New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

pinless leg vise (chain?)

Posts

pinless leg vise (chain?)

#1

pinless leg vise (chain?)

Adrian

A couple years ago I built a 30" tall bench and installed a glide vise with only 8.5" between the top of the parallel guide and the bottom of the screw. I love the action of the vise, but I'm annoyed by the pin. I'm not annoyed by the need to bend over. I bend over all the time. I'm annoyed because I forget to adjust it. I'm annoyed because when I do adjust it I almost always get it wrong the first time and have to back off the vise and try again. And after two years I'm still finding it annoying. So I'm pondering again ways to go pinless. The problem is that my vise geometry appears to make this troublesome. The cross-cross won't fit. Mcguire's system looks great, but seems impossible to retrofit. AYS sells a chain but it may not work smoothly with my geometry--Jim has offered me a guarantee if I'm not happy. (Has anybody tried it with a screw close to the parallel guide?) Of the options, only the chain seems like a candidate.

Does anybody have any suggestions?

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#3

Re: AYS Leg Vise Chain Adjuster

Adrian

I've seen your review. The problem is that I only have 8.5 inches between the top of my parallel guide and my screw, and Jim is not sure the chain will work with this configuration. I assume your vise geometry is different. All the reviews I've seen of the AYS chain are positive, but Jim recommends that you have 12" between the parallel guide and the screw. I have not seen anybody state that they installed the chain on a vise like mine and good good results, and Jim said he did one test with a short spacing like I have and it worked, but wasn't very smooth.

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#4

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

TomD

"I'm annoyed because when I do adjust it I almost always get it wrong the first time and have to back off the vise and try again."

This would be the one that would drive me nutty. I would think you could just calibrate the holes for different thickneses. If you were still off my smidges you could make a drop in shim for the vise jaws. There might still be some residual skill element like the mechanic who faultlessly chooses the perfect wrench.

Rarely does the more technical solution come with zero problems of it's own, so you have to weigh that against the desire to bail from a system that you are not perfectly happy with. Of course if like Derek you enjoy the chase as much as anything else, that's fine too. The technology we live with today endlessly holds out the promise of some perfect product down the road. Rejecting the call of that product is almost as immoral as in the past was idleness or a poor work ethic. Solving problems leads to stuff like Steve Jobshood. But part of hand tool woodworking is letting skill stand in place of technology for some reason. To each their own.

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#6

Re: pinless leg vise (ratchets?)

Adrian

I saw that ratcheting vise. In fact, that was what prompted me to start thinking about eliminating my pin again. I can't tell if that vise would solve my problem or not. I guess you can release the ratchet, snug up the vise, and then engage the ratchet?

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#7

craigd

Re: pinless leg vise (ratchets?)

craigd

I guess you can release the ratchet, snug up the vise, and then engage the ratchet?

Yeah - there is lever up under the bench top that you use to lift the latch. I think you could also just leave it long and raise it with your toe. The long connecting rod seems a bit mickey mouse but overall, I really like the looks of it.

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#8

Re: AYS Leg Vise Chain Adjuster

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Adrian

I measured my set up: there is 12" between the parallel guide and the wooden screw, and then 8" from the screw to the top of the bench.

That's how it was at the start, before I added the AYS chain. I have no idea how other dimensions work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#9

Re: AYS Leg Vise Chain Adjuster

Adrian

I have 10" between the screw and the top of the parallel guide and 10" between the screw and the benchtop. The metal nut surrounding the screw extends an inch, so I have 9" of space to work with. I thought about the idea of trimming an inch of the top of the parallel guide to give more space, or replacing the parallel guide with one made of metal that could be much shorter, and hence allow more room for the chain. Of course, both of these changes are hard to reverse. One nice feature of the chain is that if I don't like it, or if it presents some complication or fails somehow (a possibility suggested by another poster), it's possible to go back to the old pin.

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#10

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

AlanWS

It sounds to me as if the difference in your vise configuration boils down to a larger angle change. By that I mean if the guide is far from the work clamped, being off a little in thickness results in a fairly small vertical angle of misalignment between the vise jaw and the work. With the pivot point closer, the same thickness error leads to a larger and more annoying angle. That means you need to place the pin more accurately with the closer pivot.

It may be that simply using the work you plan to clamp as a gauge to set the pin will solve your problem: hold the stock against the chop and put the pin in the hole closest to stock thickness, that's a little over so the top of the vise closes first.

One thing the chain vise could allow is fine tuning of that angle on the fly, in a way not practical with any of the other systems I'm aware of. Imagine you attached the chain to the vise chop with a bolt through the chop, attached to a knob to turn it in and out a little bit. This is not generally needed, but if it were. the chain is one of few schemes that would allow it.

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#11

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

Adrian

It seems like you're right about the increased sensitivity to pin position for my configuration, though it's not obvious that the difference is enough to be a practical consideration. If Derek has 8" at the top and 12" at the bottom that's a ratio of 3/4 as compared to my ratio of 1. It's not that big of a difference.

It seems like if I installed leather pads of the same thickness that are on the chop down by my parallel guide then I could do as you say---use the workpieces to figure out where to put the pin by first placing the workpiece down at the bottom and closing the vise and then backing off the vise until the next hole is revealed, inserting the pin, lifting up the workpiece and clamping. This process doesn't sound particularly convenient.

I hadn't given any thought to the ability to adjust the clamping angle that the chain mechanism provides. Why would I want to change it?

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#12

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

AlanWS

The position of the screw affects how hard you need to crank it down to get the same clamping force, but does not affect the angle of the chop on the work unless you clamp hard enough to bend the chop. The distance between the guide and the work is what determines the sensitivity of the angle to guide setting: the shorter that distance, the more the angle varies as you move the guide in or out the same amount. If your guide is accurately set, your vise should work; as you point out, your 17" is not too different from Derek's 20". If there's room for the hardware, I don't see any reason the chain would be a problem.

As far as the fine adjust comments went, I wasn't suggesting that you'd need it, but only saying that if you did run into a problem with the angle, this would be another approach to fixing it on the fly that is not available to other designs. It would be equivalent to moving the pin holes in your guide in or out a very small amount.

I didn't at first see how close to usual the dimensions of your vise were. I was responding to the screw being 8.5" below the top, and the guide being "close" to the screw. I don't think 8.5" is close enough to cause any problems.

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#13

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

Adrian

"The distance between the guide and the work is what determines the sensitivity of the angle to guide setting: the shorter that distance, the more the angle varies as you move the guide in or out the same amount."

Actually isn't the angle determined by the distance between the parallel guide and the *screw*?

Jim seemed to be concerned about larger forces on the chain with my configuration, but I'm not convinced there's really much of a difference. If I understand the forces properly, my vise, where the screw is centered, will put half the force on the work and half on the guide (or chain). And Derek's vise which has 12 inches below and 8 inches above will put 8/20 = 40% of the force on the guide (or chain). Doesn't seem like much of a difference (25% more load on the chain).

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

#14

Re: pinless leg vise (chain?)

AlanWS

I agree that there should be no problem with the chain in terms of force applied, even if a little more is needed for your configuration.

The angle I'm talking about is the angle of the chop compared to vertical when the chop first hits the work. If the guide is too far in, it will touch only on the bottom, and if the guide is too far out, it will touch only on top. A very slight misalignment to touch first on top and deform to contact more as it's tightened is optimal. All I was saying is that the angle gets more sensitive to guide setting as the guide to top distance shortens. But yours is so close to normal, I don't think there's anything to worry about.