New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

Posts

Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#1

Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

First, LV has some interesting new tools; the medium router plane looks like a good option to pair with the standard router. But my eye was drawn to the new broad hatchet offering. I have the Vaughan but it comes with a double bevel. I have spent many hours over too many years trying to grind it down to a single bevel. I have yet to use it.

The new LV broad hatchet is priced right and comes left or right handed. My questions are, why stainless and why is the handle maple? I worry about ease of sharpening, holding the edge and whether the maple is too brittle for an axe handle. Also curious where it is made.


http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=72046&cat=51&ap=1

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#2

Re: Question for Rob Lee

Rob Lee

Hi Patrick,

Those hatchets were produced by Chestnut tools, and are made in China. The stainless was chosen as stainless works well as a knife steel, and these types of hatchets are more generally used for finer work ( well, finer that a splitting axe!) and the rust resistance would be of benefit. I am aware of European versions that are cast or forged steel ( German, Italian) .... But not at a similar price. These are to be our lower price offering.

Veritas has a much more expensive version designed using PM-V11, but it is still many months away. (Scheduling contention)

We have found that maple, while non- traditional for axes, works quite well in shorter handled axes. I would expect that the springiness of an ash would be of most benefit in longer felling, scoring, or splitting axes...particularly where over striking is much more common. Then too - it was likely a matter of ensuring we didn't end up with some sort of rubber wood.

So - this is a value/price play for these tools. They are not "off the shelf" production - They were made to a Chestnut design.

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#3

Re: Question for Rob Lee

Patrick Gibbons

Sounds like a good value. Thank you for a quick reply. A hatchet from your proprietary steel will be interesting to see.

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#4

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

William Duffield

Make your own handle for it, to fit you.

I think Rob is right; maple works well enough for a hatchet and should suffice until you know what you need. If you can find it, hickory is even better than ash. Air dried is better than kiln dried, and split is much better than sawn, unless you have a large enough billet that your sawing follows the grain in both planes.

A single bevel broad axe can also benefit from an s-bend handle. It's not obvious in the Lee-Valley photo, which is hewing a narrow piece of wood, but if you are hewing wider or longer timbers, you will want to keep your knuckles away from the plane of the surface you are working. Rob's description also does not show whether left vs. right handed on his hatchets means only that the handle is mounted upside down on the left handed axe or that two different handles are used, with opposite s-curves.

S-curve handles are illustrated in this USDA Forest Service manual, specifically in figures 34a and 34b. The handles (and maybe also the heads) in the illustrations are right handed.

You will probably want to steam bend your handle to get a suitable s-curve, another reason to start with a hewn green billet.

Before you decide you must have an s-curve handle, you should realize that it makes it possible to use the axe on very wide stock, but also makes it less efficient and more tiring when hewing narrow stock, since the plane of your swing is not aligned with the cutting plane.


img

Getting the Hang of It

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#5

has anyone ever seen a bent hatchet handle?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have several inherited from relatives and they all are straight.

The stainless steel choice is curious. It makes for a more expensive hatchet. Personally I have never seen an occasion where I thought a stainless steel ax or hatchet would be worth the extra cost. I would be curious how this steel files to sharpen the tool, or whether it sharpens differently from a typical ax/hatchet.

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#6

Re: has anyone ever seen a bent hatchet handle?

William Duffield

No, I have not. As far as axes, I can only refer you to the ones on the Forest Service page. The single bevel axe heads that I have seen, instead of bending the handle laterally, provided the clearance by angling the eye. These were all antiques, not user tools, so the subtle enhancement was not noticeable unless you were specifically looking for it (and it was not behind glass in a museum).

As I implied in my previous post, I don't think I see much advantage to the modification in a hatchet, and the obvious disadvantages trump the advantages. I can't easily imagine a piece of wood wide enough that someone would scrape their knuckles while hewing with it, that they would not choose to use an axe with much longer handle (and a larger head, too).

I definitely do not enjoy using any hand tools whose center of force is not directly in line with my hand and arm, and my wrist, elbow and shoulder joints. Therefore, I would need to carry two axes, one with a straight handle and one with a curved handle. I would rather carry one hewing axe and an adze, which would do the same job as the axe with the crooked handle.

When analyzing the purpose and choice of all old tools, one very important question you should ask is, "Was this tool used by a specialist or a generalist?"

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#7

Re: has anyone ever seen a bent hatchet handle?

Patrick Gibbons

The head geometry is far more critical than that of the handle. The Wetterlings and Granfors have eyes too large for best penetration, from what I have gathered from comments on the internet. My Vaughan has a back bevel. I believe this is one way to achieve the results one has with an offset handle. To use the axe, it must be canted slightly which takes your fingers away from the wood. However, if Vaughan didn't bevel the back, it would be easier to put in than it has been for me to take it out.

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#8

Re: A better question...

TomD

why a straight edge.?

