New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Advice on sharpening a Slick

Posts

Advice on sharpening a Slick

#1

Advice on sharpening a Slick

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi -

Not too long ago I acquired an old unhandled 3 3/4 inch Slick. It was (is) in fairly bad shape with some pretty bad pitting on the bottom of the blade (unfortunately coming right to the tip of the blade). My first (and easiest) challenge was to figure out how to put a bevel on it given that the blade profile (looking at it head on) is pretty much triangular....unlike most chisels. But I solved that problem.

Now my next problem is the bottom of the blade. Unlike most chisels this slick is not flat on the bottom and I based on what I have read that is by design. It has a very, very modest banana-like arch to it along a fair portion of the blade. I understand this it to permit the slick to easily lever/maneuver in and out of cuts.

When I put a straight-edge to it it looks like maybe the first 1/4-1/2 of an inch is "flat" before the modest arch begins to be apparent to me.

Since I'm not trying to flatten the entire back (or even the first inch or two...at least I don't think I am or should be trying to flatten that much) and since trying to flatten that only that first 1/4 or 1/2 inch of the blade requires a raising the handle ever so slightly off the bench, I am wondering how I can go about flattening this back in a repeatable fashion both now and in the future.

Any advice from the slick-savvy would be appreciated.

Thank you!

Dave

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ruler trick

Jack Guzman from Maine

Use a variation of the ruler trick. Find a thin object that holds the blade off the stone the proper amount.---Jack

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#3

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

Patrick Gibbons

Dave, I'm not understanding why this would be difficult. The end of the slick would be honed just enough to take off the wire edge from honing the bevel. Laying the end on the stones just enough to do this would be repeatable every time. Flattening for the first time would work the same way, progressing through the grits. I'm not understanding your concern.

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#4

Things are about to become complicated

Bob Hackett

Or maybe not.

I found when I was just starting out with slicks that a side sharpening approach worked best for me. I started out using a hardwood scrap of appropriate height secured next to the stone. I let the socket rest on the wood and that provided consistent results. Later, after I discovered what worked best as far as angle at the edge,I just began freehand sharpening.

Here`s another twist that may complicate things for you. I find my slicks work best with a slight camber to their edge. A bit more than a smoothing plane iron yet less than a jack plane iron.

BTW- I use a simple softwood V block to sharpen slicks and framing chisels with either a cambered or double tapered face. The V block allows me to move and adjust the angle of the edge so it grinds evenly yet rests and slides securely across the tool rest. I use softwood both because it seems to " grip" the steel better than hardwood and also lets me register the blade by setting into the wood block with a tap from a wood mallet once I find the right angle that engages the wheel evenly across the middle of the bevel.

Hope this helps. You`re going to really like using a slick and will soon be wondering why you didn`t get one of these useful and versatile tools sooner.

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#5

Re: Ruler trick

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Jack -

Thank you. Very interesting. Something akin to the ruler trick had crossed my mind, but I had resisted it. Why? A couple of reasons. First, when flattening backs I prefer to use a back and forth motion rather than a side to side motion. I worry about rocking the blade. I also find it less tiring. I may just have to get over it and pay enough attention to ensure I don't rock the blade...and eat my Wheaties.

Second, is the issue of repeatability. This slick's back is badly enough pitted that I'm going to spend hours flattening even a fairly small part of it. So - at least to my mind - stones are out of the question. I'm pretty sure I'd go through too many and spend as much time flattening the stones as flatten the slick. So, I'm expecting I'll use sandpaper on glass. This means that - for repeatability purposes - I'll need to keep track of how "tall" whatever I use as a ruler" is and where I let it rest on the back of the slick so I can do the same thing if/when and keep the correct angle for when I need to polish the back in the future. That seems like keep track of a lot of things in my messy shop. Again, I may just have to get over it and get organized.

It may be that I'm wanting to have my cake and eat it too. But it seemed to me that with Slicks having this modestly curved back by design that folks had addressed and solved this problem before...probably with more than one way to do it. Yours is a good idea and it may be the one I end up going with. One of the things I love about posting here is that often folks come up with either ingenious solutions or ingeniously simple solutions that create that kind of "Aha" moment that I enjoy so much.

I really appreciate your posting.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#6

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Patrick -

I think what MAY be missing in my communication on this is how heavy this Slick is (even without the handle). I find that with most chisels (even the biggest in my kit) you can apply enough downward pressure to keep it flat on your sharpening surface. However, since this Slick is quite massive (at least as compared to any chisel I have....or have seen) and since to obtain the correct angle to flatten what I need to flatten on it's back, I need to suspend the back in the air some (unless I use Patrick's idea and employ the ruler trick) and keeping it suspended at that same height creates consistency issues...at least for me. It would be a little like trying to flatten the first 1/4 - 1/2 inch of the sole of your Number 4 Smoother.

