New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

Posts

Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

#1

Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

Tom Colligan

My sharpening routine involves just two Shapton stones, 2000 and 8000, that gives a mirror finish result.

But periodically I've needed a coarse stone for preparing a neglected iron or chisel. Not too long ago I bought a coarse EZE-Lap stone and remember how coarse it was to the touch. Today it's quite smooth and offers no speedier result than a 1000 Japanese Water Stone. Yet, I don't believe I've used it much at all.

Is it simply the nature of a coarse stone? That is, if the grain is rough to the touch when new, it stands to reason the grains will get knocked off all the sooner compared to non diamond stones?

Is there another brand I'll have a better experience with their coarse stone?

Thanks in advance, Tom.

Re: Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

#2

Re: Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

wilbur

That does seem to be one of the downsides of diamond stones: they cut aggressively when new, but then slow down quite a bit. I’ve had the same issue that you describe with a DMT coarse diamond stone.

Currently, I have been using an Atoma diamond plate that’s rated at 400 grit. I mainly use it for flattening waterstones, but it does work well for removing metal, and I haven’t seen as much drop off in speed as I did with my DMT diamond stone. More info here: http://giantcypress.net/post/41860013521/atoma-bomb

Re: Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

#3

Re: Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

John in NM

That is the nature of Nickel bonded diamond laps. I quit using them for lapidary work because of it. They still cut after the initial bloom is off, but they cut more slowly than you'd like, remembering how quick it was at first.

The idea with bonded laps is to make using diamond clean and easy, contamination of coarser grit onto finer laps is a problem with loose grit. Loose grit is nice because the diamond is continually renewable, and really quite cheap compared to buying the lap. Personally, I quickly found that avoiding contamination was a lot easier than paying for laps that wear out quickly.

Re: Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

#4

Re: Problem With Coarse Diamond Stone

david weaver

My experience with the eze lap hones is that they lose their bit fast, too, and then settle into a fineness that seems to be 2-4 times what their initial rating is, and then they stay there.

They are not faster than a comparable waterstone at that level (for example, the 250 grit hone may end up being about as fast as a 1000 grit waterstone), but their virtue is that with something like hard HSS or powder metal, they stay at that same speed whereas a water stone will not tolerate powder metal that well unless it's very soft.

For fast coarse work in most types of tool steel, a coarse stone is more effective, and a soft coarse stone is most effective. In oilstones, medium and coarse carborundums are excellent, and dare I say it, the old style pink aluminum oxide stones are very fast and effective in waterstones, despite the fact that they make a large mess.

I haven't used any of the newer whiz bang hard stones below 1000 grit other than the chosera 400, and like choseras in general, the 400 rating is a bit coarser than it actually is (it is just sub 1000 grit in practice, only slightly faster than a shapton 1000 whereas a pink aluminum oxide stone graded 220 will raise a gigantic wire edge and do it quickly).