New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

The semantics of risk

Posts

The semantics of risk

#1

Ellis Walentine

The semantics of risk

Ellis Walentine

I'd like to elevate a thread that we've been discussing recently in the context of Derek Cohen's recent Wegner chair reproduction: the notion of "risk," in woodworking in particular but the concept can be generalized into just about any area of human endeavor. What constitutes risk and is it a useful construct?

Our recent discussion started with Derek's musing on his chair-building adventures.

I cannot say that this was a relaxing project as there were very few times where I was working within myself. Everything seemed at risk, especially the fact that I did not have any backup wood. Is that not what David Pye was referring to?
He was referring to the "workmanship of risk" (vs the "workmanship of certainty") as postulated by David Pye, the British educator/craftsman.

In his book The Nature and Art of Workmanship" Pye defined the workmanship of risk as

...workmanship using any kind of technique or apparatus, in which the quality of the result is not predetermined, but depends on the judgment, dexterity and care which the maker exercises as he works...

I offered up a few thoughts about the risks I perceived in Derek's project, having to do with his manual processes and fixturing and also with the broader risk of taking liberties with an original design. More recently, TomD injected some reality into the conversation with these thoughts:

It is interesting that one of his main tools to illustrate the point was a fixtured chisel with lever assist. It was risk in the sense of creativity, you could put the cut however you wanted, but the tool itself had many characteristics of a machine, I believe it technically qualifies as such due to the linkage and leverage. While it might be nice in this forum to consider dichotomies of the type described above but I think they are mostly meaningless. There are many non-challenging, and indeed boring things that happen entirely by eye and feel. Squaring up a split for a leg with a drawknife would be very hands on, but I don't remember it being difficult when I first tried it, and if I were a bodger, I think the risk element would have vanished long ago. Most amateurs (not a word that can be spoken of our host of course), are more interested in the idea of risk relative to skill (which they don't have), and the manipulation of tools. But a real craftsman, knows his tools and is working in a design mode (when they are working in a risk mode at all). I just don't see the risk for any experienced person, doing anything in the shop, as far as simple manipulations are concerned.

...and there is where we pick up the thread. Can we define risk? How is it important to our mental processes or to the outcome of our work?

To add another dimension to the discussion, consider this paragraph about Pye's intentions that I discovered in a Wikipedia post. I don't know who contributed it, but it's an interesting analysis.

Pye proposed that we build things to effect change. Everything occurs within a system of changes and structures and is not divisible from the system in which it operates. Most designed objects are, in his opinion, purely palliative, and very few objects truly enable new activities and behavior. We can walk instead of taking the car but we cannot fly instead of taking a plane. He also points out that design is limited by economy not technique. Technique far outstrips affordability. Because of this all design is a trade off and to that extent a failure. Where that failure is allowed to enter in is an arbitrary result of the process of designing. He points out that much of design proceeds under the assumption that tools can bring us happiness but in his opinion tools can only avoid unhappiness. In thinking that tools can equate to happiness the tools are seen as separating cause and effect which are inseparable. This belief is held because design is conceived at a certain level of isolation from outside factors which do not or cannot exist in the world.

So, what is the relevance of risk? I think TomD has a valid point about it being a mostly meaningless dichotomy. My take is that Pye found an interesting way to organize the worlds of design and craftsmanship, but it's hard, and probably irrelevant, to pigeonhole design processes and woodworking activities. Where do you draw the line between risk and certainty? And why is it convenient or meaningful to do so?

For me, it's more important to focus on the visual, tactual and mental aspects of designing and making things, and on how pleasing and successful the end result is.

Like Derek, I welcome further discussion on this.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: The semantics of risk

#2

Re: What is risk?

Steve Voigt

Definitely a great topic. Two things come to mind.

Derek - I absolutely think power tools can fit into the "workmanship of risk" - in fact, Tom rightly chastised me a while back for implying they couldn't. For example, I am working on some Windsor(ish) chairs. I don't have an adze or scorp, but I do have a lancelot "chainsaw" attachment for my angle grinder, so I'll use that to rough out the seats, then refine with a travisher. Both of these operations fit my definition of "workmanship of risk" - they take skill and discernment, and the result is not guaranteed.

