New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Back Bevels

Posts

Back Bevels

#1

Back Bevels

Hank Knight

I thought I'd start this as a new post rather than hijacking Derek's wonderful post on sharpening draw knives.

I don't understand back bevels. Apparently, for some edge tools some people insist on them while others insist on a flat bevel. I "learned" early on that carving tools were sharpened with a pronounced, radiused back bevel to aid in controlling the cut. Mary May, on the other hand, teaches to sharpen carving chisels with a flat bevel. At WIA #1 in Berea, Roy Underhill covered sharpening draw knives in one of his programs and said that a properly sharpened draw knife has a radiused back bevel. He even had a live video set-up to demonstrate the effect of the back bevel on controlling the edge in the cut. Derek's sharpening method does just the opposite: it produces a hollow ground edge. I understand that hollow grinding aids free-hand honing, but what about Underhill's back bevel? What about back bevels in general? Do you use them? If so, on what tools? Why? What do they do for you?

Curious.

Hank

Re: Back Bevels

#2

Oops! Senior Moment

Hank Knight

After I hit the "Post" buttin, I realized that Derek's sharpening method hollow grinds the bevel, not the back of the blade. DUH! Nevertheless, his draw knife has a flat back, so the question is still valid: What does a back bevel do for you?

Hank

Re: Back Bevels

#3

Re: Oops! Senior Moment

Paul in NJ

I put a small back bevel on the back of my drawknife, just a couple of degrees. It helps "steer" the knife. If you have no back bevel the knife tends to dive into the grain and for me is less usable.

I am not a carving expert like Mary May but what I do works for me. I think most carvers including Mary May strop their edges. That in itself will round the edge on both sides of the tool and essentially "back bevel" the tool. Again, I believe the rounding or microbevel helps steer the tool. Carvers tend to have a lot of chisels and can sharpen them in different ways for different tasks. I tend to sharpen straight shank tools with a very steep primary bevel say 15 degrees, add a segondary bevel of 5 more degrees, and then do 5-10 degree inner/back bevel. The back bevel allows me to turn and use the tool upside down with control for convex surfaces. Bent shank tools only get a outer bevel as you never use them upside down. I am not sure how I would sharpen a back bent tool as I don't have any. That's my story and I am sticking to it!

Paul Dzioba

Re: Back Bevels

#4

Re: Back Bevels

chuck

I frequently use the "Ruler Trick" when sharpening plane blades. It speeds up the process of getting two planes meeting at the edge. The "Ruler Trick" does add a small amount of back bevel. I have added 5-10-15 degrees of back bevel to correct serious pitting on some of the vintage plane irons I've bought at flea markets. Then it's just a matter of corrective surgery in an attempt to salvage a otherwise doomed purchase.

Re: Back Bevels

#5

Re: Back Bevels

Ray

It is my understanding that a 15 degree back bevel with convert a bevel down plane blade cutting angle to 60 degrees. If this is accurate, I would think it would be somewhat difficult to push through wood.

Re: Back Bevels

#6

Re: Back Bevels *LINK*

Lars Parrington

See the link for more than you even wanted to know about back bevels as related to sharpening.

My take on it is that using a miniscule back bevel is the most efficient way of getting and maintaining a super sharp edge (where efficient is defined as conserving both steel and time).


http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bevels.html

Re: Back Bevels

#7

Re: Back Bevels

Hank Knight

Lars,

Thanks for the link. I don't think it answers my (poorly worded) question. I'm aware of the "ruler trick" and other methods to put a micro back bevel on an edge as a shortcut to flattening the back of a cutting tool, and of wear bevels that are another way of describing the dulling of a tool through use. The kind of back bevel my question addresses is the back bevel that some employ on carving tools, draw knives and other similar tools to help control the cut. In one of Derek's contemporaneous post below, he mentions that the use of this kind of back bevel is a matter of personal preference. I'd like to know the details and the pros and cons of this technique, who uses it and why.

Thanks again for your reply.

Hank

Re: Back Bevels

#8

Re: Back Bevels

chuck

The best writing I know about that addresses your specific question is in Chris Pye's "Woodcarving: Tools, Materials & Equipment.

