New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

Posts

Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#1

Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

Patrick Gibbons

I'm building a patio table out of cypress and adapted a design from The Practical Woodworker. Decided that mortise and tenon joints might be subject to too much movement from rain and climate and made bridle joints on the top rail and dovetailed half laps for the bottom rail. I'm going to use construction adhesive and brass screws to secure the joints. Now I'm questioning my logic. Why would mortise and tenon not be the best joints? My decision making was influenced by Adirondack furniture I've made in the past. Any educated opinions out there? Too late for this project but I'm curious. Maybe it will help someone else.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#2

Outdoor Furniture Design for Long Life

Bruce McCrory

This is a bit long, but I have been wanting to do similar for some time....

I have watched--sat in--western red cedar (WRC) furniture including purchased and homemade for 30, plus, years. Some design standards were developed from those years of observations for the intent of extending furniture life and function. My philosophy is that a wood object needs to be usable for as long as it took to grow the source; or, the source is not sustainable. There are no cute or indignant exceptions to this standard.

Wood is attacked by sun, moisture, seasonal changes (weathering) animals, insects, and decay molds and fungus. Did I forget anything? Moisture and weathering are the primary catalysts for damage. They are the carriers of the preceding nasty stuff.

Most outdoor furniture woods suffer similar strife. They are naturally durable in various ways, to various extents. The extent of silica compounds—lack of nutrients—will hinder decay. In this group, Black Locust (Robinia spp.) is a durable example. Wood density and maturity is a very good feature of durability. Douglas fir was great for wooden ship construction. It’s not so great in small dimensions on an exposed patio, but is still better than most pines. Western Red Cedar is one of the lightest of the durable woods. It has toxic salts that discourage attack by organisms. Some woods have oils that discourage attack. Teak is not a dense wood but has both glass and toxic oils to naturally protect it.

Do not relay on resistance based on habitat. Bristlecone pine has stood for thousands of years at Joshua Tree, but will be gone as soon as global warming brings in its pathogens. True lignum vitae—and related—will never work on everyone’s deck. It and a plethora of similar exotic woods are rare, slow-growing in their own tiny native habitats.

Trying to protect from one pathogen usually encourages a different enemy. A bloom of molds and mildew seeking the applied nutrients will follow “sealing” with waxes and preservatives, like Tung and boiled linseed oils, or paraffin. Rigid surface seals, epoxy, paint, and polyurethanes, are temporary protection for a surface, but must be stripped and replaced every year or two. These hard shells always have pores that allow entry of moisture and decay spores, yet restrict drying, so encourage extended attack within wood structure.

The recent introduction and marketing of toasted, less costly woods for exposed use relies on lack of nutrients for durability. Another by-product, water (wetting?) resistance, improves durability.

Applied preservatives are a catch 22; damned if you do, damned if you don’t. This conundrum brings us back to design.

The best protection for furniture is shade and shelter. Keep away moisture and sun. This design solution also allows use of practically any wood for furniture. If you want sun, drag the piece out from the covered porch, shed, or garage. Then return it as soon as you are done sunning. Another form of delayed obsolescence, less durable, is to set the furniture out for summer use then put it away during winter.

When the wood is protected by shelter painting to keep it in the family for generations is now a logical solution. So too is plastic, aluminum, and stainless steel furniture, which don’t need painting.

What if you can’t, or don’t want to put away that Teak table on the deck, or rustic cedar bench under the tree. It’s a landscape feature. In that case, we design the furniture to survive as long as possible.

The biggest wood killer by design is exposed end grain. The butt end of a log and stick disintegrates faster than any other part. Minimize end-grain exposure features. Or, cover it. The stylized Adirondack chair is walking end-grain. A delay tactic is to extend the wood piece (butt end) beyond a critical joint, so there is nibble and disintegration time-room.

With this warning are end-grain penetrations. Not only is it bad for glue, end-grain penetration is terrible for nail and screw adhesion. Obviously, don’t fall for the sticks-pretty-good-at-building excuse trick. Give a piece a couple, or even 5 years, to have those types of attachment fail, so the twenty-year obsolescence can convert to 5 years.

Mass is good for exterior wood furniture. If dainty is desired, find another material. Concede ego and save something for your grandchildren. Weathering wears down all wood. If I scrub, or power wash my deck (and, furniture) every year at least a 32nd inch of weathered surface is washed off. More like 1/16th inch goes away. Scraping algae, lichens, chipped paint—then sanding—removes the same. A half-inch of lost wood is 8 years of cleaning on Western Cedar. Twenty years ago I built cedar chairs with ¾-inch wood. A couple years ago I used at least 5/4 (1”) for all the horizontal parts.