Does that clarify? I appreciate the question and the post. Thank you.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#7

Re: Things are about to become complicated

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Bob -

Really interesting.

Let me start my response by making a few observations and maybe something will resonate with you. First, if I understand what you mean by "side sharpen" (and I may not) then I find that at 3 1/2 inches my Slick won't fit into my Eclipse (side) sharpening jig. [If that doesn't sound like what you meant by "side sharpen" would you mind explaining it a bit?] If it is what you meant then you'll understand that's why I had to come up with another way to tackle the problem.

Second, and interestingly (because I was interested in a camber on the blade too) my solution was to affix the Slick to the end of a 5-ish foot 2x4 (I shaped one end to fit into the handle of the Slick) and then marked a spot on my shop floor (and placed a "stop" there) that would give me a 25 degree angle on my grinder so I could pivot the blade back and forth much as one might do with a Wolverine sharpening set up. It looks like I'm getting a camber pretty close to what you describe...maybe not quite as pronounced as you suggested.

Some day I may move to your "v block" idea. That kind of sounds like the Wolverine sharpening system, right? It sounds like it to me. For now my "2x4 solution" seemed like a quick and dirty way to experiment with this as an approach to sharpening a bevel. Admittedly it does cramp my style in my workshop...which is only 11x11.

It sounds like your "hardwood scrap" strategy is pretty close to Jack's ruler trick suggestion. Does it sound like it to you? If so, that's two votes for that approach and good cause for me to re-consider.

I'm sure not looking forward to flatten the back of this sucker :(

Thank you so much for your post.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#8

Re: Things are about to become complicated

Bob Hackett

When I mentioned "side sharpening" I was speaking of holding the slick at a 90 degree angle to the long axis of the stone and moving it what most people would consider a side to side motion so the stone scratches are parallel to the edge rather than perpendicular to it.

The wood block placed next to the stone is in fact an adaptation of the "ruler trick". Big chisels require more space to move and support all that steel. I just found supporting the socket end with a block was kinder to my hands and forearms, especially during the flattening stage.

If there are some deep rust pits right up to the edge you might want to consider trying a trick I learned from one of my mentors. Grind the bevel (sounds like you`ve already found an excellent approach to grinding the camber) and once it`s ground as you like it burnish a heavy burr onto it so the hook forms to the back of the slick. What you are aiming for is to raise enough of a hook so that the pits are now higher than the plane of the chisel back. You`ll end up with a bright band of solid, uninterrupted metal much like a micro bevel across the back once all the pits are gone. You may have to touch up your bevel grind if this requires burnishing more than once but the time saved while flattening the back will make up for that. I once pulled a heavily rusted slick from the bilge of one of the boats we were working on and this trick worked wonders for putting it back in service. The entire back doesn`t have to be flat and/or shiny. Think about how Japanese chisels and corrugated plane soles do their work.

The wood V block was what I use on the tool rest to keep a rounded or double tapered chisel face from rolling as I ground using the rest. It just served to stabilize a non-flat surface. Sounds like you have bypassed the rest in favor of your cambering jig so you don`t need the V block. If it works like the Oneway Vari-grind jig for turning tools then the rest becomes redundant. I`m sure you have already found a solution for indexing your 5 foot extension to the floor with something that is removable but if you find you need some advice there I have a few suggestions I learned in the boatyards that you may find useful.

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#9

what is a slick used for?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"You`re going to really like using a slick and will soon be wondering why you didn`t get one of these useful and versatile tools sooner. "

I presume we are talking about those enormous chisels? What are they used for in today's shop? I see them at flea markets and all I can think of is what a dandy spud they would have made in my youth when we chopped holes in the ice for fishing.

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#10

Re: what is a slick used for?

Bob Hackett

Bill, as you know I have some issues with my hands, especially my grip. what using a slick does for me is, the longer handle lets me power the chisel from my shoulder rather than relying on grip alone. Using my entire body,or just my upper body for short cuts allows me far more power as well as control. That added control has allowed me to use these oversized blades with far more confidence than I had with their smaller cousins even when my hands functioned normally. I use my slicks everywhere I can fit them in. They were originally meant to work in those tight places on board ships where planes couldn`t fit so I suppose it`s just an extension of their history and lore. I find they are one of those tools that the more you use one the more uses you find for it. The power and control will draw in those folks who took up WWing because they enjoy "dancing with the wood".

I like the larger tools so much I sought out a comparable size gouge, sharpened it in-cannel, fitted it with the same type of handle I have on my slicks and used it for rough out work. I say "used" because my brother saw me working with it and talked me into letting him have it. He lives in Utah and has no chance of finding one out there. I`m still looking for my own replacement and may just reforge one of my less than stellar performing slicks to take it`s place.

