New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

oil stones

Posts

oil stones

#1

oil stones

Frank C. Joseph

I was given a box of old oil stones . Two sided Norton type

Some are dished. Some badly 1/4 inc .

Is there a way to flatten them.

Re: oil stones

#2

bridger

Re: oil stones

bridger

yes.

ya, so smart ass answer. stones are flattened with other stones. stuff like the nortons are hard to flatten. norton makes (or made) a stone to flatten their oilstones. it's white, very coarse and very tough. the oe I have has the label on it:

norton 38a60-lvbe

hope this helps

Re: oil stones

#3

Re: oil stones

TomD

A lot of people will suggest using diamond stones, which will work, and one might think having a diamond stone around the shop would be an additional benefit. I have tried the experiment several times, and just decided not to get taken again. The problem is that diamond stones have a bond that most sharpening stone schwarf seems to eat easily, with the result that the diamond stone does not last too well. I keep hearing how x new stone is better and will not wear, and I buy it, same deal. Just not playing again.

In that regard, you can get a lot of diamond, or silicon powder cheap, off ebay. You can flatten on a lap.

Re: oil stones

#4

Re: oil stones

David Charlesworth

The old recipe was silver sand and water on a York paving slab.

A modern equivalent might be suitable coarse grit or valve grinding paste on a concrete slab.

I fear 1/4 inch will take considerable time.

best wishes,

David

Re: oil stones

#5

Re: oil stones

david weaver

Are there any natural stones to be had in this bunch? Most of the old india and silicon carbide stones (the orangish red brick colored stones, and black stones) get very hard over time to the point that they are difficult to use without a diamond hone to wake them - and they are quite coarse grit, so the diamond hone often just grades them.

Especially on the black side, where the friability is critical.

I can tell you how to flatten the natural stones very quickly (1/4" of dish might cost a cheap sanding belt from HF and take 15 minutes total), but sand as david suggests is better for the artificial stones - though if they are old enough for the crystolon/black/silicon carbide side to be super hard and completely non friable, they're best saved for very coarse outside, tile or house work.

Re: oil stones

#6

Re: oil stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use silicon carbide grit on glass with either water or kerosene to flatten stones.

I think that if you want to use oil stones you should buy new. You could go to some trouble flattening the stones, but it sounds like you have only a vague idea of what stones you have. It is difficult enough to learn sharpening without having to use mystery stones and to try to come up with a stone sequence for sharpening. Stones like you have are good for sharpening small tools that might gouge out the surface of a stone you are using for chisels and plane irons.

Re: oil stones

#7

Re: Silver sand?

TomD

Has a wonderful name, what is that David?

Re: oil stones

#8

Re: oil stones

David Charlesworth

google tells me it is fine sand with low iron content, valued for glass making.

I think it has gardening applications.

In the past I too have used valve grinding paste on glass.

David

Re: oil stones

#9

Re: oil stones

Kevin French

Save yourself some money and buy a large Concrete Building Block to do the initial grinding of the stones. They are very flat and course enough to do a lot of work. When you get them close to flat use something more expensive.

Re: oil stones

#10

Re: oil stones

chuck

If someone gave me a box of oil stones that were dished I would flatten them on a concrete driveway. I'd pick out the least dished stone or two and a place on the driveway that had an oil spot or spill. I'd sit down (uphill) from the oil spot with the stones and pour water on the oil spot. Then I'd rub figure 8's with the stone over the oil spot. I'd move over a foot or two whenever the grinding stopped being effective and start on a new area. I'd add water to keep the slurry wet and continue as long as I could stand it or until the hollow was gone. When the stones were flat I'd renew the working faces with other stones. Face A rubbed on face B. Face B on Face C and then A on C and repeat until I had three fresh flat faces. Then dry thoroughly and fill the stones with fresh oil.

I have rehabilitated a dozen flea market stones this way. Some were dished a quarter inch. One in particular was way worse than that but it is bigger than a brick so it's taken a while. This method works but it is limited in glamor, romance, and sex appeal.

Also note that a dished stone can be used as is for some tasks like axe sharpening

Re: oil stones

#11

Re: oil stones

Frank C. Joseph

Thanks all I took the worst started with a concret block then cleaned up with a belt sander and finished with a dimond stone

It took time but its flat and good to go.

Thanks

Re: oil stones

#12

Re: oil stones

William Duffield

Reviews of the Norton flattening stone are abysmal. A concrete block, or a sidewalk put down by a competent crew would be much flatter.

I use my DMT diamond stones to flatten my Arkansas stones.

Re: oil stones

#13

bridger

Re: oil stones

bridger

Quote

Also note that a dished stone can be used as is for some tasks like axe

End quote

as long as the dishing is fairly regular (no notches to snag on) they can be used for sharpening anything you want. You just have to do it freehand. No jigs. How do you think it got dished in the first place? By being used for sharpening things. This fetish for jigging up sharpening processes has resulted in the loss of a great deal of basic skills, in my opinion.

Re: oil stones

#14

bridger

Re: oil stones

bridger

I'm pretty sure that those reviews are about the flattening stone that comes with the norton waterstones. It's a grey/green silicon carbideish thing with massive slurry grooves in it. The stone I'm referencing is not that.

Re: oil stones

#15

Re: oil stones

William Duffield

You're right. The flattening stone I'm familiar with is for water stones.

However, the part number you provided, norton 38a60-lvbe, appears to be an abrasive material, grit and binder, not a particular stone made from it.

Before the quality control revelations were widely known, we sold several flattening stone for water stones. I can't recall any stone we ever carried, much less sold, specifically for flattening oil stones. Arkansas stones do not erode nearly as rapidly as water stones, and I see no reason (beyond marketing) to dedicate a flattening stone to that purpose. Diamond "stones" work fine, as do other oil stones, of even, as has been mentioned many times, a concrete block is flat enough to do the job. Whatever you use, if you want to be obsessive about achieving flatness, you need to rub three, not two, stones against each other.

Re: oil stones

#16

bridger

Re: oil stones

bridger

That number was taken from the stone I have. I looked it up once, found references to it as being intended to be used for dressing other abrasives. So yes, not specifically for oil stones.

Re: oil stones

#17

bridger

Re: oil stones

bridger

The impression I got was that the white dressing stones were appropriate for truing norton "india" stones, not so much for arkansas stones. I could be way off, though.

Re: oil stones

#18

Presume?

david weaver

That it's just a large hard piece of white alundum? That would make sense, there's no great reason for large grooves or anything when you're using it on oilstones that aren't going to slough off a whole bunch of stone swarf.

Re: oil stones

#19

Re: oil stones

Steve Voigt

I use the method Warren mentioned--SiC powder and glass, with a little Wd-40 or whatever. It works like gangbusters and you can be in business for 10-15 bucks. Diamond stones are expensive.