New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Going Electronic?

Posts

Going Electronic?

#1

Going Electronic?

Bruce McCrory

Another thread introduced electronic publications as a solution to printed. I grew up with print books and magazines tucked in a hand while lounging, so going to a desk to read them had all the sympathy of going to work to earn a herniated disc sooner--or, again.

The inference of the post was "hand held" electronic. Going electronic has matured, I guess, so maybe it is time to look into a handheld alternative?

Are there any preferences for the littlest with the most and biggest bang for your buck?

Re: Going Electronic?

#2

Re: Going Electronic?

William Duffield

I have had a tablet for a few years, on which I read books in pdf and epub formats and magazines. I am mostly pleased with it, but I would prefer to have a laptop with a retina display. However, I can't answer your question, because it is analogous to asking, "Which hand tools and power tools do you recommend from Harbor Freight?" TANSTAAFL

Note that small, low resolution screens aren't very useful for reading detailed plans and dimensions or high resolution photos. Also, there are major differences in operating systems and manufacturer support systems that can make a big difference in the ease of use, and the time you waste in system maintenance.

Re: Going Electronic?

#3

I'm still using laptops

John in NM

I don't care for tablets or phones, so I'm sticking with the good old laptop until they are gone. Last few I've been buying off lease models for cheap and replacing the windows OS with linux (necessary to run my 1993 vintage HP laser printer :D )

I tend to sit in the living room with a laptop, no desk needed.

Re: Going Electronic?

#4

Re: Going Electronic?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bruce and all,

I do a lot of reading these days. Read to my wife a couple hours a day as part of care-giving.

I have a few thoughts to offer, though I don't believe there is a 'one size fits all'. A person whose eyes are straining to pick up text has to decide between magnifying lenses+special lighting, versus a well-lit screen with text that will scale up to large size. Or maybe the ergonomics of holding a big fat book versus a thinnish tablet. Or cost may be an important matter--of the book itself or the electronic device.

An overriding concern is what formats are available for the book you want to read, and at what cost. For the past year, my wife and I have been reading a series of biographies--Ben Franklin, Geo. Washington, A. Lincoln, Harry Truman, Dwight Eisenhower, Peter the Great, Catherine the Great, Nicholas and Alexandra….

I don't believe any of these volumes are available free on Project Gutenberg. They are available for $10-12 via Kindle on Amazon. However, I bought them all in original published hard bound version from www.half.com in from Very Good to Like New condition, dust jackets and all, for from $1 to $4, plus $3.99 shipping. Half.com is incredible. And the merchants are almost without exception very accurate in their grading--mostly the book arrives in better grade than was advertised.

I do find that Kindle presents a good image, and the text will scale up really big, if you need that (I do). My older Kindle has a truly non-intuitive navigating logic, which is just about a deal-breaker for me. They may have changed this logic though in the newer versions that have come out--perhaps someone else can help on this point. Kindle can be had right now, if that is important. And any tablet or PC/Apple notebook is of course portable. My wife regularly gets 10 hours from her Apple iPads.

So it all depends. For me, I prefer getting the hard bound book and magnifying lens + lighting. Others will prefer electronic.

Wiley

Re: Going Electronic?

#5

Apple for me

Tony Wilkins

I've become an Apple fan the last few years. I find that I can read on my iPad better than books (even though I love books). I have the second gen iPad (when my wife hasn't walked away with it) and it works well. Screens are better now and I think the setup is even lighter.

Re: Going Electronic?

#6

My wife's iPad drives me nuts, but she's

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

happy with it now, after a learning curve. When I use it, it randomly goes to something I didn't ask for, sometimes backward to a screen she last looked at two days ago; and does other things that frustrate me.

Re: Going Electronic?

#7

Re: Going Electronic?

BrianMonumentCO

In spite of having spent more than 25 years in the software development area, when it comes to magazines I prefer the paper form.

Consider the following;

1. paper mags can kill bugs.

2. you can read a paper mag during a thunderstorm without risk to your wired mag

3. you can take a paper mag on a plane and read it anytime.

4. making a xerox from the mag is much easier with a paper mag... yet some electronic mags could also be printed. But the printer needs to be attached (wire or network) to your device.

5. the paper mag can be used to swat a bad dog (or politician) on the nose.