Re: Back Bevels

#9

Re: Back Bevels

Hank Knight

Thanks, Chuck. I have one of Pye's books but not that one. I'll order it.

Re: Back Bevels

#10

Carving gouges

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Some carvers have a bevel on the outside of a gouge and a flat flute on the inside. That is to say they work the inside with a slip stone which is in full contact with the flute.

Other carvers have a longer,shallower bevel on the outside and a small bevel on the inside so that the slip stone only contacts a small band along the edge. The total angle of the cutting edge is roughly the same in both cases. The angle of attack is maybe 5 or more degrees different with respect to the handle.

I'm not eager to say which system I have used for 36 years; either way half the readers might think I don't know what I'm talking about. The big difference I notice is that the carvers with the double bevel seem to use bent gouges a little more and the single bevel carvers seem to use back bent gouges more. I can think of one carver I know who has some single bevel and some with a small back bevel.

Re: Back Bevels

#11

Re: Back Bevels

chuck

Ray-

Yes, that is also my understanding. I got an unmarked wooden coffin smoother with a wedge but without a blade. It was free but had some issues. The major issue I noticed from the beginning was a split on the right side. While cleaning this plane and repairing it's defects I was also cleaning up two 2" Auburn Tool Co. Thistle Brand laminated irons. Both irons took quite a bit of work to flatten their pitted backs. I gave up on one of them and put a short steep back bevel on it. The 15 degrees is a best guess. I don't have total confidence in my measuring at that angle. Neither iron fit. I filed down the flat back (face) iron to 1 & 57/64th" wide and now it fits into the plane with enough room to move. This plane and I live in the AZ desert where the humidity was down to 7% yesterday. I have not reduced the other's width yet. I was concerned about making the back bevel too long and creating the cutting edge outside the hard steel lamination.

I also have a half of a dozen (or so) block planes that take 1 & 5/8th" blades. I have a couple of dozen blades for those. With these blades I've put primary angles from 15 to 40, back bevels from none to 10, and cambers from none to ridiculous. I'm still learning about a lot of this stuff and I have enough blades to try just about any hair-brained scheme that I hear about. One of my favorite blades is a Hock with a 20 and 5 primary and back bevel. Another favorite is a vintage thicker Lakeside blade at about 15 and 10. The only 40 degree blade I have (a Revonoc I think) has a flat back and is harder to push and control. I have a hard time passing up $1-2 flea market plane blades.

Re: Back Bevels

#12

Re: Back Bevels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't understand back bevels. Apparently, for some edge tools some people insist on them while others insist on a flat bevel. I "learned" early on that carving tools were sharpened with a pronounced, radiused back bevel to aid in controlling the cut. Mary May, on the other hand, teaches to sharpen carving chisels with a flat bevel. At WIA #1 in Berea, Roy Underhill covered sharpening draw knives in one of his programs and said that a properly sharpened draw knife has a radiused back bevel. He even had a live video set-up to demonstrate the effect of the back bevel on controlling the edge in the cut. Derek's sharpening method does just the opposite: it produces a hollow ground edge. I understand that hollow grinding aids free-hand honing, but what about Underhill's back bevel? What about back bevels in general? Do you use them? If so, on what tools? Why? What do they do for you?

Curious.

Hi Hank

A hollow grind is only about sharpening ease. The preparation for the back of the blade is more about the purpose for which the tool is to be put.

In my understanding there are three types of back bevels.

The first back bevel is the one we most commonly associate with increasing the cutting angle of a hand plane. This is typically when one might with to increase a common cutting angle (45 degrees) to a half-pitch cutting angle (60 degrees) to change the chip formation and so reduce/prevent tearout in face grain.

The second common type of back bevel is the "Ruler Trick" associated with David Charlesworth. This adds a 2/3 degree chamfer to the back of a plane blade (not a chisel blade) to either circumvent pits or where the blade back is not flat. While more commonly used with bevel down blades for this reason, the ruler trick may also be a part of the sharpening regime for bevel up blades on low beds, since it aids in neutralising the possibility of the wear bevel intruding (a wear bevel forms behind the bevel on all blades whether BU or BD, but on the BU this would be experienced as dullness occurring more quickly).

