New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

Posts

Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#1

Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools Headquarters

As an occasional customer of Lee Valley Tools I have been impressed with their innovative and affordable renditions of classic hand tools. This trip provided insight into the processes used to develop and market these tools, which I hope you all will find interesting. This trip caught LV at a busy time- finishing details of the yearly catalog which is produced in house, preparing for the Woodworking in America show, and building inventory for Christmas and new product introductions.

Lee Valley Tools is comprised of the corporate office, Veritas Tool manufacturing, a catalog sales distribution center and a retail store, all adjacent in Ottawa Canada, 14 additional retail stores across Canada, a corporate warehousing center outside Ottawa, a US mail order distribution center in Ogdensburg, NY and an associated “Skunk Works”, Chestnut Tools. I was afforded the opportunity to visit LV corporate HQ, Veritas Tools manufacturing, the store and the shipping and warehouse center in Ottawa, CA.

The visit revealed how LV designs, manufactures and sells modern upgraded versions of classic hand tools. Using the Veritas spoke shave I will illustrate their process. I do not know if the spoke shave in fact employed all the details I will describe. However, I did see these processes employed for other tools and tools under development.

Concept- An idea for a new tool may come from an employee woodworker, identified by their social media department that trolls social media, or over the fence from customer suggestions. I know firsthand that they respond to customer suggestions because I suggested the Stanley 55 router bit collection and within a few months this collection was available for sale. The availability of these bits enabled me to retire my cantankerous Stanley 55 to collector status.

Design- LV has huge, and growing, hand tool collection. The team charged with design will request the collection librarian to fetch for study the spoke shave examples in the collection. Some potential designs would be developed with an eye toward reducing manufacturing cost, improving ergonomics and improving capability and function over the vintage tools. A few prototype designs would be made conventionally, or from plastic with a 3D printer. These designs would be evaluated by LV staff and consulting woodworkers and perhaps even sited in the near-by store for customer evaluation of their ergonomics.

Manufacturing- Experienced machinists develop the manufacturing processes to efficiently make the spoke shave parts on modern computer controlled machinery. Eli Whitney, the father of mass produced goods, would be proud of the precision that parts can be made on this machinery. Computer aided comparators can quickly compare all critical aspects of a part from a new production run to the design standard with a precision of 0.00001”. Eagle eyed inspectors assemble and test the final product and rework or reject anything not measuring up. A part with a tiny scratch or casting void will be rejected or reworked.

Blades are ground flat on custom designed surface grinders to astonishing flatness and the bevel ground and sharpened so the tool is ready to use upon receipt. A blade ready to use can be a great help to someone new to hand tools and unsure of their sharpening ability. A ready-to-use tool provides a valuable bench mark.

Inventory- Inventory is controlled by state of art software. I was too boggled by its complexity to grasp the details but the bottom line was a computer system that reliably handled the complexity of having the right stuff in the right place on time with minimal labor.

Sales- The tool may be bought from one of the 15 Canadian stores, catalog ordered from their yearly catalog or occasional supplement, or ordered from the web site. I have always been pleased with the shipping cost on a Lee Valley order and I got to see how this cost is kept low. A highly automated system enables “pickers” to fetch the order from inventory and deliver it for shipping, or pick up at the store order counter or drive through “window”. Our credit card is not charged until the shipping label is applied to the package and the exact shipping cost is calculated.

Customer support- The company struck me as paying attention to details everywhere in the organization. For example, shelves of tools line the walls of the customer support call center, located at headquarters I might add! If a customer calls with a tool problem the customer support technician can fetch the tool from the near-by shelf and have it in hand for the discussion.

Summary- These processes deliver tools with exceptional ergonomics, quality and function at an affordable price. LV is an example that exceptional management and modern manufacturing can compete with low labor cost manufacturing when making high quality tools.

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#2

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill and all,

Your excellent report bespeaks a company that is thorough, organized, and shot through with the quality gene from top to bottom.

I was interested in your description of how customer service has immediate access to the tools. It explains a pleasant surprise I had when I called Canada to ask for a specific and obscure measurement on a pair of cast iron legs (for a bench). It was a shot in the dark; I doubted I could get an answer in one call, since obviously the cast iron legs would be in a warehouse somewhere, and customer service would be in an office somewhere else. And that's if I could even convey what I was after. Well, the lady who answered picked up on what I was after right away, and then she said, "Wait just a moment while I go pull the item". Huh, where's she gonna find those 50lb legs at? She came back seemed like inside of 30 seconds (I wasn't counting because I figured I'd be on hold for quite a while). She had one of the leg castings with her, and put a ruler to it while we talked and gave me my answer to exact measurement in a few more seconds. Done!! I was kinda stunned. Wrote her up a commendation and sent it to Robin.

