The semantics of risk
Ellis Walentine
I'd like to elevate a thread that we've been discussing recently in the context of Derek Cohen's recent Wegner chair reproduction: the notion of "risk," in woodworking in particular but the concept can be generalized into just about any area of human endeavor. What constitutes risk and is it a useful construct?
Our recent discussion started with Derek's musing on his chair-building adventures.
He was referring to the "workmanship of risk" (vs the "workmanship of certainty") as postulated by David Pye, the British educator/craftsman.I cannot say that this was a relaxing project as there were very few times where I was working within myself. Everything seemed at risk, especially the fact that I did not have any backup wood. Is that not what David Pye was referring to?
In his book The Nature and Art of Workmanship" Pye defined the workmanship of risk as
...workmanship using any kind of technique or apparatus, in which the quality of the result is not predetermined, but depends on the judgment, dexterity and care which the maker exercises as he works...
I offered up a few thoughts about the risks I perceived in Derek's project, having to do with his manual processes and fixturing and also with the broader risk of taking liberties with an original design. More recently, TomD injected some reality into the conversation with these thoughts:
It is interesting that one of his main tools to illustrate the point was a fixtured chisel with lever assist. It was risk in the sense of creativity, you could put the cut however you wanted, but the tool itself had many characteristics of a machine, I believe it technically qualifies as such due to the linkage and leverage. While it might be nice in this forum to consider dichotomies of the type described above but I think they are mostly meaningless. There are many non-challenging, and indeed boring things that happen entirely by eye and feel. Squaring up a split for a leg with a drawknife would be very hands on, but I don't remember it being difficult when I first tried it, and if I were a bodger, I think the risk element would have vanished long ago. Most amateurs (not a word that can be spoken of our host of course), are more interested in the idea of risk relative to skill (which they don't have), and the manipulation of tools. But a real craftsman, knows his tools and is working in a design mode (when they are working in a risk mode at all). I just don't see the risk for any experienced person, doing anything in the shop, as far as simple manipulations are concerned.
...and there is where we pick up the thread. Can we define risk? How is it important to our mental processes or to the outcome of our work?
To add another dimension to the discussion, consider this paragraph about Pye's intentions that I discovered in a Wikipedia post. I don't know who contributed it, but it's an interesting analysis.
Pye proposed that we build things to effect change. Everything occurs within a system of changes and structures and is not divisible from the system in which it operates. Most designed objects are, in his opinion, purely palliative, and very few objects truly enable new activities and behavior. We can walk instead of taking the car but we cannot fly instead of taking a plane. He also points out that design is limited by economy not technique. Technique far outstrips affordability. Because of this all design is a trade off and to that extent a failure. Where that failure is allowed to enter in is an arbitrary result of the process of designing. He points out that much of design proceeds under the assumption that tools can bring us happiness but in his opinion tools can only avoid unhappiness. In thinking that tools can equate to happiness the tools are seen as separating cause and effect which are inseparable. This belief is held because design is conceived at a certain level of isolation from outside factors which do not or cannot exist in the world.
So, what is the relevance of risk? I think TomD has a valid point about it being a mostly meaningless dichotomy. My take is that Pye found an interesting way to organize the worlds of design and craftsmanship, but it's hard, and probably irrelevant, to pigeonhole design processes and woodworking activities. Where do you draw the line between risk and certainty? And why is it convenient or meaningful to do so?
For me, it's more important to focus on the visual, tactual and mental aspects of designing and making things, and on how pleasing and successful the end result is.
Like Derek, I welcome further discussion on this.
Cheers,
Ellis
Of course everything in human life is in the US, and in all of us. But I do hear that argument about lines a lot. I think it is pretty much irrelevant in this kind of field.



