New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

The Chair - Towards the Round

Posts

The Chair - Towards the Round

#1

The Chair - Towards the Round

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It's been about 4 months since I last worked on The Chair. Life happens. All good - just very busy.

So I was back in the shop this weekend, and here is a record of the work done. Lots of pictures and just enough description so you don't fall asleep :)

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/TheChairTowardsTheRound.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Nice work - as usual....

Jesper, Denmark

from your descriptions, it appears quite clear that the back joint was intended to be machine cut right from the start. Doing it by hand is just tooooo labor intensive for a production piece.

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#3

Yes ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... there is no way that this joint could be fitted off a handsaw. I saw a fair dovetail and get most of my tenons to fit a mortice off the saw, but even using a jig here to maximise accuracy, there was correction and tuning needed to bring the fingers together.

Even if one decided to use a power saw in a home shop, I doubt whether it could be done without CNC equipment. I cannot imagine how to set up a tablesaw, for example, without multiple jigs. The jigs would consume the better part of months to build!


see: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/TheChairArmBackrest%28part2%29.html

I would be interested how others might go about making this joint. We had this discussion early on, but now seeing what is involved may stir the grey matter to come up with something.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#4

Glue and filler

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

When it comes time to glue the parts together I thought that I would use West Systems epoxy (because it is gap filling) and mix in a little colour to disguise any gaps that may be present in the finger joins. I have saved up sawdust from sanding the legs, however I think that this will turn out darker than the surrounding wood. Any thoughts and suggestions?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#5

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

TomD

Melting together into a single piece very nicely. Normally if I lay off something for 4 months... You are evidently made of stern stuff.

Just curious. How many projects would you estimate you have on the go at one time?

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#6

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... Just curious. How many projects would you estimate you have on the go at one time?

Hi Tom

I try to stick to one project at a time, but life does not always permit this.

Demands in my day job escalated as the school year began (I specialise in child development). This year has been extraordinarily busy. There are professional meetings as well (I sit on a few committees), and papers to write. I really do not ever have time for the shop during the week, and all building, etc is done on weekends. Some weekends are not free at all.

I was a little sidetracked by the Perth Tool Event early in the year as this led to building a mini-bench for demonstrations there, and then I completed a bedside table for my son, which had begun as a demonstration at the Tool Event. My wife and I purchased a cottage for rental, and this meant I was re-building a kitchen, constructing and installing a door, and painting for a while. Shortly before starting back on the second arm joinery, I had returned from a trip to Cape Town to celebrate my father's 100th birthday. That is what I mean by life - priorities - getting in the way.

Not woodworking during the week gives me a chance to work out what is needed to be done. As a result, when I am in the shop, I am pretty focussed on what to do.

Yeah, so I try to deal with one project at a time. In reality there are short excursions to other projects. Sometimes just restoring an old plane is therapeutic .. quiet .. calm .. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#7

alternate methods

ian in Sydney

Hi Derek, you asked:

I would be interested how others might go about making this joint. We had this discussion early on, but now seeing what is involved may stir the grey matter to come up with something.

My recollection (from the video where you introduced us to the Wenger chair) is that the joint you are trying to replicate was made on a shaper using a pair of matching knives.

A well equipped home shop might include a shaper – some of the upmarket table/panel saws are available with a shaper option, and many combination machines include a shaper.

To my mind while the arm to back finger joint is an essential part of the Wenger Chair's engineering, the actual shape of the fingers within the joint are not part of the chair's essential aesthetic – they are merely a consequence of the industrial machinery used to make the chair. Shaper knives last longer if rounded rather than sharp corners are used. Compare this to a hand cut joint where wear (blunting) of the tools used to create a joint (saw and chisel) have little if any impact on the ability to reliability create multiple copies of the joint.

In terms of jigging common power tools to create the chair's finger joint, I think my starting point would be a drill like you have used, followed by a slot cutter

alternatively, if making a number of chairs, it might be an excuse to invest in a small shaper!

BUT then I'd have to move over to the other side :-)

best wishes from Sydney

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#8

Re: alternate methods

William Duffield

…a pair of matching knives…[/i]

Just a detail, but it appears to me that you could use the same cutter head for both halves of the joint, with the appropriate appliances for holding the pieces. The setup would be a bit tricky, but much less difficult than executing a lock miter joint, since all of the detailed shaping of the surfaces of the joint would be done freehand after the joinery was complete. One piece would be fed right side up and the other upside down.

