New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Early note on Atoma 400

Posts

Early note on Atoma 400

#1

Early note on Atoma 400

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I have recently begin using an Atoma 400g diamond plate (fixed diamonds) to maintain a set of Sigma ceramic stones--1000g, 2000g, and 13000g. These stones cut quickly and also collect swarf quickly. I have found the Atoma plate very effective so far in truing, deswarfing, and regrading the stones.

I say 'so far', because it's still early going. Don't know what this diamond plate will be like in a year, whether it will stand up to continued use, or abuse as I subject it to sharpening uses in addition to stone grading.

I like the Atoma 400 a lot so far.

Questions:

1. Anyone else using this plate? Any experience or suggestions to offer?

2. Do you folks using Arkansas stones grade them with diamond or other abrasives? Do they benefit from surface regrading?

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#2

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Patrick Gibbons

I don't think Arkansas stones ever need flattening. Perhaps after many years. Mine don't appear anywhere close to dishing.

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#3

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Hank Knight

Wiley,

I ordered a large translucent Arkansas stone from Hall's Pro Edge a couple of years ago. It's a very nice stone, but when it arrived, it was far from flat. I sent it back to be flattened and it came back better, but still not flat. So, I bit the bullet and ordered a big DMT Dia Flat lapping plate and went to work on the stone. It was slow going, and I still haven't gotten it completely flat. It was crowned and I've worked it down to the point that I can use about 90% of the stone, all but a small rim around the edge. Occasionally, I put the stone back on the lapping plate and have another go at it in my continuing effort to flatten all of it. It seems to cut a little better for a while after a lapping session, but only marginally. I have gone many months between lappings and the stone continues to cut beautifully. I don't think lapping will be necessary to maintain the stone once I finally get the entire surface flat, if I ever do. It is my main finish stone before stropping with a compound-charged leather strop. I don't have any relevant experience with other Arkansas stones. The translucent is the only one in my current sharpening kit.

Hank

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#4

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

david weaver

Wiley - I have used two atoma 400s for about 7 years now, maybe slightly less than that.

I got one because I wanted a flat diamond hone and a DMT duosharp had clapped out quicker than I thought was appropriate. Then I got a second because I decided I wanted one I only used on waterstones and one to use flattening things.

My thoughts:

* different than anything else in diamond hones - the diamonds are in piles

* more durable than any other diamond hone I've had

* I gave in and I've used both on metal a fair amount, so they are slower than they were, but the slow is different than other diamond hones. The little piles of diamonds are all there still, they just seem a bit more dull, but they still lap waterstones fine.

* I don't generally use synthetic stones any longer, at least not waterstones, so the only things mine do are natural waterstones and some honing work

* After that many years, they are slower than they were when they were new, and finer feeling (more like an 800 synthetic stone), but still extremely durable and very uniform (my DMTs had a habit of getting pretty worn out and grayed in the center).

I still use a DMT bench stone for synthetic oilstones.

I never touch natural oilstones after they've been lapped once. If I think the coarse ones are too sleepy, I rub them together.

If you have an inclination to use them like waterstones (aggressive cutting), then you have to keep them freshly lapped, and that's OK, I guess, but they don't cut very finely like that. I prefer to work less metal, never lap them, and keep them fine cutting.

Biggs or owyhee jasper (if you can find a slab of it cheap) makes an excellent burr chaser. That costs about $10 if you are patient on ebay, and they are thin and thus need to be attached to something, but jasper settled in is harder and finer than novaculite, and it can be used instead of a leather strop with oilstones.

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#6

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

David Charlesworth

I believe Larry Williams dresses his stones, (with diamond) every sharpening or every sharpening session.

There was a nice video of his methods.

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#7

It's worth pointing out..

david weaver

..that early on when stu tierney started selling atomas, and I had to beg him to carry them, that they were not recommended for oilstones because the wafer that holds the abrasive is affixed to the aluminum milled backer with some kind of adhesive that may not tolerate some of the things we put on oilstones.

I've seen several people using them on oilstones with no complaints, so I don't really know what the score is there (I don't use mine on oilstones, because I want them to last as long as possible and not lose their adhesive bond).