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#9

Re: SS could work nicely

TomD

I don't mind the stainless if it works OK. Stainless will cross it over into garden uses, camping, bushcraft, all assuming it works.

Lee valley has been selling the far more expensive belt axe in stainless for a long time, so they have some idea what SS can do, I would think.

I was once at a Cottage show that Gransford's booth was at, and they had all their broad axes there. There are a really large number of them, weird handles, double and single bevels, those folks get into some serious distinctions. I got schooled on all of them.

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#10

Re: SS could work nicely

david weaver

I have to imagine that stainless medium carbon steel that is used for a lot of inexpensive knives is probably over there in droves and is cheap to use, and well behaved in hardening and tempering in an open atmosphere. It also negates the need for special treatment in packing and shipping, and pulling a hatchet a year old out of the box with rust.

That said, I'd see a hatchet like this as a last resort for someone who couldn't find a vintage broad hatchet locally, made of carbon steel at a time when competition made all of the brands very good (be they bitted or forged from a single piece of steel).

Around here, a plumb (or similar vintage) broad hatchet is something you could find 4 times a year at a flea market for $5 to $40, depending on who is selling it. I guess you could find more than 4, but I'd say 4 that you'd want to recondition (as in wouldn't take much more than a little bit of clean up and a file).

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#11

Re: SS could work nicely

TomD

I haven't seen a Plumb up here, is it the one that is the model for the swing of a framing hammer?

I am not sure the grind on this one is what I like, though that is easily fixed, what I did find during my interest in hewing axes was that the Gransfords aside (a little pricey for what I wanted), most the axes were impossible for me to use. At the time, around 40-45, 6'1" and burly, I couldn't imagine using any of them for anything at all. I did wonder whether the local ones were more softwood oriented, not that there is any lack of hardwood. I eventually ended up with that handleless one that Woodcraft sold.

My point being that old stuff often has a use outside of what we seem to want it for. I bought several single bevel hatchets before realizing the problem wasn't me, and turning to double bevel hatchets, which is actually what most of the folks I had seen working were using, but I figured there was something better out there. For all I know the trad. main use for a hewing hatchet was pointing up fencing, or something equally abstruse.

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#12

Re: SS could work nicely

david weaver

There's all kinds of different hatchets with the plumb mark on them, I just bring them up because along with true temper, they can be seen a lot around here used and are good quality.

There are older bitted hatchets from time to time, too, but for a hatchet, I don't get picky about what it is because it should be hard file hardness and you're going to modify the profile (and the backside of the bevel) to whatever you want.

I've got one double bevel and one single bevel and that's it - I figured that (unlike chisels), I'd see whether or not I needed anything else and thus far I haven't. I'd suspect a lot of people see videos on the internet and take a class and then immediately "need" some hatchets, which puts LV in a bind to source something new that doesn't cost $150-$250.

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#13

I have held the Lee Valley hatchet

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was an eye catcher at the International Woodworking Fair in Atlanta this week. It's big, and it's shiny!

Other than cost of material (chromium is expensive compared to iron) there is no reason to avoid appropriate stainless steel for tools. Some very fine hand tools are now made using cutlery grade of stainless steel. 440 stainless steel is a preferred steel for premium knives and knives are not far removed from hatchets.

Nobody is going to break a maple hatchet handles unless you drive over it. As bold as it looks you will easily spot it if left carelessly laying round. Maple base ball bats are growing in popularity in the major leagues.

I use an ax a lot- limbing, thinning and trail clearing. I am picky about a handle. I did not like the hatchet handle. It was a surprising departure from the wonderful ergonomics one expects in a LV tool. A few minutes with a spoke shave and rasp would, however, remove what to me was uncomfortable angularity of the handle cross section.

Buy one and you will stand out at traditional barn raisings and timber framings. Engraved, it would be a spectacular presentation gift.

Re: Question for Rob Lee *LINK*

#14

Re: At one time...

david weaver

440C stainless had a good reputation with knife makers, but they've moved on to other stuff leaving 440C for middle of the road stuff, and 420 and 440A for low priced stuff. At one point, queen used 440a in their pocket knives, and buck uses a variant of 420 stainless that's not much different in their low cost knives, now.

I'm sure it's plenty fine for hatchets, though, since they shouldn't be harder than can be filed. I'd still rather have a dry steel like a 1070 or 1080.

Given the compromises that you make with the LV hatchet (especially with the handle), at $60 plus shipping I'd call it a last resort unless someone couldn't find a vintage broad hatchet (which would have to be someone banned from ebay because more than 200 have sold on there in the last couple of months).

That's just my opinion. I'm not seeing the value unless someone is using it in salt water.

LV is in a bind with stuff like this because it was made in droves in the past (in great quality), and a lot still exists, but a lot of their customer base (and that of all of the woodworking retailers) can't handle much that needs any attention out of the box. (and everyone always wants something without paying much for it).