New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Posts

OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#1

OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We've got a small (maybe 4" diameter trunk at breast height) paper birch growing too close to the house and in the way of the phone lines (it was a volunteer). I've topped it once, and, in less than a year, it's back up to where it was. Today, the head gardener and landscaping aesthetician approved taking it out, yay!

I've become far too familiar over the years with trees that will resprout from the stump - after we had a locust cut down in front, to promises by the tree company foreman that cutting it to ground level would kill it, we had sprouts from the stump and from roots all over, including in the crawl space, until I killed the stump.

Is paper birch a species whose growth "spirit" is in the stump, or will cutting it down to a stub kill it? It's very close to a little redwood of some sort, possibly a dawn redwood, that is staying, so I'd rather not get into digging it out; but will if needed.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#2

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Sgian Dubh

I wouldn't be surprised if your tree is able to sprout from the stump at ground level. However, if you want to be sure I bet, like here in the UK, you can buy some sodium glyphosate in strong enough concentrate that will kill it. I'd search for something like stump kill or root kill. I've used similar stuff effectively. Generally I bore a hole about 1" diameter X about 3" deep and pour the concentrate in. Sometimes a repeat dose or two is needed on big tree stumps. Three doses like that killed a bird cherry with a stump about 18" diameter. I didn't want to cut the tree down, but it was within 3' of a wall and the roots were getting into the foundations and drains. Concentrated Roundup will do the job poured neat into the hole rather than diluted as if for spraying. Slainte.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Jesper, Denmark

It will not likely sprout, but to be sure, paint the cut surface with Roundup. That will fix it.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#4

Murderer! Killer!

Bruce McCrory

It is small enough to resprout from, in essence, stooling. If you try to dig up roots it may just give you a dozen more sprouts. Just create a Dead Zone and pretend you are Darth.

Do it now. Not in the Fall. . .. Or, whenever you call Fall. :D

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#5

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It might be worth your while to post this on the main board, Bill. Both Tom Dunlap and Dale Lenz are arborists.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#6

White birch

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think that it is more likely that Bill has European white birch, Betula pendula than paper birch, Betula papyrifera. Neither is native to California, but the white birch is much more widely planted as an ornamental and the paper birch is more of a northern tree. In Oregon the European white birch grows wild all along the coast, while the paper birch is restricted to the northwest corner.

The white birch likes to grow in clumps so I would expect it to sprout. I don't think I would risk putting herbicide on if it were near something I cared about. If you cut off the sprouts, they will get weaker and the tree will eventually die.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#7

Re: White birch

Patrick Gibbons

A solution I've never tried is to let the stump dry out, drill a hole into it, fill the hole with burning charcoal and dig up what remains in a day or so. What I like about this is no herbicides or poison. And besides, it's an excuse to burn something. Whenever this solution comes up in conversation, ( surprisingly, quite often) it is mentioned in hushed tones and generally includes an admonition to do it clandestinely.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#8

Re: Clandestine birch burning....

Bruce McCrory

.... then spoil the child. On the other hand, the birch being hushed is probably attached to a house. :D