Re: Krenov?
TomD
He did hollow grind, and it says something, but he also totally reground the back and used a micro bevel. I actually ground a few Japanese chisels that way, since I have several sets, and though I wouldn't do it again, It does work well. However, Krenov is a Japanese chisel user, but not in the Japanese style. I would disregard everything he does, except that it shows that what he does can be done.
So should you hollow grind the chisel. If it will save you significant time, and you want to do it, you have the right gear for it:
1) The Japanese hollow grind their chisels an large wheels.
2) The Japanese Don't hand grind when they make them.
3) I have hollow dry ground them.
But...
4) one real reason to leave the bevel flat (at least after you get them where you want them), is to support the overall bevel on the stone. The japanese chisel is made of two types of metal, and the soft iron will wear very fast compared to the edge. If in addition, you grind most of the bevel away, yes you will make quick work of honing the chisel, but it will also have a tendency to lengthen the bevel and loose control in the sharpening because the hair line of iron will reduce even more quickly. To get the full experience you need to sharpen Japanese chisels by hand with a flat bevel. If one is like that rich guy I read about (true story) who used silk napkins instead of toilet paper, one can do any number of things while sharpening Japanese chisels, that will still yield good performance while using them in odd and wonderful ways. Krenov got away with the described dilemna because he was using micro bevels so there wasn't any iron left in the bevel.
So yeah, grind away, you can always go flat later, maybe initially using a jig if you have one.