Also, something to think about on oilstones - when you use a diamond hone or something on a pore-less stone like an oilstone, a jasper, a very hard nakayama stone or something like a ceramic stone of the spyderco type, you leave small grooves all over the surface of the stone. It takes a while to work through those or have them dull so that they don't affect the fineness of a stone. I don't know that it matters to most, but if you do anything with your stones (like sharpen a razor) that requires a really fine edge, those grooves make a difference.

That's another reason that I like to rub natural stones together instead. There's no "contamination" that really occurs because of it, either, because the particles are so dull within a few passes of hardened steel.

Oh...and one last thing, I never had much luck avoiding flattening 3 inch wide stones. Those stones always become hollow on me. If you never lap a stone again, it becomes immediately evident why most of the old oilstones are about 2" wide - because at that width, they do not become hollow in their width, only in their length (and even at that, only if you allow them to in their length - my settled bone colored hard ark stone has been used quite a bit, but it doesn't have any noticeable sway or dip in it other than a tiny amount laterally, which is preferable, anyway.)

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#8

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks Patrick!

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#9

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hank,

That's really interesting. Do you prefer the translucent Arkansas to water or ceramic stones? Would be very interested in your comparison and experiences that led you to the translucent Arkansas.

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#10

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

Excellent account replete with detail (as always)! I have never been able to maintain discipline about reserving diamond plates for specific uses, though I may try your plan of having two.

Interesting your comment about durability of Atoma. I've noticed the opposite in the DMT stones I've had (the expensive mono crystalline with a flatness spec on them). They seriously lost cutting power when using them for sharpening, but then I wasn't careful about using a cutting fluid, and that was likely a contributor.

This Atoma is crazy fast right now, but we'll see in year or so.

Have you ever used a 1200g Atoma?

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#11

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks Wilbur,

Have you ever used a 1200g Atoma?

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#12

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks David,

I know the video of Larry's you refer to, and had that in mind when I asked whether others dressed their Arkansas stones. I couldn't tell what Larry was using to dress his. Can't remember if he said 'diamond stone' or if I just assumed it.

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#13

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

david weaver

Larry is in a few different videos sharpening, but IIRC one of them was a "DMT bench stone", those things that are one sided and plastic and have a little bit of elevation.

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#14

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

david weaver

It'll slow down some, but it won't give up any parts like a DMT does. Mine are fairly smooth, but the atomas do feel like a million zippers to hone on because they are arranged in such an orderly way. I don't love that on things that are delicate, but they are nice for doing something like preparing the back of a japanese chisel. It's quick work and they're very flat.

I haven't used the 1200, but it is very highly regarded on the razor board for not having that million zippers feeling, and a lot of those guys still like to lap their stones to get a slurry but they don't want large lines or grooves in the stones.

The 400s are all I've got (and three DMTs, and four different milled steel 8x3 chinese diamond hones)

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#15

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Hank Knight

Hi, Wiley,

Like everybody else, I've tried a half dozen sharpening regimens, beginning with cheap Arkansas stones in plastic boxes. i graduated to more expensive ones in wooden boxes, then to scary sharp, Norton water stones and a nice natural honyama for my Japanese blades. Somewhere in there I bought a Tormek, but it fell into disuse and has been stored for a long time. I didn't like all the maintenance and mess that went with water stones, so I decided to go back to oil stones. They don't shed goop and don't require regular flattening. I had a nice Norton coarse crystalon and medium India combo stone. I ordered a surgical black Arkansas for my finish stone. It was OK, but it didn't give me a polished finish like my 8,000 Norton water stone. I added a horse butt strop charged with green crayon and that took me to the 8,000+ level and I was happy. But I managed to drop my black Arkansas and break it in half. I got in touch with Hall's to order another one and they had an odd sized, but large, translucent Arkansas; so I bought it in lieu of the black. I've already discussed my flattening trials, so I won't go into them here. Suffice it to say that I found the translucent very user friendly. It cuts relatively fast for an oil stone and leaves a very even, fine finish - better then the surgical black stone I had. That's why I've been patient with flattening it; I like the stone a lot. From the translucent to a horse butt strop charged with green crayon gives me a very nice edge, one that is perfectly satisfactory for my work. And it's a lot less messy and maintenance intensive than my water stones.