My hand issues also have me considering making my own version of an Asian leaf or spear plane for finish work.As one of my WWing friends once told me after he saw me using one of my slicks; " When you`ve lost your grip I guess you can always look forward using your leverage". :)

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#11

Re: what is a slick used for?

TomD

Bill, they are for fitting and dressing timbers. The curved back makes it possible to work with the hands above the work, but one can do that with other shapes, and also to sweep some curves in log work, etc... If you have a minor curve to the edge the swept back allows you to get into a cut like a scrub plane, it would cut the same as if the curve was transverse, but the edge straight, and yet you don't have that even more difficult to deal with shape and a lack of depth control. Not for the most part a tool for the shop. Not all slicks are curved.

-----------------------------------------------------------

It is the case that one rarely sees the number of hewing axe forms that exist. Mainly two , while there are 6-12. Since the issues are similar I wonder if there are hiding out in Norway an equal number of slick geometries.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Best way to deal with the mess described is with a belt sander. I don't believe a flat facet inside the edge is the intended thing. If you do that there really isn't any reason for the curve. There could be cases where that is a better geometry, but it would be someone's custom fix, or they didn't know how to sharpen a slick.

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#12

Re: Things are about to become complicated

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Bob -

Thank you. This is very helpful.

I am very intrigued by your suggestion to burnish a heavy burr on the backside of the blade. Just to make sure I understand, this seems like this is effectively like putting a back bevel on the flat side of the blade. Am I right on that? When you did that did you adjust the bevel angle you were putting on the Slick since a back bevel would change the effective cutting angle of the Slick...or am I over-thinking this?

I ask because am not sure that even a heavy burr would be sufficient to overcome the pitting at the edge of the blade, so I your comment has made me wonder if I shouldn't go for just a straight back bevel...and that led me to wonder about impact on the effective cutting angle of the blade.

Also...if the offer still stands I'd love your thoughts the v-block approach you use. My approach was really more of a proof of concept to see if I could figure out a way to overcome the fact that the bevel side of the Slick was not flat. This approach takes up too much space in my shop, so if I'm going to keep at this, I need a longer-term solution.

Thanks for your post and your interesting suggestions.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#13

Re: what is a slick used for?

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Tom -

Really interesting questions, for example, "...I wonder if there are hiding out in Norway an equal number of slick geometries." I have wondered the same thing...or perhaps a variant. For example I have seen that some Slicks seem to have pretty flat backs, but their necks are cranked. However, my Slick's neck is not cranked, but instead the back of the blade is modestly curved. Both types seem to allow one to lever in and out of cuts. So this has made wonder if some styles are better for timber framing and others for boatbuilding (which as I understand it are the two major applications of Slicks).

On your second comment: "I don't believe a flat facet inside the edge is the intended thing. If you do that there really isn't any reason for the curve. There could be cases where that is a better geometry, but it would be someone's custom fix, or they didn't know how to sharpen a slick." the flat I was considering is really pretty small (maybe a quarter of an inch - max). It doesn't look to me that this would affect the apparent function of the Slick. Do you have a different thought on that? If one doesn't flatten at least some portion of the back of the blade (even if it's only a heavy burr as Bill suggested) I don't see how you can form two flat planes that intersect at the edge of the blade to give you a sharp edge. Am I missing something?

Thank you so much for your post!

Dave

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#14

Re: what is a slick used for?

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Bill -

As Bob and Tom said, and as I understand it, there are two main applications for Slicks: (1) Timber framing, and (2) Wooden boat building.

In my case my boys attend a wilderness boy's camp in New York where all of the building are log construction. Every year or so they build a new cabin and I've thought that sounded like fun...and a nice opportunity to learn. So when I saw this Slick blade...for a reasonable price, I picked it up thinking I could use it there.

I would say that - and maybe I am naïve - I am thinking I can use it in and around the shop too. I have a couple of projects that I am making out of what might otherwise by firewood...stuff that fallen on our property and was subsequently chain-sawed up. I am thinking this Slick may be just the thing to help me rough shape some of these former logs to a point where I can dress them with a plane. Other tools may work for this like a hewing hatchet but I'm thinking (hoping) this Slick will work on things like that too.

Thank you for posting.

Dave

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#15

Re: Things are about to become complicated

Bob Hackett

I would not recommend putting a back bevel on the back of a slick, I`d make at least the first 1-2 inches dead flat. A back bevel will require you to lift the handle in order to establish and maintain the cut. A slick is just a very large paring chisel and as such needs to have that flat area to jig and guide the cut. The "rocker" or curved area of the back behind that dead flat area is what allows you to lower the handle and lever up and out of the cut in a controlled manner.

Re: Advice on sharpening a Slick

#16

Thank you, Bob.

Dave (Arlington, VA)

I'll give it a try but I'm not likely to go back as far as two inches because with both the curve to the blade and all the pitting on this blade, I'll be flattening the back of this thing until next Christmas.

I appreciate your posting.

Dave