Outdoor Furniture Design for Long Life
Bruce McCrory
This is a bit long, but I have been wanting to do similar for some time....
I have watched--sat in--western red cedar (WRC) furniture including purchased and homemade for 30, plus, years. Some design standards were developed from those years of observations for the intent of extending furniture life and function. My philosophy is that a wood object needs to be usable for as long as it took to grow the source; or, the source is not sustainable. There are no cute or indignant exceptions to this standard.
Wood is attacked by sun, moisture, seasonal changes (weathering) animals, insects, and decay molds and fungus. Did I forget anything? Moisture and weathering are the primary catalysts for damage. They are the carriers of the preceding nasty stuff.
Most outdoor furniture woods suffer similar strife. They are naturally durable in various ways, to various extents. The extent of silica compounds—lack of nutrients—will hinder decay. In this group, Black Locust (Robinia spp.) is a durable example. Wood density and maturity is a very good feature of durability. Douglas fir was great for wooden ship construction. It’s not so great in small dimensions on an exposed patio, but is still better than most pines. Western Red Cedar is one of the lightest of the durable woods. It has toxic salts that discourage attack by organisms. Some woods have oils that discourage attack. Teak is not a dense wood but has both glass and toxic oils to naturally protect it.
Do not relay on resistance based on habitat. Bristlecone pine has stood for thousands of years at Joshua Tree, but will be gone as soon as global warming brings in its pathogens. True lignum vitae—and related—will never work on everyone’s deck. It and a plethora of similar exotic woods are rare, slow-growing in their own tiny native habitats.
Trying to protect from one pathogen usually encourages a different enemy. A bloom of molds and mildew seeking the applied nutrients will follow “sealing” with waxes and preservatives, like Tung and boiled linseed oils, or paraffin. Rigid surface seals, epoxy, paint, and polyurethanes, are temporary protection for a surface, but must be stripped and replaced every year or two. These hard shells always have pores that allow entry of moisture and decay spores, yet restrict drying, so encourage extended attack within wood structure.
The recent introduction and marketing of toasted, less costly woods for exposed use relies on lack of nutrients for durability. Another by-product, water (wetting?) resistance, improves durability.
Applied preservatives are a catch 22; damned if you do, damned if you don’t. This conundrum brings us back to design.
The best protection for furniture is shade and shelter. Keep away moisture and sun. This design solution also allows use of practically any wood for furniture. If you want sun, drag the piece out from the covered porch, shed, or garage. Then return it as soon as you are done sunning. Another form of delayed obsolescence, less durable, is to set the furniture out for summer use then put it away during winter.
When the wood is protected by shelter painting to keep it in the family for generations is now a logical solution. So too is plastic, aluminum, and stainless steel furniture, which don’t need painting.
What if you can’t, or don’t want to put away that Teak table on the deck, or rustic cedar bench under the tree. It’s a landscape feature. In that case, we design the furniture to survive as long as possible.
The biggest wood killer by design is exposed end grain. The butt end of a log and stick disintegrates faster than any other part. Minimize end-grain exposure features. Or, cover it. The stylized Adirondack chair is walking end-grain. A delay tactic is to extend the wood piece (butt end) beyond a critical joint, so there is nibble and disintegration time-room.
With this warning are end-grain penetrations. Not only is it bad for glue, end-grain penetration is terrible for nail and screw adhesion. Obviously, don’t fall for the sticks-pretty-good-at-building excuse trick. Give a piece a couple, or even 5 years, to have those types of attachment fail, so the twenty-year obsolescence can convert to 5 years.
Mass is good for exterior wood furniture. If dainty is desired, find another material. Concede ego and save something for your grandchildren. Weathering wears down all wood. If I scrub, or power wash my deck (and, furniture) every year at least a 32nd inch of weathered surface is washed off. More like 1/16th inch goes away. Scraping algae, lichens, chipped paint—then sanding—removes the same. A half-inch of lost wood is 8 years of cleaning on Western Cedar. Twenty years ago I built cedar chairs with ¾-inch wood. A couple years ago I used at least 5/4 (1”) for all the horizontal parts.
Rot and decay love loose seams, cracks, and tightly butted wood pieces. Either open the joints to at least 3/16th inches for air circulation and cleaning, or use fewer, fatter pieces of wood. The “or option” in this case is not a viable solution for most wood. Weathering also likes to split larger sections of wood into narrower ones. We had split cedar shakes on our roof. Like clockwork, near the end of the 20-year warranty, wood started falling apart and tight-knots fell out. I used a toilet paper tube to mark one knothole during a repair. Years earlier, the 8-12-inch wide shingles had split into several narrower sections. Crows were about the only heavy object that passed over the wood. The split sections had grown gaps due to rubbing and decay growth. Normally dry underlying wood was also attacked, first at the splits.
Gap spacing in my area is about 1/4-inch and must account for Big-Leaf Maple winged seeds. It’s not so much to get the seeds to fall through gaps, but to be able to dig them out of the seams. Most of the larger maples have similar-sized progeny.
A tenoned joint using ¼-inch solid wood may be acceptable load bearing for Oak. That joint is a terrible mistake in furniture exposed to weather. Even 3/8ths is asking for short life. Western Cedar wants 3/4-inch thick wood, and thicker at major bearing points. All joints should be simple long grain to long grain laps.
Any surface, dead end pocket, that permits sedimentation and water access (without airing) is an invitation to decay germination and growth.
I don’t know how epoxy glue will hold up to abuse. After three years the glue is solid on my chairs, but as protective paint, epoxy sucks over WRC. The paint cracks, peels, and sheds readily after one year. Thank God it is easy to strip. I think glue will fare the same due to weak fiber structure in the wood.
Most species of exterior use woods differentiate between sap and heartwood for durability. As a rule, stay away from sapwood. It is harder to identify each type when the mill treats wood to blend both types into a look-alike color.
Most exterior hardware should not be married to iron in any form. The exception is stainless steel. Most natural preservatives in wood also attack iron. You can tempt fate. An 8d finish nail will rot through at some point in WRC, in Western Washington within ten years. That size nail also needs to be clenched on modern wood fences. A corrugated version gets iffy after 15 years. Just use expensive screws of exotic formulations like brass, stainless, and whatever works for pressure treated lumber. I didn’t have coated deck screws two decades ago, so this next set of furniture may yield results before I die. Or, trees will be gone and this effort is wasted. Bigger hardware is also always better.
A general rule I follow in outdoor construction is “over-design.” If one-half-inch works, use twice the thickness. For one-inch, use 1.5”, even two. Structural engineers would laugh at my half-inch carriage bolts and 3x6 timbers. Most of my designs reviewed by those lexicons of efficiency included notes to the effect of: “OK to use”. They were used to interior design tables. Presently, I would never use anything thinner than 7/8-inch lumber for outdoor use wood.
Clear as old growth timber.