Re: Back Bevels
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I don't understand back bevels. Apparently, for some edge tools some people insist on them while others insist on a flat bevel. I "learned" early on that carving tools were sharpened with a pronounced, radiused back bevel to aid in controlling the cut. Mary May, on the other hand, teaches to sharpen carving chisels with a flat bevel. At WIA #1 in Berea, Roy Underhill covered sharpening draw knives in one of his programs and said that a properly sharpened draw knife has a radiused back bevel. He even had a live video set-up to demonstrate the effect of the back bevel on controlling the edge in the cut. Derek's sharpening method does just the opposite: it produces a hollow ground edge. I understand that hollow grinding aids free-hand honing, but what about Underhill's back bevel? What about back bevels in general? Do you use them? If so, on what tools? Why? What do they do for you?
Curious.
Hi Hank
A hollow grind is only about sharpening ease. The preparation for the back of the blade is more about the purpose for which the tool is to be put.
In my understanding there are three types of back bevels.
The first back bevel is the one we most commonly associate with increasing the cutting angle of a hand plane. This is typically when one might with to increase a common cutting angle (45 degrees) to a half-pitch cutting angle (60 degrees) to change the chip formation and so reduce/prevent tearout in face grain.
The second common type of back bevel is the "Ruler Trick" associated with David Charlesworth. This adds a 2/3 degree chamfer to the back of a plane blade (not a chisel blade) to either circumvent pits or where the blade back is not flat. While more commonly used with bevel down blades for this reason, the ruler trick may also be a part of the sharpening regime for bevel up blades on low beds, since it aids in neutralising the possibility of the wear bevel intruding (a wear bevel forms behind the bevel on all blades whether BU or BD, but on the BU this would be experienced as dullness occurring more quickly).
The third back bevel is on a drawknife, as mentioned by Paul. I understand the process, just have limited experience in actual use. It would be great to hear from those who have compared a flat and a back bevelled (or rounded) drawknife.
Essentially, the flat style is championed by chairmakers such as Curtis Buchanan, while the rounded style is preferred by chairmakers such as Brian Boggs. Brian argues that a flat bevel will want to follow the grain, and this may cause the blade to bite too deeply, and that a rounded back will be less likely to do this, and is more easily steered through the grain. This is also the reason, if I understand correctly, why some carvers want a double bevel on their chisels, and will add a back bevel to create a gradual entry to the edge. Warren mentions something along these lines in his post. I also recall discussions - endless discussions! - here about the important of a flat back to a bench or paring chisel. Adam (Cherubini) would launch forth about the unimportance of this to make the chisel work. There are two parts here, however. The first is that a flat back makes is easier to sharpen, or at least make this process more reliable. The second is that such a chisel in use would require different technique - whether one wants the blade to be pushed straight with the aid of the straight back, or whether one wants to "carve" it straight, with the option of steering it at other angles.
In addition to my "new" 7" Witherby (as yet unrestored), 8" Pexto (straight back) and 6" Jennings carving drawknife (straight back-about-to-be-rounded), I also have a 8" Jenning folding drawknife, which I have had and used for over 10 years (not a lot of experience with it - limited to some roughing out). The 8" Jennings came with a rounded back, and I have kept it that way. Once I get into making a few chairs I shall have the opportunity to compare a flat and a rounded back.
Hopefully others will chime in on the above points.
Regards from Perth
Derek