New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Saw Rx...

Posts

Saw Rx...

#1

Saw Rx...

edward in vancouver

I picked up a Spear & Jackson tennon saw a few years back and it's sat in a cupboard since then. The tote is in pretty good shape,as are the three split saw nuts, and the spine is "warranteed cast steel", but the plate is toast. It was dropped a few times on the toe and the plate is kinked and bent, pitted, but more importantly it's only 2 1/4" high under the spine.

I contacted Dom at TGIAG, but he doesn't ship to Canada anymore. I have a bunch of "project saws" I'm willing to cannibilize, but the plates are all too thick. Same for a fairly nice "Craftsman" miterbox saw @11tpi that I though of chopping down, but its "Krome edge" and very thick. What other alternatives are there for a new plate? Are there any cheapo "home despot" saws I could buy and file off the teeth and make a new plate from?

Regards,

Edward

Re: Saw Rx...

#2

Re: Saw Rx...

craig_d

Probably the easiest way to get a plate is to buy a drywall knife, they are nice steel and thin. Don't know the grade or hardness of the steel but I've seen several nice saws made with them.

Or buy spring steel shim stock (1095 51 Rc hardness), I wonder if a auto parts place would have it? I got several sheets from Enco, not expensive but you get way more than you'll ever need. If you don't have a sheer, it can be a PINTA to cut and not induce twisting (I posted a old saw w/new plate a couple of weeks ago). If you want to remove the blue, Titebond III works great (why or how I have no idea) or sand with vinegar or citric acid (which is what I actually do).

Get several nice (ie hard to find) 4"? triple taper files, filing teeth really eats them up.

Re: Saw Rx...

#3

Re: Saw Rx...

Patrick Gibbons

McMaster, or whatever their name is, sells 1095 spring steel in many gauges and lengths. I have never done this but have thought about doing it. I would imagine making a few saws and various scrapers and some left over for scratch stock. http://www.mcmaster.com/#spring-steel/=tozd99

Re: Saw Rx...

#4

Re: Saw Rx... *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

Here's the link.


http://www.mcmaster.com/#spring-steel/=tozd99

Re: Saw Rx...

#5

Re: Saw Rx...

Patrick Gibbons

Where I live, a sharpening service has an old foley belsaw toothing machine. They will retooth a saw. I imagine that would include toothing a new plate. I've run into a metal shop that was willing to cut out saw plates on a CAD/CAM milling machine. I suspect there are similar resources available in your neck of the woods. All this begs the question. Is it worth doing?

Re: Saw Rx...

#6

Re: Saw Rx., is it worth doing?

edward in vancouver

Firstly, thank you for all of your replies.

The big question is, "Is it worth it?"

I can buy a Veritas tennon saw for $85.00 and it will work great right out of the box. That's an option, and a pretty realistic one.

So I paid $5.00 for the saw a couple of years ago. Let' say I pay another $10.00 for some kind of a plate, and another $10-15 for files and parts/hardware for a homemade saw vise. Theoretically I'm cheaper off even though I'll be spending a lot of time filing and futzing around. That's another option, not a fantastic one, but a decent option

There is a pretty good saw service here, they gave me a quote of $50.00 to cut new teeth on a plate (which I supply) and then file and set each tooth. All of this is done by machine. So that's another option--not a good one, but an option.

There are no "Saw Doctors" around here. About 4 years ago I bought an Adria dt saw through the classifieds here on W.C. Adria saws are located here in Vancouver--matter of fact right on the UBC (university of British Columbia) campus. I contacted Edi S. and asked him if he could sharpen my Adria dt saw, as I have been using it for a while and it was getting dull. He said no, he doesn't do sharpening--even on his own saws, and told me his best guy had passed on a few years back and didn't know of anyone in the area who could that.

So, sooner or later, I'm going to have to learn how to file a saw. I've got a couple of flea market rejects I can practice on, or I could go whole hog and learn to cut teeth on a drywall knife.

What do you guys think?

Edward

Re: Saw Rx...

#7

Re: Saw Rx., is it worth doing?

Patrick Gibbons

There's no correct answer to the question and I think you have the right attitude. You can clamp a saw to the plate to get the teeth spacing right. For me, the time involved is more important than the money. The $50 for cutting the teeth might be worthwhile to speed up the process and get the spacing right. Then you could hand sharpen yourself for a proper sharpness. Practicing on flea market rejects is a great use of the resource. What's left can be made into scrapers and smaller saw blades. It's a hobby. Do what makes sense for you at this time. Even if the effort is less than stellar, the sky's the limit on what you'll learn.

Re: Saw Rx...

#8

Re: Saw Rx., is it worth doing?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Edward and all,

I suggest not putting any money into that saw. Few of us can make a saw equal to LV's for the same buck, and you'd have the equal of $85 in your homemade saw before you were done. And it wouldn't be a Spear and Jackson anymore either.

is the saw plate truly unfixable? I've not done this, but have seen described how a smith with a hammer can straighten steel by skillful hammering. You could make a learning experience of that saw plate, and then come tell tales about it, for better or worse!

The worst you can come out if you try to salvage the saw is to have some great scraper stock, same as what you have right now.

If you have the time to make a saw plate, you have the time to try to straighten that plate with a hammer and rudimentary anvil.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Saw Rx...

#9

Re: Saw Rx., is it worth doing?

edward in vancouver

Thanks for the replies.

Wiley, the plate measures a scant 2" from under the spine, and it's got a pretty bad kink about 2" in from the toe. That's not to say I'll trash the old plate, I can still keep it and swap it out if I ever want to, but I'd like to use the saw for cutting tennons, and that means a bit deeper than 2".

As I've said before, the tote is pretty nice shape, both horns still intact and no major chips or cracks and no repairs, saw nuts are in good shape too, and the spine is a very heavy cast steel.

In any case, time isn't ticking on this one, and if I really want to get serious, I'd better learn some basics of saw filing on some flea market junkers before I start on this project.

As always, thank you for your replies.

Re: Saw Rx...

#10

Re: Saw Rx...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think the easiest thing might be to just look for another Spear & Jackson saw. I use a Spear & Jackson saw that answers your description, warranted cast steel, split saw nuts, 2 1/4 inches under the spine; I paid $10 for it, the most I ever paid for a back saw. If you really like the handle you could put it on another saw. A 100 year old saw with a broken handle is not worth very much.

Re: Saw Rx...

#11

Re: Saw Rx...

Matthew Robinette

I saw if you want to try refurbishing the saw go for it will be money well spent and you be able to say you did it. The cost may be higher than if you bought one but the experience will be priceless.