Re: Advantage of the Peavey... Or false bias
TomD
I am having trouble visualizing that. I haven't encountered the situation in which the two can be brought into play, and the hook actually holds (leaving aside geometry busters where there is a runt limb, etc.... On the other hand, a 16-24 inch log is big for me, and that is an Ont. log, which is where I have only a cant hook (can't hook
). In NB I have both, but the logs only rarely get that large, so maybe it is just and experience thing. Maybe there is something on youtube where on can see the tool in action on really large longs.
By the way, a cant hook often does have a set of teeth facing inward, that do engage log surfaces, and can geometrically be deployed on larger logs.
There is a false bias that we tend to have in which there is an assumption that the fact that there are two tools means that there is a reason for their separate existence. Like the reason there is a Mac computer was for creative people (people who can't find the on switch of a computer without a jedi guide), while IBM was for business people (people who's secretaries, back in the day, did all the "computing"). A woodworking example would be this discussion 100 years from now looking at claw hammers. Is the ripping claw for larger nails, or 2x lumber of a larger size, or is it in fact a regional preference that became a national preference. I do have examples of both hammers, so if my stuff fell into conservator hands, and they traced my windbaggery online, they might assume I would only have both types if they were separately useful, while in my case it is a regional thing, combined with inheriting other people's hammers in the family. All the hammers I have personally bought have ripping claws.
Another thing that happens is that one goes into the store and buys a hook. Then one needs another. One buys the other type, thinking it might be useful for something (obviously not so useful that we can figure out for the most part why), just in case.