Contrast this with a jig that I saw, I think it was in FWW, where the guy was using a tablesaw to carve out chair chair seats. The jig was very elaborate, but once it was dialed in, all you had to do was slide the work back and forth, raise the blade a little, rinse and repeat. To me, this is the antithesis of "workmanship of risk." Is there any risk? Sure, tablesaws always have risk. But the key fact for me is that once the jig is built, the craftsman is just a machine operator. You could get someone with no ww-ing experience whatsoever, and they could operate the jig just fine.

The same thing can be done with hand tools, by the way. Jeff Miller's tenoning jig (the vertical one for straight tenons--not the one you showed in your chair project) is a good example. Once it is set up, all you have to do is move the saw back and forth in the slot, and stop before you overcut. It's a little tougher than a tablesaw, I suppose, but there is no real skill involved.

I should add that I have used jigs many times, and will continue to do so. I do it when the needed precision exceeds my abilities, or sometimes when I am just lazy. But it's not "workmanship of risk."

Tom - I think you might be interpreting the word "risk" a bit too literally. Take the simple example of ripping a board and then planing the edge perpendicular to the face. You're right, for someone who's experienced, there is no real "risk" involved; I can't even remember the last time I irretrievably screwed it up. But, I still need to check with a straight edge, square, winding sticks. I still need to make little adjustments. It's a skill that took some effort to acquire.

On the other hand, if I run a board through the tablesaw, I generally don't check it for square. I don't own a working jointer, but if I owned a good one, I doubt I would be constantly checking my edges for square. Using these tools, in contrast to the grinder example I gave, is mostly a matter of paying attention to safety.

So, I don't think risk is necessarily a high-wire act: it can just mean having to use your skills and senses to produce good work, versus being a machine operator.

Re: The semantics of risk

#3

Risk is a continuum, not a single point.

Chuck Nickerson

A lot of discussions lose usefulness when judgments (safe, fair, just, risk, torture, etc.) are treated as a single point, not a sliding scale. This applies to tool use and design.

When I hand saw to a line there is still some risk, just not as much as a year ago.

When I alter an existing design there's risk of ending up with something awkward.

When I don't alter an existing design, there's risk as well. I've given up one of a very finite number of chances to stretch my design skills.

Almost all of my project planning involves some informal risk assessment. The more outside my previous experience I get, in tool use or design, the more formal my risk assessment gets.

If this sounds like overkill, my guess is most people are doing the risk assessment but not labeling it as such. If you're cutting practice joints, I call that a form of risk assessment and mitigation.

Re: The semantics of risk

#4

Re: The semantics of risk

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's been ages since I read his books, but, if I recall correctly, he did not in fact describe it as a dichotomy, but a continuum, as Chuck suggests. Clearly, these are all on different points of the continuum: the laborer clamping a pre-sized chunk of wood in a fixture on the table of a CNC router, then standing back; the furniture-maker running a piece of stock past the rip fence on the tablesaw; and the sculptor tackling a big piece of tree trunk with nothing but an axe and an idea of what the finished piece should look like.

Tom makes the argument in the thread on Derek's chair, from which this new thread springs, that "I just don't see the risk for any experienced person, doing anything in the shop, as far as simple manipulations are concerned." Tom has much more experience than I, but I wonder, if this is so, from whence came the saying that you can tell an experienced person by how well s/he handles mistakes.

I remember, reading Pye's book the first time*, thinking how useful the naming of the points on the continuum are. It was and, in my judgment, remains a far more useful distinction than the old hand tools/power tools dichotomy. There are hand tools (bench planes) that are far more certain than a given power tool (chainsaw).

Part of his point, again if memory serves, is that working with certainty reduces the ability to respond to circumstances (a really nice piece of grain on the crest rail of a chair that a slightly different shaping of the crest rail would highlight), while, of course, we're all familiar with the downsides of working with risk (although it can do wonders for the vocabulary).

