New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Wood movement

Posts

Wood movement

#1

Wood movement

Svante Nilsson

Hi,

I use to build furniture with drawers in my workshop that all year round has a 50% relative moisture content. When I move the furniture into my house everything is fine until August when the moisture is peaking and the drawers got stuck. I then have to refit them and after that they work fine all year round. I have thought upon making an extra gap from the beginning and thus avoiding the annoying refitting.

My workshop has 50% RH which gives a 9,5% moisture content in the wood. In August the RH is 70% which gives a 13% moisture content. The delta is 3,5%.

In this case I work with ash, which has a movement coefficient of 0.0017 (quarter sawn) and 0.0027 (flat sawn). My boards are something in-between so lets say 0.0022.

The wood expansion can be calculated by:

delta moisture content * wood movement coefficient * drawer height

With a drawer height of 100 mm (4 inch ) we get 0.8 mm (1/32 inch) extra gap. To me that seems realistic – any comments?

Regards,

Svante

Re: Wood movement

#2

Ellis Walentine

Accuracy

Ellis Walentine

Your numbers are correct for the ideal case, based on the values cited in the Wood Handbook and other references. There are a lot of variables, though: the actual species (not all ashes are alike), the individual tree, the relative-humidity extremes you're anticipating, the type and amount of finish you put on the wood, the actual grain orientation (radial/tangential). I don't know if you were already figuring on leaving a certain amount of gap, but to be on the safe side, I would err on the heavy side; that is, add a bit more than 1/32

If you are really going for a piston fit, make the sides tight to begin with and plane off the bottoms edges as needed when they start to stick. By the end of the first humidity cycle, you'll have taken off only as much as necessary, which will still rattle a bit in the heating season.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Wood movement

#3

Cockbeading and finish

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Svante and all,

In the case you are describing, one solution might be to retard movement for a month. You may not have to design for a big gap, if you merely retard moisture for a month. Build finishes will slow down moisture penetration--they won't defeat moisture, but they will retard it for a month or two. I recall a U. S Forest Products study which examined this in detail, and shellac worked well for the purpose. So I would ask, are your drawers finished? With what? You might consider finishing them with a shellac or lacquer, in order to get you through the critical month or two.

If you are already using a build finish, and it is not a solution, then you might consider cockbeading the drawers, where the body of the drawer is 'designed for August', but the cockbeading is tapered back to front, to provide some adjustability. Also, if the cockbeading is a bit darker than the drawer, it will tend to conceal or mask whatever gap you decide you need around it--the relief does not stand out, as it will with a light ash drawer.

Wiley

Re: Wood movement

#4

Re: Cockbeading and finish

Svante Nilsson

Thanks for your input!

I normally leave my furniture unfinished until the refitting process in August is over.

For this project I plan another approach. I make the gap between the drawers approx 0,4 mm (1/64), which is about the half of the theoretical wood expansion and finish with shellac and wax. When the humid period comes, which just is about three months here in northern Europe, I count on that the finish will delay the wood expansion and the drawers do not get stuck.

Re: Wood movement

#5

A flawed approach

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I presume we are talking about drawer heights. Drawers don't change in length, although the drawer opening might in some situations. You seem to be driven to make the clearance for drawer height as small as you can get by with. Why, for looks? Function trumps looks in furniture to be used.

I am making the assumption that this furniture is being built to last generations. Hence, it needs to perform in any home environment. A 1/64 gap at the top of a medium sized drawer is too small to ensure trouble free operation over the lifetime of the drawer. Nor is a gap this small necessary to achieve a properly working drawer. A sticky drawer some time in the future will likely end in the premature disposal of the furniture. Hence, one always errs on the side of too large a gap.

Relying on finish to prevent expansion may work in a specific situation but it is poor insurance that the drawer will be working properly 10 years from now in a different situation. You may decide to move to England.

Drawer College: Take every opportunity to study drawers in antique shops and museums. See what has lasted generations. At least here in the US I don't see drawers fit to 1/64 clearance. Furniture fit with drawers that tight was thrown out 150 years ago.

After studying drawers made in the US and England it appears that about a 1/32 clearance for drawer length is about right. And at midrange humidity a 1/32 clearance for height on a medium height drawer is about right. Personally, I don't obsess getting clearance the minimum I can get by with. Rather I strive for clearance that will ensure trouble free operation.

Re: Wood movement

#6

Re: A flawed approach

TomD

While this is perhaps a gross generalization, some of this piston fit stuff seems to come from England where up until relatively recently they didn't have central heating. This makes the roll of maker a little easier.

