New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Peavey log roller is in service

Posts

Peavey log roller is in service

#1

Peavey log roller is in service

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


In the end physics turned out to reliably predict how to get the point driven in. I tried various approaches but what got it seated was to put handle in vice with end of handle on concrete floor(point end sticking up). Then put a piece of seasoned hickory limb on the point to protect the point and whacked the daylights out of it with a 3 pound hammer. Seated easily where as the reverse did nothing. The idea is that the low mass object, in this case the point, needs to be accelerated(whacked) into the high mass object, in this case the relatively heavy handle. Same situation as driving a light hammer handle into a relatively heavy hammer head.

Re: Peavey log roller is in service

#2

Advantage of the Peavey

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Looks good, Bill. I think your picture can help show the advantage of the Peavey over the cant hook. With the log shown a cant hook would do just as well because the spike does not come into play. However with a larger log, the cant hook can't get around the circumference so easily and becomes ineffective or even useless to get a grip. The Peavey can grip a large log with both the spike and the hook and is thus more effective.

I have been in situations where I was unable to grip with a cant hook and chucked it aside in favor of a Peavey. You could have a large cant hook for large logs and a small one for small logs; the Peavey is effective over a greater range.

Re: Peavey log roller is in service

#3

got it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I rehandled my cant hook I foolishly put a short 3' handle on it. I can't roll a large log with it for I am not strong enough. Including spike, this handle is 4 1/2'. So it will naturally happen that the peavey will become the log roller of choice for large logs. (I still may not be strong enough!)

Re: Peavey log roller is in service

#4

Re: Advantage of the Peavey...  Or false bias

TomD

I am having trouble visualizing that. I haven't encountered the situation in which the two can be brought into play, and the hook actually holds (leaving aside geometry busters where there is a runt limb, etc.... On the other hand, a 16-24 inch log is big for me, and that is an Ont. log, which is where I have only a cant hook (can't hook :)). In NB I have both, but the logs only rarely get that large, so maybe it is just and experience thing. Maybe there is something on youtube where on can see the tool in action on really large longs.

By the way, a cant hook often does have a set of teeth facing inward, that do engage log surfaces, and can geometrically be deployed on larger logs.

There is a false bias that we tend to have in which there is an assumption that the fact that there are two tools means that there is a reason for their separate existence. Like the reason there is a Mac computer was for creative people (people who can't find the on switch of a computer without a jedi guide), while IBM was for business people (people who's secretaries, back in the day, did all the "computing"). A woodworking example would be this discussion 100 years from now looking at claw hammers. Is the ripping claw for larger nails, or 2x lumber of a larger size, or is it in fact a regional preference that became a national preference. I do have examples of both hammers, so if my stuff fell into conservator hands, and they traced my windbaggery online, they might assume I would only have both types if they were separately useful, while in my case it is a regional thing, combined with inheriting other people's hammers in the family. All the hammers I have personally bought have ripping claws.

Another thing that happens is that one goes into the store and buys a hook. Then one needs another. One buys the other type, thinking it might be useful for something (obviously not so useful that we can figure out for the most part why), just in case.

Re: Peavey log roller is in service

#5

Re: got it

TomD

Thanks for the update. You seem to have naturally fallen upon the normal handle disposition. I have yet to redo mine because my lathe will barely stretch to 36" finished, though I guess I could just use a spokeshave. I need to make a longer bed.

Re: Peavey log roller is in service

#6

Re: Advantage of the Peavey...  Or false bias

Bruce McCrory

Wow! Bags, hammers, and computers in one post, about peaveys too!

I was surfing for historical records of peaveys, cants, and others. Because my grandpa painted a picture of loggers in PA during the late 19th. He was pretty realistic in representation. His people had longer poles, over head height. I found one photo with one man who had the peavey I remember. It even had the open hook, positioned at top, and of smaller proportions that I recall.

I don't remember any peaveys I used with stiff hinging. The hook seemed to want to swing and flop by gravity. So the open hook must be a variant. It would certainly help with balance.