The third back bevel is on a drawknife, as mentioned by Paul. I understand the process, just have limited experience in actual use. It would be great to hear from those who have compared a flat and a back bevelled (or rounded) drawknife.

Essentially, the flat style is championed by chairmakers such as Curtis Buchanan, while the rounded style is preferred by chairmakers such as Brian Boggs. Brian argues that a flat bevel will want to follow the grain, and this may cause the blade to bite too deeply, and that a rounded back will be less likely to do this, and is more easily steered through the grain. This is also the reason, if I understand correctly, why some carvers want a double bevel on their chisels, and will add a back bevel to create a gradual entry to the edge. Warren mentions something along these lines in his post. I also recall discussions - endless discussions! - here about the important of a flat back to a bench or paring chisel. Adam (Cherubini) would launch forth about the unimportance of this to make the chisel work. There are two parts here, however. The first is that a flat back makes is easier to sharpen, or at least make this process more reliable. The second is that such a chisel in use would require different technique - whether one wants the blade to be pushed straight with the aid of the straight back, or whether one wants to "carve" it straight, with the option of steering it at other angles.

In addition to my "new" 7" Witherby (as yet unrestored), 8" Pexto (straight back) and 6" Jennings carving drawknife (straight back-about-to-be-rounded), I also have a 8" Jenning folding drawknife, which I have had and used for over 10 years (not a lot of experience with it - limited to some roughing out). The 8" Jennings came with a rounded back, and I have kept it that way. Once I get into making a few chairs I shall have the opportunity to compare a flat and a rounded back.

Hopefully others will chime in on the above points.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Back Bevels

#13

Re: Back Bevels

Doug Trembath

As we discussed in another place, Derek, the differing configurations help with different situations, for me.

Many woodworkers use a variety of bevel configurations. As others have pointed out, some carvers like flat, some like rounded. I like 'em both, depending on the cut and the wood. In my experience, the differences are a bit more subtle than you might think. I believe that the objective can be accomplished by either configuration, by simply varying the manner used to manipulate the edge. Properly controlled, flat or rounded bevels will each perform the cut needed. With experience, we can all achieve the same result with either configuration. The major difference, I think, is the ease of use and the confidence a person has with their choice, for a given situation.

It's really simple to see what works and what doesn't, as an elementary sample, at least. Place a chunk of wood in the vise, and tear into it with each knife you have. It won't take long to discover what each type will do for you, and which approach to use for the objective you have in mind. If you are working straight grained wood that is well behaved, you can use the flat beveled knife (bevel down) to quite aggressively cut down to a line, then flip the knife and use the edge much like a two handed chisel to leave a very fine, straight and level surface which will need only a couple of jointer strokes for a finished surface. If the wood has more squirrelly grain, it takes a little more finesse with a flat bevel. You can use the rounded bevel to do the same thing if the back is flat, but a back bevel won't allow this, just as it would affect a chisel. If a back bevel is used, it's a little more finicky to keep the lines straight without the flat reference surface. That could just be me, however. I find that I can do better work in that regard with a flat bevel. If I'm working a curve, inside or out, I prefer the rounded bevel, as it is more steerable in my hands.

This tool is remarkably intuitive, and easy to use, but is also prone to big mistakes if a guy gets a little heavy handed, or over confident. I am grinning as I write this, because I have had a few sticks ruined when the knife followed the grain instead of cutting through it. Used with care and good judgment, these tools are wonderful additions to our arsenals. Obviously, just my opinion...

Doug Trembath

Re: Back Bevels

#14

Working with a slick

Bob Hackett

The first thing I`d like to say is that how you sharpen an edge depends on the work you intend to do with that edge.

As an example I`d like to point to using a properly prepared slick.The primary function of a slick is to pare away wood in close quarters where planes can`t fit, most often in wooden boat building and timber framing.I know there are people (myself included) who use them for all sorts of other things but it`s my understanding that this is what they were designed to do.

A properly prepared slick has both some camber in the edge to help steer it and some rocker in the blade to also help steer it up and out of a cut. Both of these features use an an almost unnoticeable amount of curvature to enhance control. Take that little bit of curve out and the slick become far less friendly.

