New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

That's awl, folk's

Posts

That's awl, folk's

#1

That's awl, folk's

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

OK, I couldn't come up with a catchier title .. :)

A few weeks back Stephen started a thread on the simple awl. He appears to favour the brad awl for starting holes for screws or drilling.


A few offered their preferences, including William ..


As an aside (since this is a related topic), I do not see why scratch awls are made in the same design as a birdcage or brad awl since they are not intended (as I understand) to create holes and are clumsy to use in scribing a line.

Scratch awls are easier to use when holding them like a pencil, hence this design.


Anyway, in the earlier thread I mentioned that I was waiting on a kit from Czech Edge, a 1/4" bird cage blade in carbide, and was planning on building a new design when it arrived. Well, I doubt that it is revolutionary, but I like it.

As it happens, I wound up building two, in different sizes.

Why carbide? Well, I made this birdcage awl about 10 years ago, and it is way overdue for replacement. The blade is a steel rod - I do not know what it is - and it is both difficult to grind into four facets and it does not hold an edge particularly well. It let me down for the last time building The Chair.


The Czech Edge carbide blade is beautifully made. 1/4" square rod and ground ready to use. Comes with a bronze ferrule ...


I thought that the end was blunt until I looked closely. It is actually ground to a high angle point, probably as carbide is brittle and a pointy end is vulnerable.


Birdcage awls are used by pushing down and twisting. The sharp ends act like reamer to cut away the waste. Downforce is required. With our local hardwoods. I wanted something that was easier to grasp, twist and push down. The awl I used was really too small ergonomically ...


The shape I had in mind was something along the lines of the pad from a brace. This is what I came up with ...


This blade was made from a 1/4" HSS square rod and ground to the same angle as the CE blade.


It was a big improvement, but I decided to make another larger version (using the CE blade) ..


This is sweet in the hand ..


A comparison of sizes ...


Please post your thoughts and preferences.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: That's awl, folk's

#2

Re: That's awl, folk's

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I have to agree with you about the shape and ergonomics of the scratch awls. The two double ended marking tools on the left in my photo do work that way. OTOH, I don't at all like the way my olive scratch awl works. It wasn't any better before I managed to break off the point a couple of times, so I haven't replaced it.

I like your bird cage awl handle, and I would like to try out the concept here. To that end, what diameter handle stock did you start with? I would guess about 2-1/2" (~63 mm). Is it some of the curly jarra left over from your chair?

My next problem is that I don't hve any square stock in either tool steel or carbide, but I have several round stock choices, including O1, M2 and solid carbide. I'm not going to canibalize my CTW bird cage awl, which is only O1 anyway. So, I'm looking for suggesstions on how to grind a square point into round stock in a controlled manner. I would have no problem with grinding a round point, or one with 3 facets or 6 facets. I hve a lathe with an indexing head and four jaw scroll chucks, a slow speed grinder with Wolverine sharpening jigs, and a drill press with a cross slide vise and a milling table. It seems I could somehow put some set of tools together and minimize the "workmanship of risk" to my scarce but cheap carbide stock. I don't see an offer for a carbide birdcage awl point on the Czeck Edge website kits page, so just buying one doesn't appear to be an option.

Re: That's awl, folk's

#3

My favorite

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I really like the Japanese ones. Especially the smaller one.

It's been so long, how do I add a picture?

Re: That's awl, folk's

#4

Pictures

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Scott, nice to see your name again.

You should be seeing a posting screen that looks kind of like this (I need to do an updated version of this picture):


If you do, you can either:

1) click on the "browse" link to find a picture on your computer and upload it, as long as it's within the type and size limits (the little question mark in a circle to the left of the browse button will tell you what these are), or

2) paste the URL for a picture from the web into the "Optional Image URL" box toward the bottom.

If you're literate in HTML, you can also use that to put pictures from the web in your posts.

Let me know if you're having trouble.

Re: That's awl, folk's

#6

Re: Why not...

William Duffield

Yes, I think you're right about the advantages of M2 HSS. If you wanted to build one with a handle in Derek's configuration, I think a 2-1/2" length is a little short, but it would be easy enough to extend the neck of the tool handle. If your handle material is expensive or scarce, all is not lost. I searched in the Enco online catalog and found a couple of alternative products on this page:

http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INPDFF?PMPAGE=162&PARTPG=INLMK32

In addition to the 2-1/2" blanks, they also offer 6" and 8" long by 1/4" square blanks in M2. That's probably less per inch than tulipwood or other rosewood turning blanks.