Re: Going Electronic?

#8

Re: Going Electronic?

Edward in Vancouver

I am really not tech savvy, and still can't comprehend the connection between computers and music, but I am curious about e-readers and have some, um..... Embarassing? questions:

-How does one purchase electronic material?

I hate, loathe. detest, etc. using a credit card. And it wasn't that long ago when US companies would not accept CDN credit cards, or would ding us Canucks pretty hard on the exchange rate and "associated" fees.

I also will not--as a principle-- give my credit card # out to any book club, record club, or magazine subscription.

-How do you store purchased electronic material? Do you store them on sticks, or just keep them on the hard drive?

Re: Going Electronic?

#9

Seems like PayPal is your friend

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Like you I hate using a CC for online transactions, although in some cases I had to.

But for the most part retailers will take PayPal, you decide how much money to put in the account, so a thief can't take $30k from your CC just because that is your credit limit...

DC

Re: Going Electronic?

#10

Round of applause!

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I too use Linux on my machines (too many to count...), but you stated another reason for using it: Windows does not update drivers with new versions after a certain time, but a Linux driver for an old device will keep on working...

I have a question, though... You're still are able to get replacement toner cartridges for a 20+ year old printer? Way cool!

DC

Re: Going Electronic?

#11

Going Electronic?

Tom Colligan

Hi Ed, you would buy the ereader, for me it was a Nook from Barnes & Noble. Then, you set up your account on it and they will provide an icon for shopping. For books you're tied in with Barnes & Noble. The Kindle is Amazon's product so you would be tied in with their store. The books are stored in your name and your reader will be able to handle more volumes than you could ever want.

But for an iPad, and the like, you could still be an Amazon or Barnes & Noble 'app' and that would enable you to buy their books, etc.

'Hope this was helpful, Tom.

Re: Going Electronic?

#12

mercifully we are in a cell phone void

Kevin French

In the winter we have to pump sunlight to the river valley, cell phones have no chance in here. I don't even have a dumb phone.

I like books.

Re: Going Electronic?

#13

Re: Going Electronic?

AlanWS

I was surprised to discover that I actually prefer reading novels on a kindle. It's lighter than a paperback book, but I have 150 or so books with me at any given time. I charge it about once a week, which is more often than needed. Most of the stuff on it I downloaded for free, and copied over using a cable from my computer. For that you don't need to use a credit card, but to buy books from Amazon you need to use a card to set up an account. It's nice to tap a word to see the definition, or search to find out who the heck is Pierrre Bezukhov. The paper book(s) I'm reading tend not to be with me in odd bits of time.

But it's just good for sequential text, and is much less satisfying for things with a lot of images like magazines. I've never been very happy with the magazine interfaces I've tried on computers. The closest to reasonable is a pdf on a large screen desktop (a laptop would only be satisfying if it had a large added screen, and then I'd call it a desktop, like the one I'm typing at now -- a hand-me-down from my daughter, attached to a 32" LCD TV.) A large screen is needed to properly scale images and text, while keeping convenient association of one with the other. In my opinion, if you need to hit any control while reading to look at the figure the text discusses, it's a poor interface or poor magazine layout. (OK, I'll accept an occasional page turn because you can't avoid laying out some articles that way, but I'm not happy about it.)

Re: Going Electronic?

#14

Disintermediation.

TomD

I have a Kobo reader that I use to read B&W novel type stuff that would otherwise come to me in a paperback or library hard cover format. The reader was 49 dollars C, and the media is pretty much free. It is all fine and good to talk about where you buy it and how you pay for it, unless you haven't missed the last 20 years.

Magazines are a very different mater. I just don't really see the point any more. E-editions are not a good experience, it is one thing to parse a page of text, but pictures, glare, are not as good as the real thing. The real thing isn't very good any more. Most magazines have lost a lot of quality. The authority just isn't there any more, and once the format is in competition with the net, why should I believe anything a writer for a mag says over what a guy on the internet says, when the cost, and gate-keeping issues are pretty much flattened out.

I started rock climbing in the 70s, and many of the guys who were the hero types of that generation (don't care about heros, but these guys were the wayne gretszkys of climbing of the day) Now reminisce on Supertopo. I can remember a couple of articles in which a writer visited with some of these guys, and those articles are still cherished and online, As I say, the guys who did this stuff, you can talk to them directly. There have been books written about these guys, but you can email them directly.

