We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have a Millers Falls hand plane that I am restoring and the rod that holds the tote is bent and corroded. I would like to fabricate a new one from 3/16 steel rod, however there are 20 TPI and 24 is the coursest I have. A search of the internet has left me finding no one who sells that size die. Rather than try to use the old rod or oversizing it, does anyone know of a source of this die? I can anticipate future uses for it so I wouldn't mind finding a single tap and die.
I think there are two choices: 1) get a beater MF so you can harvest a donor rod; or, 2) re-tap the female side so that it suits the die you have for the brass rod.
It seems to me that your #2 recommendation is going to get complicated. Won't he need to start with a larger diameter tap, and a bottoming tap to boot? Won't that mean he will need a larger diameter steel rod and matching die? This might lead to the necessity to enlarge the hole in the tote. I would suspect that the thread size of the slotted nut and the top end of the rod also use the unavailable tap and die size. If so, won't he also need to retap the nut attached to the top of the rod and cut matching threads in the top of the rod?
I wouldn't think it should be complicated. My experience is limited but I have frequently gone up a size without any issue. You are right about the other end. I forgot about that. Option# 1 is my favourite !!!
I've done it on a couple Stanley's, just run a 1/4-20 bottom tap into the hole. Carefully with lots of oil. Then used all-thread as the rod.
You can also use a #12-20 screw to split the difference. I've occasionally wondered if all those 3/16-20 rods are really 12-20's since that's an oddball size that I've at least heard of
I tend to quickly lose interest in that question though, since I prefer to use 1/4-20 rod anyway.
For a good selection of oddball taps and dies, I like Victor Machinery (I buy bandsaw stock from them too). No 3/16-20 though
It sounds to me that you like tools. Your best solution by far is to purchase and antique tap and die set from the 'bay but do not spend more than $25 and this will cover future needs as well.
A #10 machine screw is 0.190" in diameter, only 0.0025" larger, a hard to detect difference.
A #12 machine screw is 0.216" in diameter, a distinct difference.
I had a side conversation with Jeff that led me to measuring the diameter of the stud that hold the tote on, and it's a #12 screw; a 3/16" rod would be undersized enough that, even if threaded to the pitch required, would likely be too small to hold in the hole.
I didn't memorize these dimensions, by the way; Google was my friend. But I did know that #10 is just about 3/16. Interestingly, machine screws don't track on fractional dimensions very well at all. Although all the places I shop stop at #12 with their offerings of machine-screw-designated screws, my uncle's odler Starrett catalog lists machine screws up to #30. The #14 screw is 0.242". This is so close to a 1/4" screw, at 0.25", that it's understandable that manufacturers, and thus retailers, simplified starting at that dimension, sticking with fractional sizes from there up.
I pulled the stud from a boneyard plane (a Sargent*, I think, on which the front of the sole had been broken off) and measured it, as part of my side conversation with Jeff. It measured out to be a #12, with 20 threads per inch. #12-20 is NOT a standard machine screw designation - the two standard pitches are 24 (coarse) and 28 (fine, and rarely stocked by retailers).
Victor Machinery does list a #12-20 tap, although they're out of stock at the moment; and a #12-20 die, currently in stock. But making a stud from scratch would require finding rod in machine screw dimensions, or finding a very long machine screw that wasn't threaded its full length, neither task very easy.
It would be possible to retap the hole in question to a standard #12 machine screw pitch, probably coarse (see earlier paragraph about fine thread in that size). I've retapped coarse-threaded holes to fine thread several times, with good results, including a bolt that held the heavy generator on my Studebaker truck; so I think a retapped hole for a plane tote would probably be OK. That would be a solution here, if you could find a machine screw with a suitable head to fit the counterbore on the plane's tote (or a suitably sized washer to fit under the head). In my side conversation with Jeff, he mentioned that he's cleaning this plane up to be a user plane. In a situation like that, for a plane common enough not to be collectible, I wouldn't hesitate to drill the hole all the way through and retap it with a regular taper or plug tap. I would countersink the hole where it exited in the sole, so as not to create a sharp edge. But really, a hole that size on the plane sole is functionally no different from a corrugated sole; it wouldn't affect use.
--------
*For reasons that, no doubt, made sense to the early 20th century plane manufacturers, this particular stud tends to be consistent in size/pitch on Stanley, Millers-Falls, and Sargent planes (and maybe others); at least, that's been my observation. This does not hold true for other threaded bits: the fence rod for a Stanley 78 and Sargent 79 (both fenced duplex rabbet planes) differ, for instance, with Sargent using a standard pitch and Stanley (surprise!) using a non-standard one. Someone with enough time and obsessiveness on his/her hands could no doubt have fun for months compiling a comparison chart of threaded-fastener sizes and pitches on all the plane types common among the major manufacturers; maybe someone already has, and I just don't know about it.
An interesting discussion on the development of standards in screw manufacturing and the use of 12-20 by Stanley can be found at the link provided. Many mechanical standards, as well as the standardization of time by the railroads, occurred in the latter half of the 19th century.
I've kind of wondered about the 3/16-20 business for years, since 12-20 is oddball enough to not occur to many, but less oddball than 3/16-20. Since I always tapped them out to 1/4-20, it simply never occurred to me to measure. Appalling isn't it?
It would actually be quite easy to make a new stud in 12-20. You can get O1 steel in close to the right diameter (0.219") and just use it un-hardened. Of course, I'm not that much of a purist.
I usually needed longer rods anyway, since I was making my own totes.
If you think Stanley bench planes are a pain to find fasteners for , the venerable Colt 1911 designed by John M. Browning in the early 1900s has some real oddball threads in it . How about .236" by 60 tpi or .150" by 50 tpi.
With guns, the screws are often custom made, and they are often cut so the slot aligns aesthetically at one given position. Of course 1911s are a different mater, being mass produced. But there really isn't any reason why the screws should be stock, when something else would work better. Then you get someone thinking the 5" barrel should be shortened to 3" and the whole think needs to be rethought, and maybe resized.
I had to fix the serpentine belt on my f-150. The tensioner was shot and it was held on with a socket screw. I tried everything I could, but nothing fit. I went to the parts department, where I faced a guy whose job it was not to sell one parts. He said it could be any of a number of different screws, with easily available sizes like 6.8 mm, 6.3, etc... I eventually found a torx bit that sorta fit, and I cut it to fit on the mill. Maybe inside the engine, but I am not so sure why a tensioner needs a raft of different sizes.