But there are things for which jigs/fixtures/etc. are the cat's pjs. If I were finishing up a table and making the buttons to hold the top to the apron, I would be looking for the fastest way within the available tooling to make them; no sculptural buttons needed.

---------

*Our 38-year-old younger son was a teenager, which I remember only because I recall thinking about Pye's statements as I walked our dog who kind of bracketed our son's teen years. Tempus has been very busy fugiting in my life for quite a while now.

Re: The semantics of risk

#5

Ellis Walentine

Continuum indeed

Ellis Walentine

We're all on the same page regarding the risk continuum. Risk and certainty are just polarities. We humans are fond of playing semantic games with words and definitions. That's my point about working on a more experiential level than an intellectual one. It all depends on what amuses you.

Ellis

Re: The semantics of risk

#6

What I like about Pye's book

Steve Elliott

Pye's Nature and Art of Workmanship is one of my favorite books but not because of his distinction between workmanship of risk and workmanship of certainty. I'll return to why I like his book after a few comments on risk.

I've spent my working life in cabinet shops where the prime concern was producing quality work quickly enough to keep the business profitable. What is meant by quality corresponds pretty well to Pye's criteria: soundness and comeliness. It must be sturdy enough and look good.

The biggest risks to a project come from the need to work quickly. If I had as much time as I wanted almost every operation would be well within my comfort range, whether done with hand tools or programmed into a CNC router. I've generally been much more worried when I pushed the "run" button on the CNC than when I pick up a chisel or a plane because of all the things that can go wrong quickly on the CNC. Not only can the workpiece be ruined but the machine can be damaged causing considerable repair expense and loss of production.

Another risky operation is sanding veneer, usually considered a low-level skill but one that requires judgment and finesse to be done well.

Quite often in the course of a project I have to decide whether to check the layout one more time before cutting something, or review the drawings, or check the hardware specs, or any number of other things that would take time but help avoid mistakes. When Pye discusses risk it is more than just this ordinary avoidance of mistakes, yet in my work this is the main type of risk.

What I really like about Pye's book is the discussion of aesthetics and diversity. The qualities of an object that can be achieved using hand tools can add subtle interest and a kind of artistry that is lacking in most machine-made work. The subtle scallops of a planed surface are more interesting than the near perfect flatness of a sanded one. This isn't due to the risk involved and it's the subtle qualities rather than the risk that are important.

I also like Pye's point about how different design elements affect the viewer at different distances. When approaching an object the overall shape is seen from a distance, with a few details barely becoming perceptible. At a closer distance the overall shape may not be as apparent but the texture of the surfaces may be. A well-designed and well-built piece will have interesting aesthetic qualities no matter what distance it is viewed from. Nature has this quality to an extraordinary degree and not one of my pieces has ever come close to being as beautiful as the natural world.

Re: The semantics of risk

#7

Re: The semantics of risk

TomD

"Technique far outstrips affordability. Because of this all design is a trade off and to that extent a failure. Where that failure is allowed to enter in is an arbitrary result of the process of designing. He points out that much of design proceeds under the assumption that tools can bring us happiness but in his opinion tools can only avoid unhappiness. In thinking that tools can equate to happiness the tools are seen as separating cause and effect which are inseparable. This belief is held because design is conceived at a certain level of isolation from outside factors which do not or cannot exist in the world."

OK, the tools side of this I see, but the idea design is always a failure, seems a little severe. I like the limits that force various solutions. I love plywood boats, and think they lead to far more interesting solutions at times, that situations where there are no designs limits, or at least a lot less. Sometimes you even get a better boat in absolute terms, though generally fewer limits are better in that regard. But a really clever plywood design is not a failure because it was not a carbon infusion to start with.

"So, what is the relevance of risk? I think TomD has a valid point about it being a mostly meaningless dichotomy."

I was mostly arguing that the risk element is meaningless to a professional worker, and that therefore the main point Pye was making was on the design side. Of course there is meaning all over the place in reading his books, and if it speaks to someone in a different way that is good. But to get a tight reading I mostly believe it only makes sense relative to the design distinctions.