My pal is building a 46 foot catamaran. There are guys online who have been sailing that boat for over 10 years. The designer of the boat is a real old sea dog, but he hasn't been sailing it for 10 years, he has a 60 foot version. There are videos and magazines, etc... But who cares, you can talk to the real people.

I have been using Japanese tools for almost 40 years, and have written thousands of posts on them. Others have more experience, and are also active on various boards. Why would I care about a 1500 word article in FWW magazine.

Magazines were about establishing an undeserved authority. If you can take good photos and get something on paper you were in. I won one small mag competition at one point for an article I published. After that I couldn't be bothered. They will take stuff from just about anybody. It was a great thing when that was as close as one could get. Great pros like Ellis gave us a lot to work with.

What the internet does is disintermediate. You don't have to go through the gatekeepers. Unfortunately, this kind of stuff has not strengthened the breed. It seems to have been a pretty straight slide from the moment FWW started publishing.

We live in an information age in which information is commoditized. The result is that you can learn anything on youtube. You just don't need magazines any more. The value of the information in magazines is on a straight line to zero. The somewhat more challenging point is that the value of the represented skills is going to zero also.

Re: Going Electronic?

#15

Re: Apple for me

Bruce McCrory

I have to throw my towel to the hardbound folks. Paper still works for me.... almost.

I guess the sheer mass and volume of web presence has kept me satisfied with the desk and monitor. Besides, I can't even, now, manage maintenance myself. Son banished me from network/internet and spouse cpu. How can I start taking care of "accessories"?

I have always avoided Apple and Company, but yours and Tom's comments are intriguing. Tom said: "But for an iPad, and the like, you could still be an Amazon or Barnes & Noble 'app' and that would enable you to buy their books, etc."

Are there problems with magazine subscriptions, like PWW, or FWW--are there other woodworking publications--on iPad?

I think the irritation for me is that it seems the paper titles have changed positions with the various e-readers, booklets, books, tabs, and tablets. A slough of different hardware for the pleasure of reading choice.

Re: Going Electronic?

#16

Re: Use your library *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

Many if not most libraries are now part of an e-library system. For the price of a library card you can download books for a set period. Once read you either hit the return button or it will go away on expiration. The link below takes you to the Northeast Texas Library digital consortium. Use the advanced search to see what all is offered both digital and audio. Your library is probably set up with something similar.


Northeast Texas Libraries

Re: Going Electronic?

#17

Toner

John in NM

Yes, we just replaced it last year - gotta love Amazon. The original lasted that long under light use. No idea if the replacement will even come close :D

Re: Going Electronic?

#18

Re: Apple for me

Tony Wilkins

As mentioned elsewhere, here in Lubbock our libraries offer books to download for e-readers.

As far as 'multi-format', I have the Kindle App for my iPad and it works fairly well. I haven't needed the Nook app yet but I bet it works easily as well.

Not long ago I used my iPad to download books for my Doctoral seminar and was able to find many of the titles. And Chaplaincy and Counseling titles are a bit obscure.

My iPad has needed very little tinkering and maintenance to work - IOW it just works.

Re: Going Electronic?

#19

Re: Going Electronic?

Hank Knight

iPads are much more effective for swatting politicians on the nose.

Re: Going Electronic?

#20

Re: Going Electronic?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

I have an iPad (version 3 with Retina screen). I purchased it about 2 years ago after an overseas trip where I returned with a really sore shoulder, caused by carrying a MacBook Pro in a shoulder bag. I figured the iPad would give me eMail, Internet coverage and I could write reports as well. I was not thinking about magazines and books at the time. My wife, however, absolutely loved her iPad (version 2), purchased a year earlier, and was forever downloading magazines and books.

It occurred to me at some point that I could load the CD collection of Woodwork magazines. In fact, they work better on the iPad than they do on the laptop. The iPad can change the orientation from landscape (as on a laptop) to vertical, which is how the original magazine was printed. Consequently, the electronic version on the iPad is a replica of the paper version. It is better than the paper version in that the print size can be increased, you can zoom in on details, and the screen lighting is good for ageing eyes.

