New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

gouge to match 1/2" router bit

Posts

gouge to match 1/2" router bit

#1

gouge to match 1/2" router bit

Rolf Selvig

Hello,

I was wondering if anyone knew what size carving gouge I can purchase to match 1/2" round Freud router bit. I made a fluted pilaster for an entrance on a Victorian house and now that it is installed I need to extend the fluting just a bit but i can't fit the router in place so I was going to try to complete the clean-up with a gouge. Any ideas?

Thanks,

Rolf

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

#2

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

Philip F Duffy

Why not take the router bit to the nearest Woodcraft store and match the 2 of them. - - just my 2 c. Philip

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

#3

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

William Duffield

If you don't have a Woodcraft near you, use this chart.

http://www.woodcraft.com/articles/articles.aspx?articleid=396&page=1

But first you will need to calibrate the .jpg chart. You can do that by measuring across the sweeps with a metric ruler and enlarging or shrinking on a Xerox machine, or using an appropriate application on your PC.

I don't know where to find an equivalent chart for other manufacturers' carving gouges, and Woodcraft is the only importer of Pfeil gouges that I am aware of.

If you can't fine an exact match, choose the next smaller sweep. With a smaller sweep, you can always take another cut to fit, but if the sweep of the gouge is too large, it will dig in on the sides and remove too much material.

Another option to get a perfect match, after removing most of the material with a gouge, is to scrape with one of these:

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2020022/28386/Lynx-Convex-Cabinet-Scraper-Set-(2).aspx

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

#4

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

Rolf Selvig

Wow, great resource on the WoodCraft site. Thanks so much. Unfortunately they local branch close a few years back so I cant go look and compare bit to gouge but this chart looks pretty good.

Thank you for your help.

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

#5

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

William Duffield

There's a Woodcraft down in San Carlos. You might try calling them and explaining what you need. If you can find an employee with a little carving experience, they should be able to compare the gouges they have in stock to your Freud router bit, which they should also have in stock, and pick out the appropriate gouge. They should be able to take your credit card and mail you the gouge. It will take a few days longer than ordering one from Parkersburg, but the shipping might be a lot less and the service better.

At least that's the sort of service we always gave our customers when I worked for one of the Woodcraft franchises. All the other franchises in "our neck of the woods" would provide the same kind of service.

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

#6

File + scrape, and other stuff..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Rolf and all,

You didn't mention whether the flutes will end in a taper, or if they will run flush into the overhead board. Coupla ideas anyway…

1. The gouge. In principle, a No. 9 sweep is half-round, either in the Sheffield or Continental style. A 1/2" or 12mm would be the theoretical width, however, as Wm. Duffield says, it would be better to rough it out with a little narrower width, and then file/scrape to final surface. Big problem I see with a carving gouge (out cannel) would be keeping the bottom aligned with the routed section--in principal a pattern makers cranked gouge would be best, as it would nestle into the flute and be self-aligning--but these are rare, and trying to find one in the right sweep/width would be about impossible (and expensive).

2. Help from friends. Do you know a gunmaker nearby? If so, a consultation might help, because what you're doing is kinda similar to a barrel-inletting problem.

3. Practical solutions. I would recommend not trying to make the finished cut with a gouge, unless you have lots of experience with gouges (in other words, I wouldn't try it myself :) ). I suggest a half round file that will fit into the flute (even if not perfectly), followed by a 1/2" diameter scraper of the type Wm. Duffield showed, or similar as sold by gunmaker's suppliers like Brownell's.

Incidentally, the amazing Don McConnell figured out gouge sweeps and wrote a treatise on Sheffield sweep/width geometry here:

http://www.planemaker.com/articles_gouges.html

and then he extended the analysis with a comparison to Continental sweeps here:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=19902kNIBMRmnumLED531402239429;spage=1;sanc=142780;sbid=3109;md=read;id=142780#m_142780

Note that #9 sweep is the half-round, in either series.

Wiley

Re: gouge to match 1/2" router bit

#7

Re: File + scrape, and other stuff..

Rolf Selvig

Thank you all for your insight and advice. I really appreciate it. While I am an admitted tool junkie and pretty picky finish carpenter and do build casework and occasional furniture pieces, I have zero experience carving. I am eager and willing to learn a few new skills but not at the cost of destroying new work just put-in-place on a nearly completed job...with a happy set of customers too boot.

So I am going to mock up some sort of extension on a trim router and finish with a proper side dowel, sand paper and a that cool looking scraper that was previously suggested.

I really don't care what anybody says about woodworkers. You guys are great! ;-}

Thanks again for the outstanding commentary.