"My take is that Pye found an interesting way to organize the worlds of design and craftsmanship, but it's hard, and probably irrelevant, to pigeonhole design processes and woodworking activities. Where do you draw the line between risk and certainty? And why is it convenient or meaningful to do so?"

I don't want to be a bigot, but there seems to be something legalistic in the US air (a good thing) that makes people very impressed with black or white solutions. It is OK if it is legal, regardless of anything else. And of course the ultimate winning argument always seems to be "where do you draw the line". This can be a real issue in matters of rights, and law, if there is no way of drawing a line it is going to require some fancy footwork. Perhaps we could solve the problems with interpreting Pye by invoking privacy rights. :) Of course everything in human life is in the US, and in all of us. But I do hear that argument about lines a lot. I think it is pretty much irrelevant in this kind of field.

One should always try for the greatest clarity, but I agree the idea that there is a line is not really the point it is a continuum of tool or design skill. In the case of tool skill for the pros, the dychotemy should not exist, because they are at one end of the line, not because the range does not exist.

Re: The semantics of risk

#8

Re: The semantics of risk

TomD

"Tom makes the argument in the thread on Derek's chair, from which this new thread springs, that "I just don't see the risk for any experienced person, doing anything in the shop, as far as simple manipulations are concerned." Tom has much more experience than I, but I wonder, if this is so, from whence came the saying that you can tell an experienced person by how well s/he handles mistakes."

I don't know, let's ask this guy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wX_rh8Qugt0

Actually, probably proves your point.

I suppose one way around would be to say that if a pro can really handle mistakes, doesn't that eliminate risk? If Raffan makes a catch, he can immediately adapt the design to it. That makes his work more varied, which may be seen as a plus. So where is the risk? I think one can argue that design is a different real, but to an extent it is risk free for the expert also. I was just watching a video by Al Murray, a standup comedian, he was addressing Cambridge Union, and he did 450 shows a year in his early years, about 80% improvisation. He also spends a ton of time writing. So at this point in his career, 20 or more years down the road, there is still risk in the design aspect, but it is a lot less so than for most. And also with humans, you can always push a point. You can always go to another level. Not really the case making a chair. If Derek makes a thousand, it is hard to see how the last 50 will be the same design challenge as a stand up who decides to really tear into a drunk.

Re: The semantics of risk

#9

Re: What is risk?

TomD

"Tom - I think you might be interpreting the word "risk" a bit too literally. Take the simple example of ripping a board and then planing the edge perpendicular to the face. You're right, for someone who's experienced, there is no real "risk" involved; I can't even remember the last time I irretrievably screwed it up. But, I still need to check with a straight edge, square, winding sticks. I still need to make little adjustments. It's a skill that took some effort to acquire."

I would push that though. Leaving out the quality control we all do to be sure there wasn't a crumb in the fence or whatever, the hand jointing an edge is an entirely mechanical thing, I can do with my eye's closed. Because the hand jointer is a straight edge that measures longi straightness within a few thou, and I never have to pick up another tool, there isn't a better one available. As far as square. I do have to check that, unless I pair pieces, which is a perfectly viable technique in some case. I would have to check a jointer if it didn't have a built in fence on it. And hand planes can have built in fences.

What I think is additionally interesting about this is that we think it will always/often be true that there has to be that extra skill in there. There was a fair amount of skill involved in figuring some of this stuff out, before it was common knowledge, but it isn't really a big deal these days. My belief is that hand tool woodworking gained a lot of momentum precisely because people now realize that you get extra credit for doing it, but it is in fact just the same risk wise as constructing a process around router jigs. Now some stuff is free ish handish, sawing is less easily jigged, in some instances.

"On the other hand, if I run a board through the tablesaw, I generally don't check it for square. I don't own a working jointer, but if I owned a good one, I doubt I would be constantly checking my edges for square. Using these tools, in contrast to the grinder example I gave, is mostly a matter of paying attention to safety.

So, I don't think risk is necessarily a high-wire act: it can just mean having to use your skills and senses to produce good work, versus being a machine operator."

