New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Electrolysis question

Posts

Electrolysis question

#1

Electrolysis question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi -

I am making my first try at electrolysis for rust removal and I have a question. The tool I am trying to de-rust is a 3 5/8 inch slick. The slick had very little "red" rust (Fe2O3 - iron oxide?) on it, but a fair amount of "black" rust (Fe3O4 - ferrous ferrite?).

I have been cooking this now for over 48 hours and there are still A LOT of bubbles coming off the entire slick. How long is this process going to take? I am surprised that there doesn't seem to be much of a reduction in the creation of oxygen and hydrogen bubbles. Should I expect to see these diminish gradually or will they just suddenly (or pretty suddenly) stop?

Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.

Dave

Re: Electrolysis question

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Electrolysis question

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'm not quite sure about the science behind it by I have cleaned many pieces of rusty metal by electrolosis. In my experience,the process is usually done in several hours. The bubbles won't diminish after the rust is gone.If you place a clean piece of metal in the solution it will bubble. I would remove that slick and using a combination of plastic scrub pads and water clean the black off the slick. I don't know what you mean by black rust but after a few hours in the electrolosis "red"rust tends to turn black and that black substance is fairly easy to clean off the metal.---Jack

Re: Electrolysis question

#3

It is all explained in WC Articles section

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

search "electrolysis" and look for my article on this topic

Re: Electrolysis question

#4

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" I am surprised that there doesn't seem to be much of a reduction in the creation of oxygen and hydrogen bubbles."

There is noting that can happen short of running out of water that will lessen hydrogen and oxygen production. However, given the excessive time this metal has been exposed to hydrogen, hydrogen embrittlement could be a problem. Suggest baking the piece at some temperature short of what will soften the temper

Re: Electrolysis question

#5

Re: Electrolysis question

David Churnega

The bubbles sometimes mean that you are eating away the steel. This method of rust removal leaves the metal in a dull lifeless gray. You might have been better starting off with emery cloth but you can still use it now.

Re: Electrolysis question

#6

Re: Electrolysis question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, Jack.

I removed the slick from the tank when I got home. Everything appeared fine. The thick black rust came off with the scrubbing. I'll post some pics before too long because I have some other questions about this slick. I appreciate your help.

Dave

Re: Electrolysis question

#7

Re: Thank you, Bill.

Dave (Arlington, VA)

As I mentioned in my reply to Jack, I've removed the slick from the tank and it looks fine. On you issue of hydrogen embrittlement...if you were me and wanted to use an abundance of caution, how long and at what temperature would you stick this slick in the oven?

Thanks you for your reply....and for the helpful article!

Regards -

Dave

Re: Electrolysis question

#8

Re: Electrolysis question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi David -

Thank you for your reply, David. I've cleaned my share of old tools using scotch pads and elbow grease. The black rust on this slick seemed to me to be pretty bad and I was curious about how electrolysis might work.

The slick is a bit gray but that doesn't really concern me. I am more concerned about Bill's comment about hydrogen embrittlement....though I had thought that was of greater concern to things like saws which are relatively fragile and which teeth can easily bread when being set. And while there remains quite a bit of pitting, I don't think it came from leaving the tool in the tank for a couple days.

Dave

Re: Electrolysis question

#9

makes no chemistry sense

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The bubbles sometimes mean that you are eating away the steel."

The bubbles may, and do, blast loose stuff off the surface but there is no way they will remove unoxidized metal. For metal to go away the metal has to loose electrons. Presuming the electrodes are hooked up properly electrons are being fed to the metal which does a dandy job of making sure the metal's electrons stay put and no metal goes away.

While one may readily abrade away rust from flat surfaces it is tedious to impossible to remove it from nooks and crannies. It is in these case that electrolysis excels. Personally I don't care what shade of grey the metal turns out.

Re: Electrolysis question

#10

Re: Thank you, Bill.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

how long and at what temperature would you stick this slick in the oven?

I don't know. It is something I have studied from books but have no practical experience.

It probably goes in at same rate it comes out, at the same temperature. Diffusion is hugely temperature dependent. There is no risk of loosing hardness at 225 F. Might try a couple of hours at this temperature, maybe adding another half hour for warm up.....just a somewhat "educated" guess.

There are some that get hysterical over the use of stainless steel anodes. I get hate emails several times a year. I have done the testing. There is nothing to fear.

Re: Electrolysis question

#11

Re: Thank you, Bill.

Dave (Arlington, VA)

I appreciate your thoughts on this, Bill. I hope to give this a try over the weekend...assuming I can steal some time in the oven for a hunk of steel.

Thank you.

Dave