New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Japanese chisel ID

Posts

Japanese chisel ID

#1

Japanese chisel ID

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We were cruising the garage sales today, and I found this*:




I know very little of Japanese chisels, although I know enough to recognize that the previous owner smashed the wood down nicely around the hoop. Have I purchased a cheap chisel? Mid-grade? Fabulous $1 find?

---------

*I'm always intrigued when I go to a sale and find a tool completely out of context. Besides this chisel, there wasn't even a rusty screwdriver at the sale. I have no idea how this chisel got there.

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#2

Re: Japanese chisel ID

TomD

I can't identiy it for you. It is interesting he didn't even remove the label.

It has a rounded hoop, which is a pretty good indicator of origin if it came from a tool catalog (aside from the obvious read the label if one could thing)

The handle doesn't appear on straight, and it is red oak, which isn't so good.

Prep it properly and the proof is in the use.

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#3

Prepping

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The edge is a little ragged, so it'll need grinding. I normally grind with a Delta wet grinder, of a design that they no longer make but similar to a Tormek: 10" diameter wet wheel turning slowly. This gives a shallow hollow grind. Some of the posts I've seen on Japanese chisels advocate strongly for a flat grind. Is this truly necessary?

The handle is on straight; the crookedness in the photos is an optical illusion, probably caused by the angle at which I took the pictures.

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Out of context

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

I stopped at a garage sale a few years ago. There was an elderly man in the garage of a 30 year old house with a table of knickknacks. Little crystal candle holders and soap dishes and such. I was about to walk out when I saw a pair of handsaws on the wall hanging from a nail. One of them caught my eye. The other was a 1980s era rusty dull handsaw. The one that caught my attention was a backsaw with a brass back and it looked old. I asked if they were for sale and he said "I guess so,sure"It was a 14" 8tpi crosscut.Very heavy with a beefy brass back engraved with "A. Mathieson and son Glasgow.The medallion says Alex Mathieson and son Glasgow and Edinburgh. Saw plate clean and straight with a light fine rust in a few places. He had no idea and would have let me have it for a couple bucks. I gave him $25 and was a very happy guy.I told him who the maker was. Only other tools in the garage were stuff like leaf rakes and cheap screwdrivers.I figured that the tool gods put it there for me to save from oblivion.---Jack

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#5

Re: Prepping

Howard Pollack

The folks who are into those chisels all say "flat grind". However, Krenov used to hollow grind his and they worked for him. I've done the same without any problem. Maybe someone who was tougher on the chisels would have different results...

-Howard

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#6

Re: Prepping

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

You can tell from the hollow that this chisel has seen very little if any use. That small land behind the edge is exactly the width they come from the maker. It's a good find.

I don't know the brand, but the JWW house brand always got good reviews from users, so you can get a very good usable chisel from Japan at the house brand level.

The only chipping problem I have ever had with hollow-grinding a Japanese chisel was with a mortise chisel taken to 25 degrees and hollow, and used on satinwood (it's hard). And that was on a truly hard chisel. Many Japanese chisels are tempered closer to 220C than 180C, which is the difference between RC63-64 versus 60-61.

I suggest hollow grind it to an overall primary bevel of 30 degrees, hone at 30, and go from there.

Thanks for posting!

Wiley

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#7

Re: Prepping--P. S.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Howard reminded us that Mr. Krenov hollow-ground his Japanese chisels. His grinder was in the ballpark of 5-6" diameter IIRC. The 10" grind you're talking about is of course much shallower.

Wiley

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#8

Re: Krenov?

TomD

He did hollow grind, and it says something, but he also totally reground the back and used a micro bevel. I actually ground a few Japanese chisels that way, since I have several sets, and though I wouldn't do it again, It does work well. However, Krenov is a Japanese chisel user, but not in the Japanese style. I would disregard everything he does, except that it shows that what he does can be done.

So should you hollow grind the chisel. If it will save you significant time, and you want to do it, you have the right gear for it:

1) The Japanese hollow grind their chisels an large wheels.

2) The Japanese Don't hand grind when they make them.

3) I have hollow dry ground them.

But...

4) one real reason to leave the bevel flat (at least after you get them where you want them), is to support the overall bevel on the stone. The japanese chisel is made of two types of metal, and the soft iron will wear very fast compared to the edge. If in addition, you grind most of the bevel away, yes you will make quick work of honing the chisel, but it will also have a tendency to lengthen the bevel and loose control in the sharpening because the hair line of iron will reduce even more quickly. To get the full experience you need to sharpen Japanese chisels by hand with a flat bevel. If one is like that rich guy I read about (true story) who used silk napkins instead of toilet paper, one can do any number of things while sharpening Japanese chisels, that will still yield good performance while using them in odd and wonderful ways. Krenov got away with the described dilemna because he was using micro bevels so there wasn't any iron left in the bevel.

So yeah, grind away, you can always go flat later, maybe initially using a jig if you have one.

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#9

Re: Prepping

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I hollow grind all of my Japanese chisels on a Tormek. The large wheel creates a shallow hollow and the wet grinding is protective of the temper. On bench and dovetail chisels the grind is 30 degrees, and the slicks at 25 degrees. The hollow is used as a guide for freehand honing, so the bevel angle remains the same. This is a faster and more accurate method of sharpening than honing on the flat bevel, and I do not use secondary bevels on chisels.

It is about 6 years on since purchasing a Tormek and in the time I have used the chisels this way on our local hardwoods, there has not been any chipping or failure in the edges.

One more reference is David Charlesworth, whose lead I followed here.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#10

Re: Japanese chisel ID

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't get it, Bill. You once claimed to live in "old tool hell" and yet you find Japanese chisels at a garage sale? I'll bet I have the only Japanese chisel in my whole county ;)

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#11

There is a quote, but I can't find it right now

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I want to think it's from/by Saroyan, to the effect that, no matter where you are in life, some people are better off than you, and some worse*. I got the impression this is an old tool hell from some of the show-and-tells from people like Todd Hughes and Walt Quadrato, whose every weekend is about equal to the best summer I've ever had. But I've come to realize that this area is somewhere around a mid-point of richness.

For what it's worth, this was about the first "oh, now that was a worthwhile Saturday" of the season. In the conversation about this chisel over on WoodNet, the consensus is that this is a mid-grade or lower-grade chisel. We shall see when I get the round tuits in my time budget to clean it up.

-------------

*The line was in a book from my junior high years, and was part of advice to a young boy from one of his elders, the message of which was not to compare himself to others.

Re: Japanese chisel ID

#12

Re: There is a quote, but I can't find it right no

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I swear, next time we visit it's going to be on a Saturday, and we're hitting the garage sales!