It should all be reduced to nothing. Why hold onto the idea it needs to be hard. It's easy, should be what we want. We are overly invested in the idea that the skill is the thing. No the product is the thing. I came across this on a cycling thread. Someone asked what is better about a custom bike. Well obviously everything... But in his view while he admired the craftsmanship, he thought the product was no better than stock. Totally backwards, craftsmanship is like walking or breathing, the product being better is what counts.

Re: The semantics of risk

#10

Re: What is risk?

Steve Voigt

We are overly invested in the idea that the skill is the thing … Totally backwards, craftsmanship is like walking or breathing, the product being better is what counts.



As Tonto said, what do you mean 'we,' white man? ;)

Seriously though, the above quote is purely a matter of opinion, and it's definitely not my opinion. I guess if one is making a living at woodworking, "the product is what counts," but I'm not. I did make a living at it for a time, but there wasn't much hand planing or dovetail chopping. Now I'm an amateur again and the skills are what I'm interested in.

Re: The semantics of risk

#11

It’s all Dirty Dish water

Bruce McCrory

Years ago this (Pye, and possibly, Krenov) may have been a fun debate at the written level. In a sense, it is still fun at another level.

It’s a Universal Principle. The bastions of education are expected to pour forth knowledge to justify public expense; or, do gobshite. To meet this requisite, Pie looses his bolts of disdain (championing risk) at the machine of mass consumption (certainty) and penetrates his own hallux. Having praised the engineering of the automobile, he proceeds to lambast its multiples in the parking lot. Well, it’s them because a dray won’t fit the bay, and draft teams spilling effluent onto asphalt are frowned upon in modern society.

It's a book, not an article, so transport is followed by a train of more examples of what he is fuming about. Further injuries have not blunted his pencil.

One can too often hide insecurities and reputation in incomprehensible language, confusion and complication. [The essence of the above comment is borrowed. But it supports.] Especially, when he is in the gibbet for lack of edible fodder.

However, don’t toss the milk with the sullage.

It’s a Universal Truth. Mid-twentieth Century was a time of flux. Political, philosophical, and psychological change was the rage, along with Nehru-ware. To the mind a pencil was an erection. Back then.

Let’s take risk at face value. We have a furniture designer and builder (no dichotomy) who enjoys crafting apparatus for the construction as much as, if not more than, producing the final product. I don’t call his gallery work trite—his ‘workmanship of certainty’ yields delightfully refined furniture. And he can make hundreds of the same thing. Next door, Jose builds ‘in the air’, where jigs and fixtures often don’t survive the completion of a ‘one-off’ piece. I don’t call his gallery work trite or primitive—his ‘workmanship of risk’ also yields creative and comely pieces.

The former craftsman worked risk out of his creations. Jose just works with it.

Enough. Save corruption for another roast..

Re: The semantics of risk

#12

Re: What is risk?

TomD

Depends what one means by interested in. I am currently re-learning swimming with great effect. It is satisfying on many counts, and of course that all comes from the skill I have been gaining over the last few years. I only get a few dozen open water swims a year, relatively short. I am improving my abilities, not doing anything noteworthy here. Mostly that means skill, not endurance improvements. Lots of fun, life long desires being met, and things coming together with other areas of interest like my understanding of boats. But at the end of the day, the public purpose would be less people drowning, starting with me or my kids. I am interested in general water competency, being at home in the water, and swimming in survival situations, not sport. So yeah, the jazz is learning the skills, but being a skilful simmer, the fact that the odd person has commented on how great I look moving through the water is not the point. Not drowning, etc... is the point. And, while I have a long way still to go, I am starting to get past technique. I have solved enough of my inefficiencies (thank you youtube, and pirate bay) that I now feel comfortable (I could always swim, and did long open water swims as a kid but I hadn't got it figured out, and it wasn't usually comfortable, or I was slow).