I gave my wife a mini iPad for her birthday recently. She much prefers this over the full size iPad she had been using for the past three years. Her view is that it is like reading a paperback versus a hardcover - light and manageable. She enjoys that she can pop it in her handbag, and has not noticed a loss of detail in the slightly smaller print. However her eyes are better for close up reading than mine.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Going Electronic?

#21

Re: Going Electronic?

BrianMonumentCO

I prefer the concept of a rolled up newspaper or magazine.

The symbolism is so much stronger.

The rolled up paper is used to swat other annoying things, such as mosquitos, wasps, flys, etc.

Most polliticians fall into that category.

I would not want to damage my tablet doing that.

Re: Going Electronic?

#22

Re: Disintermediation.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I started rock climbing in the 70s, and many of the guys who were the hero types of that generation (don't care about heros, but these guys were the wayne gretszkys of climbing of the day) Now reminisce on Supertopo. I can remember a couple of articles in which a writer visited with some of these guys, and those articles are still cherished and online, As I say, the guys who did this stuff, you can talk to them directly. There have been books written about these guys, but you can email them directly......

.....We live in an information age in which information is commoditized. The result is that you can learn anything on youtube. You just don't need magazines any more. The value of the information in magazines is on a straight line to zero. The somewhat more challenging point is that the value of the represented skills is going to zero also.

Hi Tom

One of the things that the Internet has done is made everyone more accessible to one another. When we began reading FWW and Woodwork, the authors were known from their articles. To us living in foreign lands they were the authoritative voices.

Forums have changed all this. Now we rub shoulders with the writers of magazine articles. How many of us here have published articles or work in magazines. I have several. I would be surprised if we did not discover a dozen others in this thread alone. So now you find that the articles in magazines today no longer have the same special quality they had in days of old. These days I am more likely to purchase a magazine to honour a friend who has an article in it, than to purchase the magazine for the articles within it. After all, they were discussed beforehand on this forum.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Going Electronic?

#23

Lawyer joke

Hank Knight

Frustrated lawyer to the Judge:

"Your honor, I request permission to strike the witness with his deposition."

Judge: "I see nothing in the deposition that merits striking the witness's testimony from the record."

Lawyer: "No, no, your honor. I want to strike the witness WITH his deposition."

Pause while the judge consults the rule book ...

Judge: "I see nothing that prohibits it, so I'll allow it. You may proceed."

Re: Going Electronic?

#24

Re: Apple for me

William Duffield

Anecdotally, I have the February, 2014 issue of Popular Woodworking in .pdf format on my 3rd generation (retina display) iPad, and it works fine -- Easy to view, easy to navigate, and the internal links within the magazine work well. External links to Safari (internet browser) and on to the internet do not work automatically. Getting the document from my iMac to the iPad was also painless. I dragged its icon from the Finder to iTunes, and dragged it from there to the iPad's icon. I didn't need to type anything.

I don't have any experience with FWW, but I assume it works just as well. I suppose I should try an issue of Woodwork, which I have on DVD, but I have no doubt it will work, too. It's a little more difficult to copy videos from DVD to watch on the iPad, but I've successfully done that too.

Books are not a problem either. In fact, I find it is much easier to read Roubo's To Make As Perfectly As Possible on the iPad than it is to read my deluxe edition in the paper form. :D That, of course, is an extreme example. Not all publishers make copies of their printed books in .pdf or .epub format when they publish them on paper.

.epub books are just as easy to download to the iPad and read as .pdf documents.

I have some experience with Android on my cell phone, but I haven't tried to use that for reading books or watching videos since I got the iPad. My wife has a Kindle, and doesn't have any problem reading novels on it, but it is very limited in other functionality.

If you learned to touch type, like I did in high school, you will probably find the touch screen simulated "keyboards" on any tablet more than frustrating.

Re: Going Electronic?

#25

Movies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It's a little more difficult to copy videos from DVD to watch on the iPad, but I've successfully done that too.

Hi William

I have the same iPad as you. Mine has a 64 Gb memory.

I do not copy movies to the iPad. They take up a lot of memory, and in any event there is an easier method.

I have a Seagate 1 Tb portable hard drive that is wireless. This connects easily (wirelessly) to the iPad, from which you can access any number of movies, etc you have loaded onto it from your laptop. It runs fast and there are no lags.

Regards from Perth

Derek