While Bill is probably right about the idea that if the drawers don't work the piece may well get tossed well before it should (though there are a mountain of reasons why that might happen anyway), the idea of seasonably accessible drawers is not all that foreign. I have one desk that get's too tight while we are away over summer. I could easily fix it because it is on wooden runners, but so far haven't bothered, this attitude is not all that foreign.

Finish will not really retard moisture uptake at the rate one might be after. Anything that "dries" has holes in the finish you can drive a truck through. Even epoxies will normalize to enviro conditions, though in that case it takes a while. And drawers were typically unfinished. Your finish to some extent was the drawer housing. Same reason we put precious instruments in boxes.

Re: Wood movement

#7

Re: A flawed approach

Sgian Dubh

"While this is perhaps a gross generalization..."

I tend to agree with that.

"... some of this piston fit stuff seems to come from England..."

I believe there is some truth in the piston fit thing originating in the UK (not England alone) where it is most commonly seen in small drawers, such as pencil drawers in a desk, or drawers in small jewellery cabinets.

"... where up until relatively recently they didn't have central heating...."

Nor did they have central heating in any other part of the world until relatively recently, although I'm guessing that we might be able to find a few Roman examples from about two thousand ago.

"This makes the roll of maker a little easier."

If that's the case it seems logical to assume the easier role you mention probably applies to all other parts of the world where central heating (and other climate control measures) have become more common and increasingly widespread, i.e., in only the last hundred or so years. I am aware, from my time living in Houston, that air-conditioning, central heating and the like was quite often missing from residential properties in that area right up until the 1950s or 60s. Quite a few houses built at that time had only whole house attic fans and fires of various sorts for winter use. Slainte.

Re: Wood movement

#8

Some data

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Svante and all,

Here is a reference to the U. S. Forest Products Lab. paper I mentioned:

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplrp/fplrp462.pdf

Note that all the test results are given at 90% relative humidity (RH); the test of moisture-exclusion that is used is the weight gain from 30% RH to 90% RH for a varying number of days. Most of the tests are done on Ponderosa pine sapwood, but they do show that hardwoods tend to absorb less moisture, but there are many, many variables (plain sawn vs. quartered, end grain sealing, wood density, and so on).

To point to just one datum, on p. 15, finish number 23 (shellac, unpigmented) applied at 6 coats, provided approx. 50% moisture exclusion at 35 days in continuous 90% humidity.

The main point made by the authors is that moisture-exclusion is very much a function of the number of coats applied.

Here in Southern California, our climate is not very challenging, so I can't quantify this next piece of advice. However, I believe you could help yourself quite a bit by sizing the end grain of your drawer fronts--in fact, all of the drawer parts end grain-- with dilute hide glue. Seal the end grain.

Wiley

Re: Wood movement

#9

alternative, and other data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Instead of relying on finish to ensure a drawer works, fit the drawer properly to begin with. Professional furniture makers successfully make furniture in their home location and ship anywhere. There is a shop in Shelbyville, Ky that buys exceptional English Period Reproductions from England and resells the pieces all over the US. The drawers in these pieces work well and look good.

I typically finish drawers with two coats of shellac. It keeps them looking bright and they slide easier. From my experience building several chests of drawers this amount of finish does not retard moisture take up and loss sufficient to prevent an ill-fit drawer from sticking at elevated humidity. You will see an increase in drawer height (quartered poplar) on a large drawer (8") in a matter of days, not weeks(for example sitting in the truck in the summer for three days during a delivery). Been there and done that.

Re: Wood movement

#10

Re: Another Study, and a Question

William Duffield

Don Williams has provided another important research paper on permeability of several different finishes to water and other solvents, here:

https://s3.amazonaws.com/theBarn/Articles/Shellac/Williams%2cDon-Effects_on_Permeability.pdf

It was published in 1937, so some terminology has changed, as have the availability of some of the different film finishes. Note especially that the term "varnish" was applied much more widely at that time than today, and included shellac and lacquer. The research does not address polyurethane varnishes, as polyurethane was only first made in 1937 and had not yet made its way into varnishes at the time.

Do you always apply cockbeading to your chest drawers? If not, have you noticed difference is rates of wood movement between drawers with and without cockbeading? Cockbeading, since it covers the end grain of the drawer front, should theoretically inhibit moisture exchange through the most permeable drawer surfaces, and therefore decrease seasonal wood movement.