New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

Posts

A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#1

A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've been helping my son clear out a garage - an older gentleman died and the family needs the garage emptied to store furniture while they rent the house.

This was one of the finds from the second week of clearing, a square and bevel from the Fred C. Breul Tool Works of Connecticut, stamped "Fox's" and "Patented 1921."


This sure looks like one of the ancestors of the modern aluminum (or plastic, gag me!) one-piece speed square. It may not be obvious from my not very good picture that the vertical portion of it, as it appears in the picture, is a stock, with flanges on each side that would be held against the edge of the work, as with the stock of a try square.

But I'm puzzled by the extension of the top beam (the square part rather than the beveled part) past the stock. When would this be useful?

There's not much on the Internet about this design. I found one discussion in the OldTools archives, but it focuses on the patent history rather than the use of the tool. All the other Internet listings are just various auctions/sales of other examples of the tool.


OldTool Archives post on the subject

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#3

Thanks.  Missed that in the patent info I'd seen


Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#4

Speed Square bias..

Bruce McCrory

Bill said:

This sure looks like one of the ancestors of the modern aluminum (or plastic, gag me!) one-piece speed square.

I have an issue with those of us who feel that all tools should be made of toxic metals--see, California labels on, presumably, all metal tools offered for sale--and/or endangered, exotic woods.

I have spent a good portion of my career pushing pencil and pen into plastic "speed squares" as Bill describes them, and no buildings fell down, looked crooked--except through chemically altered minds (builder's, not me)--and, usually produced a closed polygon (pretty close).

One advantage of plastic over wood, or metal, is that the out of square plastic is readily recognized, is no longer a closed triangle. The broken tool then becomes a more useful Frisbee, or boomerang. A broken, rather, bent and deformed metal tool will simply make the user appear to be a drug addict, until he discovers the problem. Which is after the building is finished.

In defense of Bill's [flippant insult] comment, most if not all plastic bags carry a gag hazard warning label, even in the State of California. However, drafting triangles and plastic speed squares don't, to my knowledge, bear such label. So, yes, Bill may gag on one.

p.s. Normally, this post should be pickled with emoticons. However, I view them a distraction.

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#5

Re: Speed Square bias..

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Good points; and I was, yes, flippant and a bit teasing.

The few plastic tools I've had occasion to use* have not impressed me with their quality or durability; but maybe the plastic speed squares differ.

*I exempt, in this comment, plastic bodies for power tools. Generally, a plastic handle on an electric drill will not affect usability, unless the manufacturer chose the wrong plastic or the wrong engineering.

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#6

Re: Speed Square bias..

Bruce McCrory

Bill, now I feel like a heel (heal?). I was overly serious? Picked a sensitive topic to roast? I will pucker my lips and rejoin the army of dead serious people (gag me) in black Pilgrim hats.

Seriously, unless the thing lives under the back window of a car--picture/hear warped audio of disks, 8-tracks, cassettes, etc.--a plastic speed square seems the ideal* material for construction square. They can be left in the rain, thrown, accidentally cut, etc.. Just avoid heat.

*) One assumes that a laser tool will not be treated like a Frisbee.

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#7

Plastic not quite ideal

John in NM

I prefer the aluminum ones, because they have just enough mass for tapping something into place, earning them the nickname "squammer" :D

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#8

Oh, not to worry, Bruce

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I didn't mean to sound ticked off/offended. I was, in fact, interested to hear that someone in the trade found plastic preferable. And I'm aware that many construction tools get the [insert bad words here] knocked out of them in the course of the day. I was raised on combo squares as the tool of preference, and, for my remodeling work, continue to prefer them over a speed square, mainly because I can pull back the rule and test square in odd spots where a speed square wouldn't fit. It also serves as a pencil marking gauge when I need to mark out odd cuts - a common thing on our old house. But maybe I'm just not understanding the uses of the speed square correctly.

And, yeah, I do have to watch it with the combination square - not using it as a hammer, for instance. I've dedicated one square to carpentry use, hoping the shop square will stay square.

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#9

I have one. Somewhere?