Rot and decay love loose seams, cracks, and tightly butted wood pieces. Either open the joints to at least 3/16th inches for air circulation and cleaning, or use fewer, fatter pieces of wood. The “or option” in this case is not a viable solution for most wood. Weathering also likes to split larger sections of wood into narrower ones. We had split cedar shakes on our roof. Like clockwork, near the end of the 20-year warranty, wood started falling apart and tight-knots fell out. I used a toilet paper tube to mark one knothole during a repair. Years earlier, the 8-12-inch wide shingles had split into several narrower sections. Crows were about the only heavy object that passed over the wood. The split sections had grown gaps due to rubbing and decay growth. Normally dry underlying wood was also attacked, first at the splits.

Gap spacing in my area is about 1/4-inch and must account for Big-Leaf Maple winged seeds. It’s not so much to get the seeds to fall through gaps, but to be able to dig them out of the seams. Most of the larger maples have similar-sized progeny.

A tenoned joint using ¼-inch solid wood may be acceptable load bearing for Oak. That joint is a terrible mistake in furniture exposed to weather. Even 3/8ths is asking for short life. Western Cedar wants 3/4-inch thick wood, and thicker at major bearing points. All joints should be simple long grain to long grain laps.

Any surface, dead end pocket, that permits sedimentation and water access (without airing) is an invitation to decay germination and growth.

I don’t know how epoxy glue will hold up to abuse. After three years the glue is solid on my chairs, but as protective paint, epoxy sucks over WRC. The paint cracks, peels, and sheds readily after one year. Thank God it is easy to strip. I think glue will fare the same due to weak fiber structure in the wood.

Most species of exterior use woods differentiate between sap and heartwood for durability. As a rule, stay away from sapwood. It is harder to identify each type when the mill treats wood to blend both types into a look-alike color.

Most exterior hardware should not be married to iron in any form. The exception is stainless steel. Most natural preservatives in wood also attack iron. You can tempt fate. An 8d finish nail will rot through at some point in WRC, in Western Washington within ten years. That size nail also needs to be clenched on modern wood fences. A corrugated version gets iffy after 15 years. Just use expensive screws of exotic formulations like brass, stainless, and whatever works for pressure treated lumber. I didn’t have coated deck screws two decades ago, so this next set of furniture may yield results before I die. Or, trees will be gone and this effort is wasted. Bigger hardware is also always better.

A general rule I follow in outdoor construction is “over-design.” If one-half-inch works, use twice the thickness. For one-inch, use 1.5”, even two. Structural engineers would laugh at my half-inch carriage bolts and 3x6 timbers. Most of my designs reviewed by those lexicons of efficiency included notes to the effect of: “OK to use”. They were used to interior design tables. Presently, I would never use anything thinner than 7/8-inch lumber for outdoor use wood.

Clear as old growth timber.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#3

Re: Outdoor Furniture Design for Long Life

Patrick Gibbons

Bruce, your reply was the kind of response I was looking for. It seems harder to get posts like yours now than it use to be. I refuse to use pressure treated wood unless I have to. Cypress was the traditional choice here on the Gulf Coast but the wood available is not as resistant to rot as old growth was. Eastern red cedar is incredibly good. It sounds like I made sound choices for joints. I had wanted to finish with polyurethane so the beauty of the cypress would show, but still may go with paint because of its superior protection against rotting. Your comments would be appreciated.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#4

Re: Outdoor Furniture Design for Long Life

chuck

Thank you for the excellent discussion about failure of outdoor furniture, the failure of the finishes, and the failure of the joints.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#5

Design vs Construction vs Durability

Bruce McCrory

I saw (didn't read) a FWW article (on sale now) by Mike Fortune about building an outdoor chair. He is bending glued laminations of some mahogany species. Beside the point that few of the called mahoganies are even modestly durable, the ones left for use are not durable. The lamination suits a design and reduces the exposure life of the furniture. His design is a total failure, and a worse disgrace if the wood is salvage.

Nice, huh? We see the same old thing spun in a new package and run out to get it. Consumption is finite, in spite of 1st World fantasies and greed to mount the last elephant trophy on a den wall.

