File + scrape, and other stuff..
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Rolf and all,
You didn't mention whether the flutes will end in a taper, or if they will run flush into the overhead board. Coupla ideas anyway…
1. The gouge. In principle, a No. 9 sweep is half-round, either in the Sheffield or Continental style. A 1/2" or 12mm would be the theoretical width, however, as Wm. Duffield says, it would be better to rough it out with a little narrower width, and then file/scrape to final surface. Big problem I see with a carving gouge (out cannel) would be keeping the bottom aligned with the routed section--in principal a pattern makers cranked gouge would be best, as it would nestle into the flute and be self-aligning--but these are rare, and trying to find one in the right sweep/width would be about impossible (and expensive).
2. Help from friends. Do you know a gunmaker nearby? If so, a consultation might help, because what you're doing is kinda similar to a barrel-inletting problem.
3. Practical solutions. I would recommend not trying to make the finished cut with a gouge, unless you have lots of experience with gouges (in other words, I wouldn't try it myself
). I suggest a half round file that will fit into the flute (even if not perfectly), followed by a 1/2" diameter scraper of the type Wm. Duffield showed, or similar as sold by gunmaker's suppliers like Brownell's.
Incidentally, the amazing Don McConnell figured out gouge sweeps and wrote a treatise on Sheffield sweep/width geometry here:
http://www.planemaker.com/articles_gouges.html
and then he extended the analysis with a comparison to Continental sweeps here:
http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=19902kNIBMRmnumLED531402239429;spage=1;sanc=142780;sbid=3109;md=read;id=142780#m_142780
Note that #9 sweep is the half-round, in either series.
Wiley