New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

Posts

Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

#1

Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

don stephan

Last spring I experimented using poplar making a through tenon mockup for a trestle table rail and post. Formed the tenon using table saw and 1/2" stacked dado blade set. Carefully laid out both sides of the mortise, using only one edge of the post and adjustable square, drilled the majority and then carefully chopped to the edges with wider chisels. Results were not as crisp as I had hoped. I'll have to practice more, any tips and tricks would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

#2

Re: Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Don,

Suggest:

1. Make the tenon a little long, then cut off 3/8" of it to serve as a template. This way, you're not relying entirely on measurement and layout.

2. After you locate your mortise corners both sides, lay the 'template' over them (this will help correct any inadvertent measurement slop), and pencil around the template taking care it doesn't move (you could clamp it on while pencilling).

3. Knife in the mortise outline before beginning the drilling/chopping. Set the knife gauge so that the knife is just shaving the inside of the pencil lines. If the gauge won't reach the mortise ends, then clamp a batten across the post, and knife in the ends. It is this knifing that is going to create the crispness. Make multiple passes with the gauge, starting very lightly, and use several passes to knife in deeply. It is preferable to have the knife bevel to the waste side (interior) of the mortise; in this case, start lightly and use multiple cuts, because the gauge may have a tendency to push the fence off the work, due to the bevel being inside.

4. Work from both ends of mortise in toward the middle. When done, test both sides of the mortise with the actual tenon, so you know you have fit. If it's still a little tight, use file or rasp to get the final fit.

5. [option--make shoulders within the mortise] After you've knifed in both sides of the mortise, but before drilling/chopping, use your chisels to lift out a first course, so as to create shoulders to work within for the balance of the waste removal. To do this, use a chisel the width of the mortise, and go down the mortise from end to end, making vertical chisel cuts about an 1/8" deep, every 1/8". This will break the grain of the mortise, so you're left with mostly rubble to lift out with the same chisel, used bevel down.

If the mortise outline is well-knifed, this last step is not strictly necessary, but can be helpful in avoiding slipping and over-cutting the mortise boundary by mistake.

Wiley

Re: Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

#3

Re: Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

Bob Lang

I think of the layout lines on the show side as the final cuts, even though I make them first with a knife and a gauge as Wiley suggests. If these are in the right place, all you need to worry about is not messing them up as you get the rest of the wood out of the way and bring the tenon to final size. Work within those lines however you remove the waste.

When you make the tenon, you can fit from the outside in; when you can get the end of the tenon to fit nicely in the hole, you're almost there. Make the tenon too long to start with and chamfer the ends.

For appearance sake, only that little bit of material that shows on the outside is critical. For the rest of the joint, you have some margin where you don't need to fuss so much. You can chamfer the shoulder side of the mortise to make getting the tenon started easier, and the mortise can be tapered a tiny bit in that direction.

You need to be able to tell where to remove material to get the joint to fit. If your eyes and available light are good, you'll see shiny areas where the two parts rub. An alternative is to rub chalk or lead from a soft pencil on the tenon before a trial fit.

Bob Lang

Re: Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

#4

Re: Very Clean Thru Mortise and Tenon

TomD

First off, start with the mortise not the tenon, there are many ways to very accurately remove tiny amounts of tenon, relative to the same on the mortise.

To make a clean mortise you can cut it with a router. My power tools for one-offs routine is hollow chisel mortiser, or router for the mortise, and I bandsaw the tenon, and trim on the router table.

If you are doing it by hand, the standard method is to use a chisel to chop the mortise. On cabinet sized mortises holes do not help. Or if you are using drilled holes you want them small enough to allow the chisel to form all visible parts. So for instance on 3/4 stock your mortise might be as thin a 1/4. you would want about 1/16th to hold the chisel, leaving only 1/8 for holes. Basically pointless as the chisel can easily excavate all the material, drilling holes is just one more thing to do and to go wrong. The hollow chisel machine can use almost a full size hole, but then it sometimes too will leave nasty marks, anyway, it is a powerfully stiff machine.

On larger work like timber frames, you need maybe 1/8th to hold the chisel, and the tenon could be 2 inches, and your machine might end up drilling 1 3/4 holes, so the upside to drilled holes is a lot greater.

When drilling holes, the main two methods are to chop with the edge perp to the grain, for everything you cut. Or you can do some paring. In either case you will probably have cleaner results on throughs if you work from both sides. Particularly with the paring approach.

For the tenons the two best/easiest methods to reduce the tenon by hairs are with a router table, or with a hand plane. You do not absolutely need a shoulder plane. If you don't have one use a chisel to remove the material near the shoulder, this will probably overcut, but you should have plenty of strength with modern glues. The rest of the tenon is now a raised plane and you can get your block plane, etc... in there to reduce the tenon surface a hair at a time. Use only enough chisel as you have a gap between the edge of your blade and the edge of your plane.

While one can cut perfect mortises with either of these techniques the perfect motises of modern work (mostly as seen in media), are probably a bit of an anachronism since to do work that clean for the most part meant doing work with hidden joints.