Re: Alteratives
david weaver
(not saying this to be argumentative)
The MDF strops won't gain any roughness if the crayon is used consistently. They will instead glaze, even as the burnished surface is worn off of MDF. A drop or two of oil even on bare MDF will mitigate the rough and allow it to be burnished.
I have found that when using one, which isn't something I do often any longer, that it's helpful from time to time to keep a junk card scraper to take a pass or two and remove most of the swarf.
A drop or two of mineral oil helps the action of the MDF and ensures that you continue as a user to burnish the surface of it.
I like horse butt, too, for compound - when it's glued to a backer, it's really not much different from MDF, though - it's halfway to wooden.
Butt strips can be found on ebay and out on the internet for an inexpensive amount if one wants to cut their own strops. The TFWW option looks good for someone buying, *but* leather cuts very easily with a marking knife and a straight edge - especially horse butt which isn't as thick - and for those of us using strops in various places, it's helpful to have a good smooth bovine section and a horse butt strip. The combination of the two should be about $50 and yield dozens of strops, a handy thing if one ever contaminates a strop with something by accident.
That said, a contaminated strop can be sanded if scraping doesn't remove the contaminant. veg. tanned leather sands very well (just brush it off or vacuum it afterwards), and a treatment of mineral oil on the sanded surface yields an almost uniform smooth surface near immediately.
(I have almost the same problem with strops as I have with stones, but not quite so bad. And I only make my own, something I haven't yet tried with stones! But I've been through various veg tanned horse and bovine, and also bought a cordovan shell from horween several years ago - the latter is not useful for tools, too expensive, but it is available if you know who to ask, contrary to popular belief. You me and everyone else are just last in horween's line - they will not ship a shell until they have satisfied orders for shoe makers and others who are large customers, and it's extremely expensive (about $300 delivered for a shell that is two or three square feet - but it makes an interesting razor strop and it is in such demand that a mention of having excess will have watch band and wallet makers you've never met asking you if you'd like to sell your scraps to them)).
Anyway, I do think this is one thing - strops - where it's worth it for a woodworker to get some leather and experiment. Everything but the horween is cheap, and it's not my first choice for razor strops even because only the factory surface is what you want, and while the shell itself is very durable, the surface treatment can be damaged easily. And the surface treatment is the real treat in the whole deal - definitely way out of bounds for tools. Way out, and I think a desirable razor strop just because it can be used immediately from horween and because it's expensive.