn to do the same, assuming they had some kind of prior proof of stability in the flat. To plasticized 3/4 is a long time in live steam. The moisture is not really beneficial other than as an effective way to get the heat in there when plasticizing.

Speaking of irons, I bought 5 of them last month. 4 electrics and one SAD. The SAD weighs 20 pounds. I got three in a deal for 20 bucks, they are useful for their intended purpose, and for stuff around the shop. The heavy ones make useful weights to hold stuff for pattern making, etc...

Actually, the SADs are another source of cast iron for those who want a lap, or want to practice flattening machinery with scrapers. I'm glad I wrote this, as one of the benefits of blabbing on at this place is I get ideas like that. I want a way to flatten it, wasn't sure I could hold it in any of my mills. But I do need practice hand scraping...

Speaking of plasticizing wood with irons, there are some nice looking rib bending irons with digital heat control on the chinese parts of ebay.