New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Historical scrub plane question

Posts

Historical scrub plane question

#1

Historical scrub plane question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I got to see the tool chest of a late 1800's German emigrant woodworker that worked on architectural projects- houses and churches. There was what was described as a scrub plane in the chest. It was a very light weight plane about as long as a #4, more narrow than a #4, it had a single blade that was exceptionally thin, and the sole was highly radiused such that it could have been used to make cove molding as well as scrubbing.

What was the advantage of the round sole on this plane and how common was this format of scrub plane vs flat sole and cambered blade?

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#2

Re: Historical scrub plane question

Kees

You can find quite a few of these planes in The Netherlands too. With a front and a back tote. They came in three versions, concave, flat or convex bottom. The first was called a "mastschaaf", mast plane. The last was a "gootschaaf" gutter plane.

But a lot of these gutter planes have been found, and one wonders how many gutters needed to be planed. So maybe indeed they were used like a scrubplane too.

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#3

Re: Historical scrub plane question

David Churnega

I am no expert. These may have been used in making large pieces of molding as I suspect that American gutter planes were used.

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#4

Re: Historical scrub plane question

Bruce McCrory

I inherited some tools from a carpenter cousin of some remoteness who worked the 1870s and onward, in Des Moines, IA. The kit, no tool box included, contained a substantial sized wood "gutter plane". It was the explanation given to me back in the 1960s.

From a FWW article, the radiused plane is able to handle making coves of various radii. Wood gutters of the period were approximately the same trough size.

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#5

Re: Historical scrub plane question

Patrick Gibbons

I think they mislabeled it; something I see often. Salaman shows a picture of what you describe under his entry for a spout plane which Americans call a gutter plane. So many items requiring concavity are no longer fashioned from wood. A perusal of Salaman reveals many tools that were useful to someone wanting to accomplish a concave shape in one way or another. Very few are available, let alone known, today. In a week or so I'll show you one I'm making.

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#8

Re: wood

TomD

That doesn, t sound like a scrub plane. And if it was, I am not sure where that leaves those theorists wh believe they are a modern invention and not an authentic plane from the past

Those who wonder about stuff like guters should read The Village Carpenter, great fun anyway, I can, t recall anything about gutters, but heavy jobs of that type certainly.

When using a modern scrub, the flat sole is key, for depth of cut, and to get the plane to run on top negative space as tthe job progresses. Otherwise it tends to fall into the trenches, where it stops cutting.

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#9

Re: Scrub = Flat Sole

Bruce McCrory

That makes sense! Flat sole. 8)

BTW, I am trying to level a glulam right now.

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#10

How large was the mouth opening?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Flattening planes usually have a mouth you can throw a large shaving through.

Re: Historical scrub plane question

#11

Re: How large was the mouth opening?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The mouths in all of the planes in this collection were widely gapped.