New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

epoxy

Posts

epoxy

#1

epoxy

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Does anyone have a preference between System Three T-88 and West System 105 epoxies? I'm inclined toward the T-88 because it comes in smaller sizes (it's available relatively locally in half-pint units) but users have said it is more runny than West brand epoxies.

Re: epoxy

#2

I can't compare them...

John in NM

But West system is pretty thin stuff to begin with :D

We used it almost exclusively for filling voids and stuff, and for that thin was good. I remember it was just thick enough to brush or roll onto a surface for bag laminating.

Re: epoxy

#3

Re: epoxy

TomD

Well you don't say what you are using it for...

Here you can see the T-88 being mixed at around 12:00:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PXd11KC07ZE

It is a pretty typical 2 part mix out of bottles where it is stiff enough to go up the stick as you mix.

Comparatively West is wet like maple syrup, or corn syrop.

There are far runnier epoxies still, particularly those modified for application over cloth with a roller (west works great on cloth but you have to spread it with a squeegee.

The thing is that while WEST is far runnier that T-88, WEST is normally used with a range of products to modify it characteristics. These include colloidal silica which stiffens it and cuts running dead in it's tracks. CS if overused will lead to a hard to sand, brittle, heavier epoxy glue, that yields poorly. But there are other products like microballoons that can be added to extend the mix, give large batches, that are lighter syntactic foams. So a recipe I use a lot is 3 parts micro balloons to 1 part silica. Not to say that you can't just use WEST without these additives.

Basically, if you have used 5 minute epoxy and found the consistency useful for what you are currently doing, T-88 is like that. That is why guys use it to spot weld stuff like the airplane components. WEST is great for projects where you need a thinner glue, and particularly a glue that will be strong and versatile. It can be used as a coating, sealer, lamination resin, glue, casting parts, harware bonding, fabric wet-out etc...

West is similar (better than) Sytem three's classic resin, they offer several products that are in the range (they bought up a bunch of brands). S3 stuff, and indeed sometimes west are offered in trial pack size. With T-88 (one of the brands S3 bought up) it is already in smaller packs. MAS is another you might find a trial pack in.

Re: epoxy

#4

Re: epoxy *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You described the method I want to use for holding a spindle to a base here. I can't get small quantities of West System locally, but Woodcraft does carry System Three.


setting bolts in end grain

Re: epoxy

#5

Re: epoxy

William Duffield

More info on bonding metal fasteners to various substrates, directly from the people who developed West System:

This article is for fiberglass, but the techniques also apply to wood (more or less):

http://www.westsystem.com/ss/repairing-machined-holes-in-fiberglass/

And here is an index to many useful articles, including the one I sited above:

http://www.westsystem.com/ss/

You can't get this kind of help from System 3, which is one reason I have kept my loyalty to West System.

Re: epoxy

#6

Re: epoxy

BrianMonumentCO

I don't know if you care to learn about other epoxies.

As a gunsmith, I use a product line called Acraglas sold by Brownells.

The product line has several variants of epoxy.

They come in different sizes.

One is what I call runny acraglas that I use on stock repairs where I want seepage into cracks etc.

And the other variant I use is a gel kind of like peanut butter in consistancy.

I use the gel for glas bedding and fixing various objects like sling hardware to stocks.

I use either one on wood, metal, plastic (need to rough it up).

Believe me when I say that epoxy can bond wood to metal....... been there, wish I hadn't.

It sets up a little faster and stays basically where it is put...... just like peanut butter unless mice get it.

Bot runny and gel acraglas can be colored. For us gunsmiths brown, black and a white are provided colors.

I have used a tint color to create an orange color for a site I made by hand. Used white coloring and the tint to get the site color.

Re: epoxy

#7

Re: epoxy

TomD

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2000338/2383/System-Three-Epoxy-Resin-Quart.aspx

That is their original product, and it is a good one for general use. Not as strong as west for hardware bonding, but a very good product you shouldn't have any problems with. Epoxy requires accurate and thorough mixing, it is not a catalytic reaction, the molecules in the two parts need to be thoroughly introduced for maximum effectiveness.

If you are able to contain the stud so that it is sitting in a hole, then you should be able to get good results without any additives. Adding some colloidal will control running.

Re: epoxy

#8

Re: epoxy thickeners

William Duffield

System Three silica powder also works with West System epoxy. I suspect it is the same material as West's colloidal silica.

I have erroneously been warning people about the hazards of these products. I looked up their MSDSs. Both are colloidal silica, NOT crystalline silica. While they can cause respiratory irritation, they are evidently NOT a cause of silicosis.

http://www.westsystem.com/ss/assets/MSDS/MSDS406.pdf

http://www.systemthree.com/reslibrary/msds/SilicaThickener_MSDS.pdf

http://www.cbs.state.or.us/osha/pdf/pubs/3301.pdf

Re: epoxy

#9

Re: epoxy thickeners

TomD

Yeah, all the additives are interchangeable to the degree they all work in whatever epoxy though some of the products are different capability. (also I am talking about the similar epoxies not all the additives work well in stuff like 5 minute. And if you use a cheaper version of some of them in the cheaper epoxies that can degrade performance.

Coloidal or fumed silica, etc... All seem the same.

WEST 410, I have yet to hear of anything that works like that, and it is the best (but I don't think it matters in anything you are doing).

The bulkers like the different balloons are the most variable. some are stronger, and others yield a lot more volume which reduces cost a lot. Often cheap bulkers are a bad idea, though the most expensive ones aren't necessary in most cases, either.