My observations might look dismal. However, for people like you and me the cause of failure must be identified, as best we can analyse. Then we seek correction, solve the question. Enjoy solving the problem, Chuck.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#6

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsig

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would have used mortise and tenon joints. If you have a 7/8 apron joining 2 inch legs for your table, you can have a tenon that is 3/8 or even thicker. I would forget the glue and use a wooden pin to secure the joint so repair is easy. Roubo illustrated mortise and tenon joinery for garden furniture in 1770, the English garden furniture of the 19th century was mortise and tenon, and such joinery made in the 20th century is still in use.

Here is an anecdote. In 1980 I went to the junkyard to get a window to make a cold frame. I picked out a $1 window, but when the owner realized my purpose, he said "you don't want that; I have regular hot bed sash." So he got me a 36X72 sash and a few panes to replace the missing ones. It was painted, but worn and peeled in places and appeared to be 30 or 40 years old.

Over the years I reputtied but never painted the sash. It has long 65 inch muntins but no cross muntins and last winter one muntin tenon broke under the weight of ice and snow. (The escarole survived) The main mortise and tenon joints are still solid. I think 70 years is pretty good for something that was not well maintained.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#7

Paint for Protection

Bruce McCrory

Thanks, Patrick. The only reason for my reply was the need to record some observations. What you read is a "first draft". Well, a current mulling. You did pose a fairly comprehensive question, however.

I posed the same finish question for a set of cedar chairs a couple years ago, 3 summers. There was an article in FWW that reviewed exterior finishes of the same type in various US climates. I think they were all clear finishes. I used two types from that list.

A problem with light woods such as WRC, Eastern Cedar, and Cypress is the poor adhesion these woods exhibit with "thick" surface attachments. Any weathered wood fibers are merely hanging, and surface tension (or similar) won't permit deep penetration. Quite large sheets of glue, paint, and shell-type varnishes will easily peel away, with a micro thin layer of wood fiber.

The first finish was epoxy, covered by spar varnish. Both finishes were ghastly expensive. The epoxy did not flow well, and could only be brushed in small (Pint-size) quantities to avoid getting too stiff. I tried to thin it with denatured alcohol. Epoxy does not store well in my garage, so consider waste of leftovers. The finish is pretty glossy, and ugly. One coat; it was so hard to apply.

The spar varnish covered the epoxy to tone down the gloss. Didn't matter, however. The next summer, after winter exposure, the finish had a bluish plastic look and showed ugly patches of separation from the cedar. By summer #2, the finish was well on its way to shedding. This is advantageous for stripping ease.

The second chair was covered in spar varnish, two coats. I am used to this varnish and blend it with turps, and BLO to make a soft oil type finish. No matter, a winter of rain and wet, plus the finish, yields a black, blotchy, mildew surface. It was Epifanes. That finish is persisting.

My wife was unimpressed with the clear finish. So, after more of the existing finish sheds I will strip the loose, then paint-stain. That will be an experiment, too.

Have been toying with the idea of "milk" paint as, and combined with stains. The only way a finish will adhere to Western Cedar is have a thin preservative soaking deep into the pores and fibers (substantial depth) and; then, surface that 'primer' with a durable and flexible finish. I don't think a poorly breathing shell seal is desired, however.

Will see, in a year or two...

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#8

Greenhouse sash

Bruce McCrory

Tough stuff! I know what you have. Worked in a greenhouse my final year of HS, plus. Every summer the boss climbed up into the gutters and sprayed thin paint on the glass for shading. I would have refused to climb onto the glass, but he never gave me the opportunity.

Occasionally, the points would rust through enough to release the panes. A whole section of panes could slide down the "ribs" like cards, before collapsing.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#9

Clear finishes

Bruce McCrory

You will likely be disappointed by a poly finish. They are fantastic for interior work, but don't have the flex to swell and shrink with seasonal movement outdoors. Spar varnishes are the choice, still, outside. Best place to research is wooden boat magazines.

But, like every market, hype can confuse. I went to a nearby marine store and got both epoxy and Epifanes (spar varnish). You may be better there, because boat people are rabid about durability.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#10

Treated wood

Bruce McCrory

The lumber industry cannot supply the demand for naturally resistant woods. There are very few species suitable for decay and pest resistance, and all of the species rely upon heartwood and old growth for duration of the efficacy of resistance. None of those harvested woods have a useful life anywhere near the age of the source log. In the USA harvests are into second growth and younger timber cycles.

Treated wood, including the cypress you want to finish (treat), extend the useful life of the wood object. We beat up "pressure treated" wood because the toxic chemicals used to preserve it are pretty scary. They are really no worse than the mess we create for alternate treatments.

