New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Jointer vs. Planer

Posts

Jointer vs. Planer

#1

Jointer vs. Planer

Tom Colligan

For 15 plus years I've had an 8" jointer and a 15" planer in my two car garage. I don't think I've used them more than 2 or 3 times in any given year. I'd like to unload one of them and try making do with a hand held planer, perhaps a Makita or Milwaukee.

Does anyone else get by with a hand held planer or are these tools a disappointment?

If you think this is a workable arrangement I'm having trouble visualizing which stationary tool to unload, the planer or the jointer? Your comments would be appreciated and thanks in advance.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#2

If I had to make it with just one,  *LINK*

Keith Newton

I'd go with the Makita 1806 B Power Plane. I've had one since the late seventies, and really like using it. I have a 12" jointer in the shop, but when I go out to work on job sites, this serves as the jointer there. I've added some wider jaws to my vice which allows it to be clamped upside down, allowing me to handle smaller parts over it like on a stationary tool. But for larger stock, it lays on the benches or horses, while I handle the tool over it.

It has a longer infeed bed than all of the smaller 3" tools that I've used, and really provides a wonderful cut with sharp knives. But I think you still need a planer, but maybe you should downsize to the more portable ones which can store on a shelf under your bench too.


http://www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-6-3-4-in-Corded-Planer-1806B/203162062?cm_mmc=Shopping%7cG%7cBase%7cPLA%7cD25T%7cPowerTools&gclid=CIzdqd-zq8ICFQyFaQodTLMA4A&gclsrc=aw.ds

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#3

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Patrick Gibbons

The cost my preferred lumberyard charges to plane and sand wood is minimal. The amount of wood I would have to plane to justify the cost of buying a planer or joiner is high. I decided many years ago not to spend my money and occupy shop space with these tools. I wish I had a bandsaw to make thin stock out of thicker, but that's a related issue.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#4

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would only sell one if I was desperate for cash, or wanted to forsake power tools in favor of hand tools. A hand held planer is not a substitute for a thickness planer.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Jack guzman from Maine

In my opinion,a power jointer is the least necessary.i never regret selling mine. Jointing is easier to perform with hand tools. That one machine takes up alot of real estate

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#6

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

I would keep the jointer.

This probably flies in the face of all that other recommendations, however I approach this as a handplane user of seriously hardwoods.

Getting a board flat and coplanar can take a lot of effort. However, with one flat, reference side, it is a relatively simple matter to mark off the opposing side and plane to the lines. Or run the board through a bandsaw and then plane it smooth.

I had a 8" jointer and a 12" lunchbox thicknesser-planer for several years. The thicknesser-planer was seldom used as I hated the noise. The jointer had a long bed and was tucked away and awkward to get to, and so got less use than it could have. Recently I purchased a 12" combination machine (Hammer A3-31) with spiral head. Not cheap, but quiet and efficient, and it has a small footprint. There are less costly equivalents of this type of machine, and they are worth considering, especially if time is an issue, as it is in my case.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#7

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tom,

In part, the answer to the question depends on what operations you do, or are willing to do, by hand. For example, I happen to be pushed for space, and so routinely flatten one side of a board by hand, and run the other side through a lunchbox planer (Makita NB2012, which I do not find especially loud). This is best done in a couple iterations, but it works well. I also do all edge jointing by hand.

Relating this to your case, you could do the same thing I do, and get rid of both fixed machines in exchange for one lunchbox planer.

But again, it depends on what you wish to do by hand: If you do not wish to face flatten or edge joint by hand, then the 8" jointer remains essential, because a handheld planer will not replace it. In that case, you could keep the jointer, and swap out the 15" fixed planer for a lunchbox type, and save the space (assuming that is what you're trying to do :) ).

A third possibility comes to mind--get the fixed machines on casters or rolling bases, if you wish to keep them out of the way most of the time, and bring them into play only on demand.

Wiley

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#8

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Curt Putnam

As always, the answer depends on what your projects are. Edge jointing by hand is relatively simple. Face flattening can be done with a planer with proper sleds & shimming. I like to get one face flat enough with hand planes and then run the board through my planer. Hand held planers are, IMO, a rough, construction grade tool, especially in my hands.

So, my answer to your question is to lose the jointer. It's easier to do without it than it is a planer. I would not like to have to make a bunch of panels from 5/4 rough and thicknessed down to a ready-for-joinery 7/8" by hand. YMWV

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#9

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've frequently thought of getting a powered jointer. Been thinking about it for the last 25 years or so, but still don't have it, mostly because it really takes up a lot of the real estate in my very small shop.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#10

Re: Quality

TomD

By hand held planer I assume you mean a hand held power planer, They are ok, and once the work gets large enough you have few choices, which is why 12 inch wide hand planers are available for timber. That said, I am not sure they are really all that ramped up for harder hardwoods, the one I have seems to struggle.

I would probably keep the planer, it will do a lot more work than a jointer does. Wood for jointing (really face planing) falls into three cats. One is wood that has to be hand planes for reasons of yield or safety; wood that can't be planed on the planer one has for reasons of capacity, too short, too heavy, won't cut properly. And of course wood the jointer will face plane nicely. So 2 out of three times the stick needs hand treatment anyway. I pretty much edge joint by hand because I prefer the results. So to me, the jointer even when fully used is not all that useful. Hand planing works better, and is more accurate than power face planing, or jointing.

Conversely planers work much faster, do more work, and yield better results than hand planes. Sure there can be a last pass by hand plane for perfection, but up to that point the power tool work better.

So overall you results will be more accurate, you work less, if you kept the planer, and it takes up less space.

I can't really see getting rid of a jointer if I had one though.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#11

Get rid of both

markhennebury

You obviously don't need them.