So right now I get a lot of bubbles from my left arm, and there are a bunch of reasons. I am breathing on the right at the same time. I realized I was starting the weak side stroke too soon, and this was causing me to loose forward bouyancy, etc... I could write a book about my left arm. But I am starting not to be all that interested in it. And I am just swimming. Maybe in a year or so. I have to tear it all apart. I am a natural analyser, not a natural athlete type. But ultimately it should all fall away.

As to woodworking. You can hire any of a million or so woodworkers who are better than most of us, the skills are not what the public should find remarkable. They either want the pieces or they don't. Again, looking at what Pye was writing about craft in a professional setting. There is woodwork beyond our garages and basements, for the time being anyway. I am not sure how much of what he says applies to dabbler, certain a lot but not sure that is the setting.

Re: The semantics of risk

#13

Re: It’s all Dirty Dish water

TomD

I don't have the books at hand, but I have before made the comparison to Sartre, on the subject of être-en-soi and être-pour-soi. Probably easier to WIKI than sit through my explanation. The claim, not entirely convincing was that neither state was better, they were just different. And whatever Pye said, can't check, that is how I saw what he was writing. Neither certainty, nor risk are better, one than the other. You are engaged in doing something different, but not better. So if that is the lesson, needs checking, that kinda blows your objection out of the water because he isn't justifying his output or ragging against what others are doing. He is merely distinguishing. Which would be smart whether he meant it or not since it eliminates a certain avenue of rejection. And you can be pretty sure that people will go one's way anyhow: The young and the old are equally beautiful in their own ways, but you can count on the manufacture of consent to get the right age group on most magazine covers.

If Pye is engaged in an academic exercise it would be mind blowing if he didn't see the connection to Sartre himself, it is so obvious, and I always assumed it was the inspiration for his categories. Either way, risk and certainty are just subsets of what Sartre described, whatever Pye thought of it.

Re: The semantics of risk

#14

Re: What is risk?

Bruce McCrory

I see this as: we seek a product, not a board full of dovetail skill builders. Continuing, skill evolves as the products are created..... My freebie..

My carry on: The goal is a substantial, edible, useable construction. Art is often interesting to admire. Someone may build a delicate Krenovian box to place the art piece into. But what to do if it is a clash of two beasts? Perhaps, the display box is more attractive. Nope, they both need a place to sit; and are clutter if position is wrong. Purpose prevails.

Re: The semantics of risk

#15

Re: The semantics of risk

Jim

Woodworking in the context of straight reproductions, with no time limits, with an original in the shop subject to using profile gauges, direct measurements, etc. is NOT what David Pye was referring to in any way as risk.

Re: The semantics of risk

#16

Re: The semantics of risk

TomD

I disagree, except to the extent that you may well be right that it wasn't in his mind. However, in the situation of Derek's repro, every component piece is an individual work of risk because there is a sculptural element in which the line has to be right. Think turning bowls. What the heck, hardly a new thing to do, there have been bowls, pretty much every one is a repro of something, quite possibly an actual copy, but you still have to exploit the wood, and cut the perfect line, and get the right balance between the inside and the outside shapes, etc... That is pretty much all there in what Derek did, not to mention the technical risk, which is not my idea of what Pye was talking about for a variety of reasons...

An example to think of is the evolution or adaptation in something like a Maloof chair. Certainly people say how great they were, and the man himself has described the risk process by which the shapes are refine in each chair. Or at the very least in each new direction the chairs have taken. How is that different in a copy? Sure you are not inventing the type, but neither is Maloof, either in the sense of owing a lot to chairs, to the scene around him, or the previous chairs he already had on file. But there is still risk in every artistic decision about a line, a piece of wood, and so forth. I am not saying there is risk in every decision, because some of them are routine.

This is part of the problem with going too far with this stuff. As I earlier said there is a pretty clear analogy to Sartrian Existentialism. However, nobody takes that stuff seriously. It came and went in a blink. Or so they said in the early 80s. Same thing here, this idea has it's point, when you first come on it, and you can learn some stuff from thinking about it. But at the end of the day, it is not "right". I am pretty sure one can argue in or out of this stuff as the cause requires. It's interesting, but not bullet proof.