New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

What Have I Got?

Posts

What Have I Got?

#1

What Have I Got?

William Duffield

My brother found me a #3 bench plane. While trying to decide what to do with it, I noticed a crack in the sole from one corner of the mouth back about 1/2". The only markings it has are "No 3" cast into the front of the toe and a tapered blade marked "BUHL". I can't see any clear indications that the blade might be cast steel or laminated, but I'm not ruling that out.

Other than the crack in the sole, and a lot of surface rust, it appears to be in pretty good shape. My idea is to repurpose the parts: The frog, blade, chip breaker and lever cap would be made into a stringing thickness scraper. Reference the one offered by Lie-Nielsen here: http://www.lie-nielsen.com/tools-for-inlay/latta-thicknessing-gauge/. This one would be larger, and more complicated than a piece of steel and two screws, but the price is right and it would be more easily adjusted. I would need to turn the blade over and regrind the bevel at about 40° to make it into a scraper. The sole could be sawed in two at the mouth, and the rear 3/4 mounted in another block of wood, charged with 0.5 micron diamond and used for sharpening. I'm sure I could find a use for the rosewood knob and tote. Any better ideas? I already have a Stanley #3 with an aftermarket blade in it that works well, so I don't need another small smoother.

Re: What Have I Got?

#2

craigd

Re: What Have I Got?

craigd

... so I don't need another small smoother.

Somebody is in denial.

Re: What Have I Got?

#3

Testing for laminated blades

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm not sure if this works on other laminated blades, but I've found that 24 hours of soaking in white vinegar will affect the different steels in Stanley's laminated blades, with the higher-carbon steel of the cutting lamination turning black while the rest of the blade remains steel color.

It sure doesn't sound like a collectible plane, and the crack you describe would hardly be worth fixing; so your repurposing makes sense.

Re: What Have I Got?

#4

Re: What Have I Got?

William Duffield

You're probably right. The blade on mine is ground straight across, with a very small relief at the corners, while this one has a pronounced camber.

Re: What Have I Got?

#5

Re: What Have I Got?

Jim Crammond

William,

It sounds like you have a good plan of action to re-purpose this plane. For what it is worth, Buhl was a hardware dealer in Detroit. We see a fair amount of Buhl tools in this area. Without seeing the plane, based on the tapered iron, my guess is that the plane was made for Buhl by Ohio Tool.

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

Re: What Have I Got?

#6

Re: What Have I Got?

Patrick Gibbons

If you need a radius plane or some other specialized tool, it would require only making a new body. Your idea sounds fine. I would bet it would work ok even with the crack. Hope you post pictures when you finally do repurpose the tool.

Re: What Have I Got?

#7

Re: What Have I Got?

William Duffield

Thanks, Jim. My brother found it somewhere in Silicon Valley, probably San Jose (a long way from its home), where we've found some other interesting tools in the past.

Re: What Have I Got?

#8

Re: What Have I Got?

William Duffield

Come to think of it, after I found the crack, I never even tried it out. I should test it, especially since I'm going to have to clean it up for whatever use I put it. Using the frog, blade, etc. for a stringing sizing tool won't make it impossible (or even difficult) to put it back together as a plane, if I find that the stringing sizing tool doesn't perform to my expectations. There are lots of otherwise useless broken plane bodies out there, especially larger ones, that would make better polishing stones, anyway.

If the scraper does work out, I'll be sure to provide pictures, dimensions, and construction instructions.

I don't need a radius plane. ;) As I mentioned to Jim, on a previous trip to San Jose, I found, among other rarities, a Type 1 #113.

Re: What Have I Got?

#9

Beep, beep... Zoooom (drive by in progress)