The Enco prices are lower than the MSC prices, which I don't understand, since they are the same company. The last piece of machinery I ordered from Enco was clearly printed MSC on the carton, but the Enco price was considerably less, on sale, and they were offering free shipping, which made a big difference at 54 lb.

While you are putting together and order, you might also consider the round and rectangular blanks. I've made lots of turning tools from their M2 round drill blanks, and some of the rectangular blanks would work very well for skew chisels and scrapers. Even if you were turning your handles from jarra :D , M2 would be suitable, so you wouldn't need to consider the more expensive cobalt steel bits.

Re: That's awl, folk's

#7

Re: That's awl, folk's

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I like your bird cage awl handle, and I would like to try out the concept here. To that end, what diameter handle stock did you start with? I would guess about 2-1/2" (~63 mm). Is it some of the curly jarra left over from your chair?


Hi William

Yes, made from scrap pieces from the Fiddlewood Jarrah left over from the chair build.

The smaller one is a 2" diameter and a 1 3/4" height (top to end of ferrule), while the larger one is 2 1/4" diameter and a 2 1/2" height.

The square blade for the smaller awl is HSS rod, which I picked up at the recent Perth Wood Show in 1/4" and 3/16" sizes. I planned to make one with the narrower rod as well, for comparison, but I really like the 1/4" - much easier to sharpen.

Grinding the square rod is straight forward on a 8" grinder - just rest it on the rest and away you go. the great thing about HSS is that you do not need to be concerned about the temper. After this, I honed the hollows away on a coarse diamond stone. The aim is to achieve a flat, sharp edge to act as cutters. Incidentally, I did try and grind the Carbide on the same white Norton wheel - heh .. heh ... it barely scratched it! And that is why the carbide - it should remain sharp forever!

HSS rod should be available where ever you purchase supplies for lathes.

How to grind a round rod to four square ends? Bloody hard if you are trying this freehand! I just eyeballed it each time. If I was to do it with more precision, I would index the sides.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: That's awl, folk's

#8

Re: That's awl, folk's

William Duffield

I think I've decided how I'm going to proceed, and I'll let y'all know how it turns out. Here's the plan:

I've made lots of tools using M2, and I have M2 round stock available.

I think my strategy for fixturing the blank while I grind the point will be relatively easy: I'll start with a piece of square stock (like a pen blank), and drill a centered hole in the end. (Pen turners do this all the time.) While I could use a drill press and a v-block, for better precision, I prefer to use a scroll chuck on the lathe with spigot jaws and a drill bit in the tail stock. I'll temporarily fix the M2 rod into the wooden tool holder, and index the grinds off the four flat sides. If it works well, I'll post pictures, and also show some of the other techniques I've used for making handles for hand tools.

When I eventually need to resharpen it, I should be able to do it freehand on one of my diamond stones. My major stumbling point will probably be selecting just the right piece of figured wood for the awl handle.

Re: That's awl, folk's

#10

Re: Why not... *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

Here's a source for 1/4" square W-1, 36" long for $4.72. Just use a torch to heat treat and temper in the oven. Not carbide or HSS but will do just fine.


http://www.flat-stock.com/~store/Merchant2/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=T&Product_Code=PM-W1&Category_Code=PMDR

Re: That's awl, folk's

#11

Engraving burin

Patrick Gibbons

Your handle is exactly what is used fur burins to engrave metal. They maximize a pushing motion. Should be very good for a birdcage awl.

Re: That's awl, folk's

#12

Re: That's awl, folk's

Patrick Gibbons

A 1/4" awl sounds very large. Is it difficult to pierce the wood with that large a diameter? What are you using this for exactly? I've probably not paid attention here.

Re: That's awl, folk's

#13

Re: That's awl, folk's

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Patrick

I plan to build another, with a 3/16" blade and compare this with the 1/4" blade.

While one may expect the narrower blade to pierce more deeply, this is really more a function of the bevel angles. The advantage of the 1/4" blade is that it is easier to freehand hone (on a diamond stone).

Regards from Perth

Derek