Finger joint cutting head, but with square teeth instead of radiused:

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41M44GQXT3L.jpg

Lock miter joint cutting head:

http://www.tool-home.com/products/catalog/images/tools/cmt/fz_694011.jpg?osCsid=e19m1c9j4dddsriv7ugue111u0

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#9

Adam of Oakland

Re: Glue and filler

Adam of Oakland

Hi Derek - They make tints for epoxy that you could mix and test out. I had used them during my fiberglassing days with a motorcycle project.

For gap filling where strength is important, i'd probably be tempted to use glass micro fibers (it looks like dust...not to be confused with microspheres which are just tiny bubbles which could actually weaken the joint) to help strengthen the bond. I'm thinking about when I glued the aluminum petcock and filler cap fixtures to this fuel tank that i made. The joint was mechanical in that there were fasteners, but also glued using epoxy mixed with the microfibers.

that said, i wouldn't try anything without a test first, a "roof" test, that is :-)

-Adam of Oakland, CA

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#10

Of course, you are right ...

ian in Sydney

using a shaper, you only need the one knive

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#11

on further reflection ...

ian in Sydney

Derek,

I think we agree that a finger joint is essential to the chair's engineering.

Given that, are you willing to accept that the shape of the fingers in the Wenger chair are a function of the tooling used to create them and not a deliberate decision of the chair's designer?

I know almost nothing about Wenger as a designer and most importantly do not know if the Wenger Chair was an exploration of what was possible using then available industrial tooling -- especially the mechanical shaping of the parts using a copy sander and early 3 axis router -- or if he specified the tooling his design required for the finger joint.

The engineer in me says a designer would say to the maker "this is my design, please make it", rather than "when you make the chair, the finished joint must look like this and be positioned precisely here"

In a home shop, possibly one of the easiest joints to make is a finger joint using a dado blade and two jigs – one for the arms, the other for the back.

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#12

Re: on further reflection ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek,

I think we agree that a finger joint is essential to the chair's engineering.

Given that, are you willing to accept that the shape of the fingers in the Wenger chair are a function of the tooling used to create them and not a deliberate decision of the chair's designer?

I know almost nothing about Wenger as a designer and most importantly do not know if the Wenger Chair was an exploration of what was possible using then available industrial tooling ....

Hi Ian

The designer's name is Hans Wegner, a Dane, and one of the most influential (and prolific) post-ww2 furniture designers. He has a number of "classic" chair designs, with The Chair perhaps the most famous.

There is some description of the background in the early posts found near the lower end of this index, "Building Hans Wegner's "The Chair":

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/index.html

Wegner was a trained furniture maker. He also built models of all his chairs, most of which did involve some handwork in the production stage. You are correct, however, that the finger joint was structural and not aesthetic (although we have since applauded its inclusion). Originally the joint was dowelled together. This was changed to fingers by the factory when it went into production in 1949.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#13

must remember it's "Wegner" ...

ian in Sydney

sorry about my bad spelling ...

the finger joint [is] structural and not aesthetic ... Originally the joint was dowelled together. This was changed to fingers by the factory when [the chair] went into production

Thank you, that explains much.

for a one off, dowels would be fine, but in production they would be real pain to get right across 1,000 or more units.

Shaper cut fingers are a whole lot easier to keep consistent. One setup for the knives, and then three jigs to present each component (back, left arm, right arm) at the right height [for the final joint] relative to the cutter block

I'm waiting to see how your fingers display after the final shaping

Re: The Chair - Towards the Round

#14

Re: Glue and filler

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Adam

Yep, I know about microballoons, etc from days of repairing surfboards and windsurfers. Fortunately, the fingers are actually pretty tight, and the only gaps will be at the tips of the joints, not the sides.

I prefer epoxy to other glues in this situation because I think it will cope better with the stresses here. The gap filling area is an non-issue. Any voids would better be filled with coloured epoxy or a shellac stick, which will be easier to match at the end.

My priority at this stage is to shape the back and sides as much as possible - that is, remove as much waste as I can - leaving enough of the existing body to glue on anchoring points for clamps to pull the fingers together at glue-up time. Then it will be time to complete the shaping.

Regards from Perth

Derek