I must say however, that I still use my water stones for my Japanese chisels. I've tried my oil stones on my Japanese blades and they work OK, but they didn't seem to cut the hard steel very fast. It may be purely a subjective matter, but I like the water stone process with my Japanese chisels, including the final polish with my natural honyama stone. I freehand sharpen and it's a tactile thing. The feel is different and I prefer it to oil stones with my Japanese blades. I'm willing to put up with the fuss and the mess of water stones for my favorite chisels.

Hank

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#16

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

wilbur

I haven’t tried the Atoma 1200 grit. I have tried other diamond sharpening systems in higher grits, and I’d rather use waterstones.

The main advantage of the Atoma 400 in sharpening is that it will remove metal fast while remaining flat. For me, I can manage a 1000 grit waterstone so that I have to do a relative minimum of flattening, so diamond plates don’t have an advantage there any more.

In addition, I find that diamonds give me a “fingernails on a chalkboard” feeling that I’d rather not deal with. Waterstones are just nice to use.

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#17

Arkansas stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Arkansas stones become a lot coarser if they are abraded. I have never flattened or abraded my black Arkansas, in use since 1976. It still measures 1.000 inches thick. If you want a coarser stone use a Washita or soft Arkansas; there is no point in scratching a fine stone unless you want it to work like a cheaper soft Arkansas.

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#18

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hank,

Excellent detailed account! Your remarks about the feel of a stone resonate with me. It's what I like about water/ceramic stones. Also, I like to see the black streaks on every stroke, as proof that steel is coming off. I used to use a lot more water, than now--now I just use a spray bottle. And to flatten/deswarf/condition them, I have used sandpaper on glass, concrete block, rubbing them together, etc. The Atoma 400 beats them all for convenience and speed.

I hear you about the oilstones being so easy to manage--that's a big plus.

I have a natural finish stone that Kayoko bought in Japan after consulting with Yataiki about it--so I know how you feel about that natural stone. I don't like to use anything on it except wide plane and chisel blades. Plough irons and narrow chisels go to manmade only. Or loose diamond on iron.

Thanks for the great account of your experiences!

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#19

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

Hank Knight

Wiley,

Kayoko found my finish stone too. I had asked her to keep her eyes open for one. She called months later to tell me she had found one. I swallowed hard when she told me how much it cost, but I had comitted to her and wouldn't let her down. It's a great stone and it really shines with my Japanese blades. I don't use it on anything else.

It's my understanding that Kayoko had (still has?) the privilege, on occasion, of selecting natural stones from a large collection from various quarries before they are offered for market. Wherever she finds them, she comes up with great stones.

Hank

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#20

Re: Arkansas stones

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Warren,

That's really interesting, and since I know so little about novaculite, it's mysterious. I think I understand that novaculite is SiO2, and that it is graded by density (specific gravity), i.e., smaller more tightly packed crystals are 'hard' or 'translucent' Arkansas. And that's my limit.

And the dense rock retains cutting power after decades of use and doesn't glaze over or slough off material--can someone comment on why this is? Or straighten out my thinking?

I understand it works, whether I get it or not, but am just curious. Perhaps others are as well.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#21

Re: Arkansas stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Arkansas stones are partly metamorphosed, it is like the crystals are slightly melted together. They are good at smoothing off irregularities and thus polishing an edge, not so good at removing material from a smooth surface. So the action sort of shuts down as the surface becomes smooth. It is as if crevices do the cutting, catching on rough spots, not like the stone's protuberances are digging into the surface. There is not loose grit floating around.

Forty years ago workers were sort of mystified by the newly imported Japanese stones, not used to loose grit. Today they are expecting Arkansas stones to behave like water stones.

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#22

Re: Arkansas stones - Thank you Warren

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Your description of the crevasses in the stone cutting the rough spots off the tool really makes sense to me and explains (for me anyway, (it is a sharpening discussion after all)) what I have experienced with Arkansas stones, water stones and so on.

Thank you.

Bob in NJ

Re: Early note on Atoma 400

#23

Re: Arkansas stones

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Warren,

Thank you! That is a wonderfully clear explanation and comparison of the two types of stones. I've never heard anyone explain it before.

Your account also explains Hank Knight's observation that abrading the surface only has a temporary effect--the dense novaculite does not shed particles in use in the first place, so as soon as the abraded edges get worried down in use, you're back to where you were.

Thanks very much!

Wiley