Bruce McCrory

I am actually the guy with the pencil, and it used to be: T-square. A good contractor friend introduced me to the speed square years ago. But it didn't work very well on velum. :D The t-square plastic edges crazed and fell apart about the time the Mayline bar was retired and it's building dust somewhere. The costliest printers "stretch" CAD generated plans to less accurate scale than they were when hand drawn; and I still try to use a scale as a straight edge. But still, 'do not scale drawings'.

Checkmate. You win this game, Bill. ;)

I like "squammer".

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#10

Plastic Edge T-Square

Jerry Nicholson

I still have the plastic edged T-Square that was part of my start-up kit when I started to college. No crazing at all. The markings say that it is a Doric made by K&E, part number 8819-24. The plastic triangles I got at the same time are a good bit beat up but not crazed.

Maybe 1954 was a good year for plastic drawing tools.

Jerry

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#11

Not just Dustin and the Graduate...

Bruce McCrory

You do have a point that many have wondered about. Naturally, I did not salvage the remains, and to be honest, am not sure of the provenance of the shattered tool.

I do have knowledge (well, recollection) of 1954 plastics, however. My brother and Father built a model manufactured then. I maintained a long-term lust for that particular model. Then, years later acquired it and a few more of its series. I am only a collector of that series. Research indicates the model was one of the early plastic kits.

Simple castings were oddly gyp-boardish in texture and Nylon-ish in flex. The first runs of this kit included glass-like parts for cylinders, or "blown" pieces. The glass parts were very fragile, and the T-square plastic always reminded me of the model. It began fracturing even while I used it.

So, I can only presume that the t-square edges were of less durable plastic type than my workday Frisbees; and later speed squares. Also, yours may have been from a plastic generation that was not troubled with obsolescence by design policies.

Now, we know why plastics were the next big investment.

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#12

On the durability of "plastic"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First let's define what we are talking about. A plastic is a synthetic polymer that has plastic properties. A synthetic polymer is a very long molecule made up of carbon, hydrogen and often additionally oxygen, nitrogen and perhaps even sulfur. There are thousands of combinations of these elements that will result in a plastic. Even for exactly the same composition the molecule may be larger or smaller, branched or crosslinked.

Additionally, plastics are usually formulated with plasticizers, antioxidants, UV inhibitors, mold release agents, colorants, fillers, reinforcing fibers, etc.

Everything I have mentioned above affects the life of a plastic part with composition and the stabilizers having the greatest effect, as well as the additional variable of how the plastic was processed having a significant effect.

The 3" tall book pictured describes a few of the common plastics.

PIC

1950's, and later, quality drafting supplies are most probably cellulose acetate, a plastic made by combining acetic acid with cellulose from trees or cotton fiber. This plastic is stabilized with various additives and plasticized to facilitate molding. If the material was formulated for long life and toughness and not damaged in molding, a triangle will last a long time. Mine have lasted since 1958. Cheap drafting supplies could have been made from poly(styrene) which is not as tough. If customers wanted to bear the cost a triangle could be made from polycarbonate, a plastic used in tank windows that will stop a 50 cal. bullet (I have seen the demo).

The bottom line- calling something a plastic reveals nothing about its properties or service life. Absent knowing something about the additives and details of processing even knowing the composition-nylon, polyester, acrylic, styrene, etc- doesn't shed light on expected service life.

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#13

Re: On the durability of "plastic"

Bruce McCrory

Hi, Bill. You don't wear glasses. Because, if you did you would be wondering if you could stand in front of a tank and not blink when the fireworks started. 8)

I think plastics (ie: polymers) fall into the same category as wood species do for people who only consume them. Or, people who swat at a bug and don't know its environmental niche. Your polymer manual must be related to a non-permanent additive. I used to have Nylon combs that shed constituents as prolifically as my hair. And, I don't think Mrs. Robinson wore any of the above. She is on page what?

I am pretty sure it doesn't matter to this thread what species the Frisbee and squammer fall into. We're just pleased to incorporate your encyclopedia into the blooming forest of humor. Thank you.:)

Re: A puzzling design for a square *LINK*

#14

for example

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Poly(ethylene) sheeting lasts less than a summer in the TN sun before the long molecules get chopped up by the sun and oxygen into smaller pieces and it becomes brittle. Yet this same plastic, optimally stabilized for outdoor exposure, has lasted for more than 20 years as electric fence insulators. As they say, it's all in the details.