I have specified miles of wetland, and wetland buffer fencing. Every last stick of it has been pressure treated wood, as specified. I have fought with the biggest jurisdictions in Washington because they don't want that "poison wood" in their wetlands. They specify split cedar.

Funny. No, really tragic and stupid. The fences are outside of the protection area. There are no suitable "old growth" cedar logs that will last even 10 years. Old growth might stand for 15 years. Most of this material (in my experience) was harvested and produced by 'Cedar Savages', who have that name for a reason. The fence serves only to mark and warn of a protected area. Cedar rails and posts are quaint, traditional, and aesthetically pleasing. Why, a fence; where it is; purpose, function, and the list of questions continues. So, millions of feet of a precious resource is threatened, destroyed due to ignorance.

No, pressure treated wood serves a very useful, and functional purpose. What regulators failed to do was force a method of decontamination. In the mean time, I hope that the new toasted woods can replace both a depleted resource, and a toxic alternate.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#11

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsig

Patrick Gibbons

The Practical Woodworker has an outside table plan with M&T joints. That's what got me to questioning myself originally.

Toasted wood, or thermally modified wood, seems to be a very good alternative. Just try to find some to buy in small quantities.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#12

Re: Outdoor Furniture Design for Long Life

TomD

"My philosophy is that a wood object needs to be usable for as long as it took to grow the source; or, the source is not sustainable. There are no cute or indignant exceptions to this standard. "

Well written piece.

Sustainability of old growth is not going to happen it is mine-able resource. In the book The Way of the Carpenter, there is a historical piece that traces the development of Japanese tools from their earliest, very simple forms, to the near present. What was interesting was that the changes in tools were driven by changes in the wood. Basically the wood always got worse, and the tools had to adapt to it. This was a revelation, I thought we started running out of wood in the 80s. :)

This might have been particularly an issue in Japan, where the aesthetic is one of purity and perfection of the source wood, not veneers of swirly junk wood, and also not a culture driven by science as much as the 19th century west was.

I don't think any available woods really lasts that well in the elements. Teak was the one that was grown sustainably, at one time. But they mined it out, and at it's best, the sustainable stuff was not the teak that put the teak in teak.

One consideration is to look at the structures. They are basically posts and beams. Oddly, even with ground contact, and end grain exposed to the sky, the posts often last better, while the beams (seats, or horizontal load members) rot away. Epoxy sinks into endgrain fairly deeply, so it can help the post elements quite well. As you say, it doesn't stick to the sides well. One thing there, the basic rule is you need to laminate over the 3/4", so the extra half inch rule could be making things worse. Ultimately it might be better to make the horizontals out of recycled plastics as they are increasingly doing with decks. Fancy talk aside, the softwood genocide has been heavily pushed by decks that only last a few years, where the wood might have been used in musical instruments that last centuries.

Beyond that, one can build real wood structures for the out of doors, wood epoxy saturation technique, as with boats, the wood lasts for centuries, or at least for 50 years with no sign of any problem or shortening of the lifespan. toxic resins that outlast the wood entombed in them, have a long history.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#13

Beat and be beaten

Bruce McCrory

My philosophy and motivation (commitment) to that end have always had a line of detractors gloving up to oppose. Personally, I try to buy second hand, salvage and reuse, and source local, ie., use indigenous and native wood species. I do think we all, in this personal effort for quality work, have that sense for preservation.

"Basically the wood always got worse, and the tools had to adapt to it."

I have wondered if our fondness for gnarly character, running to the fire wood pile, is a tacit bow to the state of affairs at the lumber yard. It might look interesting, but spalted wood is mouldering junk from a forest floor, or lumber yard waste pile in my eye.

Re: Outdoor furniture, 2nd guessing, 20-20 hindsight

#14

Thermally modified wood for exterior use

Bruce McCrory

"Toasted wood, or thermally modified wood, seems to be a very good alternative. Just try to find some to buy in small quantities."

I think this wood is gaining more traction. I saw my first samples at a specialty wood store in Seattle a couple years ago. It had specialty pricing, also.

The examples were Red Oak and Poplar. They reminded me of scorched wood that was cleaned of charcoal. Some must have been in that state. Nearly black, and brittle, hard and really light compared to un-treated, I was inclined to find some different samples by other processors. Of the two, Poplar looked safer. The Oak was very splintery and dangerous looking.

My anticipation for using thermally modified wood was severely deflated. I may call Rob Lee for advice. His chisel handles seem ideal.