As someone who also uses drawknives a bit I also find that a bit of curve also helps tame things and make a drawknife more agreeable in my hands. I use them both bevel up and bevel down, usually by just flipping the same tool over.

I use the work as a reference for edge prep rather than another tool, like a chisel, as my reference point. I believe that if you treat all edges the same then it`s like owning only a hammer, everything looks like a nail to you. Even in the kingdom of nails there are multiple variations as well as methods of holding, starting and driving this simple yet important bit of work. Sometimes all it takes is an almost unnoticeable ( to an untrained eye) change to make all the difference between having a productive day and making blood squirt out from under your fingernail first thing in the morning.

Just ask a roofer or anyone who has had a co-worker wax the face of their finishing hammer to explain how subtle differences can make all the difference in the world as well as the work.

Re: Back Bevels

#15

Alternative approach to pitting

Bob Hackett

I find that if I turn a really heavy burr (toward the back) on the edge of a pitted blade I can hone that burr off and the pitting many times disappears along with the burr. Just an alternative approach if you ever want or need a truly flat back rather than a micro bevel.

Re: Back Bevels

#16

Re: Alternative approach to pitting

chuck

Bob-

Do I understand that you are talking about turning a burr on the edge of a plane blade as if it was a scraper? That is a fix I hadn't heard of and I think I'll try. Thanks.

Re: Back Bevels

#17

Re: The real answer

TomD

All blades have back bevels some are just longer than others.

DKs are complex because a lot of what happens beyond edge geometry is actually sharpness or handle angle. The edges may look radically different, but if they present the same due to differences in the handle set, they are more similar than they seem at first look. They will cut differently if the bevels and clearances are different, but that is downstream of the actual bevels.

If you look at traditional tools like swords, axes, DKs, in many cases they did not sharpen them with a hollow grind, or even a flat bevel. They convex ground them. That is a whole other thing to discuss, but today there is a definite preference for what jigs or machines yield in the way of edge geometry. It would not surprise me if some of the modern Jeddi were promoting the flat bevel because students find them easier to sharpen. All other fancy talk aside, sharp, as sharp as technically possible, trumps just about every other marginal consideration.

A fourth kind of tool is the double bevel chisel as with some turning, or carving chisels.

Re: Back Bevels

#18

Re: Back Bevels

TomD

"I don't understand back bevels. Apparently, for some edge tools some people insist on them while others insist on a flat bevel. I "learned" early on that carving tools were sharpened with a pronounced, radiused back bevel to aid in controlling the cut."

Some part of this is that it is hard enough to sharpen a flat back let alone a radiused one, so some of this is for sharpening.

"Mary May, on the other hand, teaches to sharpen carving chisels with a flat bevel."

If the edge is more centered on the tool it raises the radius the geometry fits into. If as in the May case you use the full bevel on one side, you lower the radius. This assumes the same bevel length geometry to the bevel, there are other ways to handle this. If the bevels skewed to the angle of the tool, they would get smaller when centered which would offset this, but it is not the way the tools seem to roll.

"At WIA #1 in Berea, Roy Underhill covered sharpening draw knives in one of his programs and said that a properly sharpened draw knife has a radiused back bevel."

Well only if it has a radiused back bevel. Both of the antique DKs I have are aero shape, and have a knife edge, not a planer edge, therefore radiused BBs.

" He even had a live video set-up to demonstrate the effect of the back bevel on controlling the edge in the cut."

I don't see that having much effect, unless the back bevel is in the cut, in which case it is sorta the primary bevel? Otherwise it is just rubbing the shaving?

"Derek's sharpening method does just the opposite: it produces a hollow ground edge. I understand that hollow grinding aids free-hand honing, but what about Underhill's back bevel? What about back bevels in general? Do you use them? If so, on what tools? Why? What do they do for you?

Curious. "

So hollow ground or radiused bevels are a different mater that back bevels, just to set the stage.

Other than that, they seem to make the tool easier to sharpen, like a kitchen knife; they centralize the cutting geometry; for the same length of bevel, they fit into various radii; they produce different fulcrum geometry, but this is where the flat vs convex is a game changer; they distribute splitting forces in accordance with various plans (so for instance if one is splitting by halves, one wants a device with equal bevels. Keeping in mind that most all woodwork has a splitting element to it.)