Just one of several above and beyond experiences I've had with LV, from Robin himself to unknown toilers on a work floor somewhere. The entire culture has the values.

Excellent report!!

Wiley

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#3

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If they have a motto it would be "Attention to Detail". The company is more vertically integrated than I could have imagined and appears to be managed by "Walking Around". The vertical integration enables all the details to be controlled and managing by walking around enables the managers to discover the details that lead to improvements.

I once asked one of the extraordinarily pleasant order takers if she ever got to meet Robin. "Yes", she breezily replied, "he drops by". (BTW, that is an opportunity to cut costs. The order takers are so nice to talk to that I never use the more cost cutting computer ordering system.) Ditto for LL Bean.

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#4

Thanks Bill

Patrick Gibbons

Enjoyed your post. Lee Valley helps to make woodworking an important part of my life. I also was interested to hear about their customer service procedure.

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#5

Rob Lee and customer service folks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've also e-mailed Rob about the stunning service I got from one of the customer service staff. What I loved most about his reply was a tone of pride in her work. Not taking credit for it himself; just really proud that she worked for Lee Valley.

I've both been on the front line and supervised it, and I can tell you how much difference it makes to get that kind of support from the boss. I know that you get that kind of customer service by setting the kind of tone that Rob sets, and finding people who want to give that kind of service.

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#6

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

Curt Putnam

Rob Lee is an exceptional and unique individual. I would love to meet his parents simply because they had such a huge part in shaping him. He lives his values as well as making sure that his people share them and share in LV's success. If you haven't yet, read about the the unique salary structure in LV. Read also about the remarkable work that Leonard's charity (the name escapes me) does and which is funded, in no small part, by LV.

Yes, a remarkable family has built a remarkable company. IMHO, the whole thing ought to be studied in great detail by every student wishing to get an MBA.

You might guess that I am, and will be, a fiercely loyal customer. Thanks for the report.

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#7

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Bill. I had the good fortune in January last year to travel to Ottawa with my wife, Lynndy, and spent a wonderful 10 days with Rob and his wife, and the Lee Valley family. Sitting in on design meetings, visiting the factory, obtaining a little insight about how the whole caboodle works from order to shipping, exploring the tool library, meeting old cyber friends for the first time, and making a bunch of new friends .... well, this was a time to remember (I won't tell you about the experience of dogsledding with the Lees! Maybe another time).

I did not take photos within the offices or factory, however I can offer these, which I did post after my return to Oz.

For those that have not travelled to Canada and are curious what it would be like to purchase tools from an actual LV store, here are a few photos.

Apologies for the quality of the pics (had difficulty resizing and retaining any quality).

The way it works at LV is quite different from any other store I have visited. More about this in a moment. First, this is the entrance to the store, taken by my wife Lynndy.


Through the front door ... great music playing in the background. Staff around to help.


The nerve centre of all LV stores is here ...


It's a reference centre, with all the catalogues. In the right corner you will see a computer terminal ...


Each store works by displaying all the items for sale. One of each. They are behind glass or on a wall. Some can be handled, others not. You write down your selection on the computer, and then collect your order at Customer Service ...


Here are some of the displays. First woodworking handtools (of course) ...




A Festool display ...


A hardware display - there is an amazing variety of hinges, handles, drawer pulls, etc here. This is an example of the compact way LV get so many items into a smallish area. ...


Books and DVDs ...


There is also a gardening centre. Lynndy headed there ...


.. and managed to get some some help from one of the staff there (he seemed to be up to speed on everything) ...


Of course, I put in my order while Lynndy was preoccupied ... :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#8

Correction?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Some can be handled, others not." I was told by Rob (I think) that the store is amply staffed to assist anyone wanting to remove an item from a case to scrutinize it.

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#9

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

The wording is from the earlier post. Cut-and-pasted. I think I meant to write back then that some items were out in the open, while others needed a staff member to access.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Trip Report to Lee Valley Tools, Ottawa

#10

Re: Rob Lee and customer service folks

Patrick Gibbons

I'm surprised by how many companies (including ones I've worked for) that are the direct opposite of this. Is it really more profitable to be the crappiest piece of sh@£ in the bunch?