New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

over finished?

Posts

over finished?

#1

over finished?

milesteg

I recently built a couple of chairs made of cherry. I decided to try the mixed finish using 1/3 each of spar varnish, boiled linseed oil, and mineral spirits. First coat - fine. Second coat seems to take forever to dry. It is the 3rd week and they still feel a bit tacky. Humidity is high here at 70 to 80% lately and that could be part of it. It seems the linseed oil component did not soak in or dry off.

Looking for recommendations as next step to start sitting in the chairs. I even baked them in the sun several days which helped a small bit. Did I just overdo it?

help appreciated.

Bob

Re: over finished?

#2

Re: over finished?

Bruce McCrory

Are you finishing outdoor furniture? The recipe you describe is for that purpose. And, no, the 'wet, greasy' feeling will remain for some time.

I tried it one year as part of a life war with the elements of weathering. Cedar and Redwood absorb the permanently wet finishes better than most other wood, but the surface is still staining clothes for weeks after treatment.

Don't worry. It will flush away after enough rain. The BLO will also eventually absorb. You can hurry along dissipation of the finish by soaping and hosing the contact surfaces.

If interior furniture, try to wipe the surface dry with thinners--turps, paint thinner.

Re: over finished?

#3

Re: over finished?

milesteg

Its indoor furniture. I am satisfied with the finish, it will endure for quite a while. I have stared to sit in them in my work cloths thinking I would burnish the contact surfaces as you note.

I don't want to mineral spirit away the finish. Perhaps, old cloths sitting and time is the solution after all.

thanks.

Bob

Re: over finished?

#4

Re: over finished?

TomD

The Maloof finish consisted of polymerizing tung oil, linseed oil and valspar in equal proportions. One reason to use the valspar was that it had dryers in it, at the time anyway, not sure what they use for that these days. Anywho, your mix probably just isn't amped enough with dryers. You could try another coat with some Japan dryers added, or whatever the paint store says will work these days.

I don't know why you need that much MS, the 50/50 mix you have should penetrate well enough. Normally it takes small additional amounts of thinner to achieve a workable viscosity.

I would recommend the Maloof version. Also you could try just top coating (sample some place it won't show with Watco danish oil). It's a super finish, easy to use, and might kick over your current mix.

I think the combination of a week drying finish, and the conditions you mention is likely at fault. That is why they sold Japan Dryer. Just checked, JD is sold on Amazon. So whatever it is today, is out there. The stuff we used to get came in an eye dropper bottle. This stuff comes in a fairly large can.

Re: over finished?

#5

underwiped

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I believe this finish is employed as a wiping finish which is to say= wipe on, wipe off(excess). Repeat until it looks finished. May take several coats.

Wet a rag with paint thinner and wipe off what will wipe off. Let dry a while. Wipe on a last coat, wipe of excess and let dry. Even just oil should be dry in 2-3 days, especially in summer temperatures. But if left thick it can take a long time.

Next time use a formulated wiping varnish.

Re: over finished?

#6

Yeah, underwiped....

John in NM

Anything with linseed must be wiped down pretty well after application. That tacky feeling is excess linseed oil.

Wipe it down with mineral spirits or turpentine. If it wipes off the sheen, you can always recoat with something that dries a little harder.

I regularly use BLO on walnut - 1 coat for color - and then use Waterlox or another similar product to get a nice luster. I like the look of Waterlox better, but it's so thin that I sometimes use something similar to thinned varnish instead or in between the BLO and the Waterlox.

Re: over finished?

#7

Clint Searl

Re: over finished?

Clint Searl

I think the problem is your home brew. Spar is intended to be soft and flexible when cured, which is slowed and exacerbated by BLO. My inclination would be to strip and wash, followed by a finish of oil poly, either thinned or not, brushed or wiped; or waterborne poly. IMO, the best would be a solvent lacquer.

Re: over finished?

#8

Re: over finished?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Bob,

I'll add my 2 cents to the mix.

The Spar varnish/BLO/mineral spirits or turps mixture is a good one, don't toss it out based on one bad experience.

The 'under-wiped' answer/response is what went wrong.

I have learned this the same (hard) way that you are learning it.

The first coat lulled me into a false sense of security in that it is almost all adsorbed into the wood immediately, so the wiping off part of the first coat is often almost non existent and it dries in a day. Then the second coat is applied, and having not needed to wipe off the first one very much, I didn't put much effort into wiping off the second coat, and there started my trouble. In my case the second coat 'sort of dried' at least enough for me to apply a third coat, which I also only halfheartedly wiped off, but that third coat after 3-4-5 or more days, just refused to dry. The remedy for me was to wipe/scrub off the piece with mineral spirits, scrape and sand and start over. During the 'second chance' application process I paid close attention to wiping off vigorously, and sometimes wiping off several times over the course of a couple of hours if you see oil rising out of the pores as the finish cures. The wiping off seems to me to become more important on the latter coats, once you have begun to build a film with he first couple of coats.

Of course, I'll make the tired old requisite statement regarding all finishing, "Test the finish schedule out on scrap first". If you test on a small piece of scrap you can better watch and observe the curing process to sort of learn how it progresses. This is especially important when using a new or unfamiliar product or technique.

I've even taken that advise once or twice, and prepared a scrap of the same wood as the project and, separated by strips of blue tape, applied different finishes side by side to see what I (or more likely my wife) likes best.

Anyway, hope this helps and let us know how you make out.

Bob in NJ.