Re: Jointer vs. Planer
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Tom,
In part, the answer to the question depends on what operations you do, or are willing to do, by hand. For example, I happen to be pushed for space, and so routinely flatten one side of a board by hand, and run the other side through a lunchbox planer (Makita NB2012, which I do not find especially loud). This is best done in a couple iterations, but it works well. I also do all edge jointing by hand.
Relating this to your case, you could do the same thing I do, and get rid of both fixed machines in exchange for one lunchbox planer.
But again, it depends on what you wish to do by hand: If you do not wish to face flatten or edge joint by hand, then the 8" jointer remains essential, because a handheld planer will not replace it. In that case, you could keep the jointer, and swap out the 15" fixed planer for a lunchbox type, and save the space (assuming that is what you're trying to do
).
A third possibility comes to mind--get the fixed machines on casters or rolling bases, if you wish to keep them out of the way most of the time, and bring them into play only on demand.
Wiley