New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

An unusual joint

Posts

An unusual joint

#1

An unusual joint

Lars Parrington

I've been working on a console table that employs tusk tenons on the ends of stretcher:


I wanted a similarly knock-down-able joint between the legs and tabletop. What I came up with is not something I've ever seen elsewhere, but I think it's a fairly elegant solution. It should be reasonably robust, it is easy to disassemble, and it is not difficult to make.

Here is a photo of it, ready for assembly:


And here is a photo of it assembled:


For each leg assembly (looks like 2 legs, but is one piece), there are two pairs of cleats glued to the undeside of the table top, making 4 pairs total. The wedges that lock it together are tapered in two directions. One direction forces the joint tight, the other direction just keeps the wedge pressed against the underside of the table top.

Possibly the hardest part to make is the angled cutouts in the legs. But this turns out to be quite easy if you make the cleats first, and then use them as a jig, like so:


Re: An unusual joint

#3

Re: An unusual joint

TomD

I like that a lot. And I haven't seen anything like it either. Cool invention.

My gut feeling is glue failure down the road. I had the same prediction for some cleats on my canoe when I built them 35 years ago, and I was wrong about that. Or put it like this. I wouldn't sell it.

But here is an idea, because yours may work 100% over a long period of time, but an option would to have the cleats have those tapered dovetails on the surfaces that mate to the table so that they would fit into shallow tapered dovetail sockets in the table top. A good job for a router, of either type. Then you can drop the cleats into the dovetails, spread them apart so they lock, then put the leg and wedge in. The wedge will hold everything in place, no glue anywhere. A small tenon on top of the leg might help also. It would help support the sides of the leg where they meet the cleat.

Anyway, I love it.

Re: An unusual joint

#4

Clarification?

CJ in MPLS

Are the cleats on the underside of the table top simply face glued? I agree that a shallow mortise or at least a dowel or two would be in order as I would worry about the glue failing or more likely, the face grain popping off over time.

That said, this is an excellent idea.

CJ

Re: An unusual joint

#5

Re: An unusual joint

William Duffield

Ingenious improvement to an ingenious joint, but I have a couple of minor issues:

First, your proposed sliding dovetails between the cleats and the tabletop have the same long grain failure mode as a glued attachment. i.e., they would tend to fail at the plane of the bottom surface of the table top. Either one could of course be reinforced with vertically oriented dowels or loose tenons.

Second, your proposed tenon in the top of the leg is just a little more complicated than one might imagine. The cheeks of the tenon must be angled at the same angle as the face of the cleat (unless you stay with the original plan of gluing to cleat to the table top, and glue the cleat AFTER you have installed the leg into the tenon--but that defeats the idea of a knock-down design).

Re: An unusual joint

#6

Re: An unusual joint

Lars Parrington

I like where this discussion is going. The cleats are indeed just face glued to the tabletop. Although I don't anticipate a glue failure, I did use hide glue there, so hopefully a repair (if needed) would be easy.

The typical joint used in this situation is just a few screws & slotted holes or some cabinetmakers buttons, right? I think what I've done is at least that strong. Also, keep in mind that the configuration of the stretcher effectively eliminates any racking loads on this joint.

In order to facilitate the discussion of how to improve the joint, perhaps some analysis of the expected failure mode of the existing joint is in order. Those of you who anticipate the joint failing, how do you envision it failing? Does the glue fail in shear or in tension, or is it some combination of both? Does the failure happen when someone jostles the table exceptionally hard, or is more of a fatigue or creep type failure which occurs over a long time frame?

Making a shallow mortise for the cleats would help prevent a shear failure, but it wouldn't reduce the tensile stress on the glue (or wood near the glue). I expect a sliding dovetail would behave similarly. In that case, As William wrote, the wood would fail at the plane defined by the underside of the table top.

Adding some dominos or dowels would strengthen the joint in both shear and tension, although the tension strength still relies on glue.

Re: An unusual joint

#7

Re: An unusual joint

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Lars,

I like the joint a lot! I expect it'll hold just as you have it.

If I were to suggest one thing, it would be that the trestle will reduce racking loads, but not eliminate them entirely (do you have kids?). The risk is the glue failing in shear, as you said. But you could help the glue resist shear by simply running a screw or two through each block up into the bottom of the table top. Screws could be counterbored and hidden by unglued plugs to preserve knockdown.

Really good idea! Thanks for sharing.

Wiley

Re: An unusual joint

#8

Re: An unusual joint

William Duffield

I think shear failure would be much more likely than tensile failure.

Imagine these scenarios:

A week from now, you ask Aunt Bertha to take the platter with a twenty-five pound turkey and all the trimmings and set it on the table. The golden retriever has been waiting, and practicing, for weeks for just this opportunity. The turkey flies, clearing everything from the table top, and Aunt Bertha's well padded hip collides with the end of the table top. That's shear failure.

After dinner, you ask Uncle Albert, a retired pro middle linebacker, to help you move the table. (Between now and then, you have decided it was a little unstable, an added trestle feet.). He starts to push it across the carpeted floor. That's also shear failure with some torque thrown in. After you've smacked him aside the head with a turkey leg and explained that one must ALWAYS pick up furniture instead of sliding it to move it, he bunglingly puts his foot on top of the trestle foot and lifts. That's tensile failure.

The names have been changed to protect the innocent. No, your table doesn't need trestle feet, and Wiley's alternate method of countering both shear and tensile failures should be sufficient for any practical scenarios.

Re: An unusual joint

#9

Re: An unusual joint

Lars Parrington

Ok, I'm crossing Aunt B and Uncle A off the invite list.

Screws would add some strength. There would actually be no need to remove them when knocking-down the table.

Just to be clear: I don't have any intention of modifying the joint on this table. It's already been finished, and I don't think it is at all necessary. But it is interesting to think about how the joint could be improved for next time.

Re: An unusual joint

#10

another option

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

That's a nifty joint which I thank can adapt for use with step and wood.

Another joint that you could have used is segmented sliding dovetail. It is, a the name implies, a standard sliding dovetail that is adapted to become a blind joint. This is done by divideing the slot and the tail into an even number of segments. Every other segment on the tail is removed, making it look like multiple tenons with dovetail shoulders. Every other segment of the slot has the shoulders removed which allows the doweled segments to slip into the slot and then slide to one side to lock it into place. This us an ideal joint for attaching wide legs to table tops that don't have aprons as it helps keep the tip flat but allows for seasonal movement.

Robin

Re: An unusual joint

#11

This sounds nifty, and I think I understand it...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...but if you have time for drawings or pictures, that would confirm whether I got the idea.

Re: An unusual joint

#12

Re: This sounds nifty, and I think I understand it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'll fess up to my denseness. I don't understand it at all.