New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Posts

Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#1

Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Guillaume Dery

Hi gang, following up on my Mortice chisels TOTT find and ongoing rehabilitation.

Now that the backs are (finally) flattened, I still need to sharpen these and fix the primary bevel. They are badly chipped and out of square and have a variety of issues. While I can and often do freehand my smaller chisels and plane blades, this doesn't extend to suckers this big and top-heavy or restoring geometry.

I am definitely going to jig these up. Looking at the honing guides and polling a few people, I have landed on the Kell honing guide as being well suited for this. My existing Veritas and eclipse guides can't handle the chisels due to the huge cross-section. Never mind how well it could hold the, I can't get the in, period.

So a 2-part question for owners/users of the Kell guides:

1- What is the working depth on the large wheel #2 Kell guide? (I am pretty sure that the 1/2" pig-sticker is just about an inch in cross section) I would hate to buy something for a specific purpose only to have undersized it.

2- Can anyone point me to a Canadian or US source I can order the appropriate Kell guide from? Ordering direct from Richard Kell is out as I have a philosophical difference with PayPal and he won't accept any other form of payment (not that I blame him, I understand his reasoning, it just means I can't do business direct with him, much as I'd like to). I did note that they seem to have them at Joel's toolsforworkingwood but they seem to be the old model with the small wheel (based on the accompanying image on their website at any rate).

Thanks in advance all,

Guillaume

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#2

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Sgian Dubh

""While I can and often do freehand my smaller chisels and plane blades, this doesn't extend to suckers this big and top-heavy or restoring geometry.

If you can do those 'smaller' plane irons and chisels freehand what's really stopping you sharpening those mortice chisels? I am aware that you said something about your arm or wrist being in plaster for at least a month, but you said that near enough a month ago. And if I can, at a bit of a push and if I'm in the mood, freehand sharpen pretty much any chisel or plane iron I use with just one hand, what's stopping you doing something similar ... except perhaps fear itself?

I never cease to be amazed at all the obstacles and difficulties people dream up to make the elementary task of sharpening a basic woodworking tool either difficult, or impossible without unnecessary sharpening aids, guides and other fripperies.

This is surely the Hand Tool woodworking forum? Who can really call themselves a hand tool woodworker of any merit if they can't even sharpen their bloody tools without guides, training wheels, jigs and other nonsense.

There's a slight hope in this post that I might stir this unusually moribund forum into something slightly reminiscent of life.

Why is it so quiet around here anyway? Slainte.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#3

Re: One Hand

david weaver

I agree - one hand. No guide. grind the chisels how you'd like, lift the edge just a tiny bit and drag it on a stone. Work off the wire edge with the method of your choice (polishing stone, strop, whatever) and use your chisel. It will be much harder to use that guide than it will be to hone the chisel itself with one hand.

I've done the same thing often - the only prompting I need to use one hand on mortise chisels is to have something in the other hand and not feel like putting it down.

If you find you have a bias to the left or right, just consciously counteract it. If you screw up the bevel over several honings, just regrind.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#4

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Guillaume Dery

Tsk, tsk, tsk,

You really are out to stir a hornet's nest aren't you?

If you can do those 'smaller' plane irons and chisels freehand what's really stopping you sharpening those mortice chisels? I am aware that you said something about your arm or wrist being in plaster for at least a month, but you said that near enough a month ago. And if I can, at a bit of a push and if I'm in the mood, freehand sharpen pretty much any chisel or plane iron I use with just one hand, what's stopping you doing something similar ... except perhaps fear itself?

Wrist hasn't been healing well so after my next appointment, it will have spent about 2.5 months in plaster... not fun.

Now as to the sharpening and re-establishing the geometry, never tried one handed and can't imagine that it would work too well for me, I would have control issues (missing digit courtesy of rock climbing accident). Nonetheless, while I may attempt it at some point just for kicks, I believe that it would have a lengthy learning curve for me and that I would need to develop the muscle memory to do it reasonably well with something that had proper geometry to begin with. I don't think that it is a question of fear but just of being intelligent enough to know my imitations and learning process. The idea that I can freehand grind, hone and polish a large chisel that has well over a pound of metal hanging off the back-side, effectively lifting off the stone, one-handed with my non-dominant hand and have any hope of getting an acceptable edge, or not gouge my stones as well as restore geometry and square the chisel is slightly laughable. Even were we to give me unwarranted credit and say that this is possible and that I will get there, there are some factors to take into consideration. How many hours/weeks will it take me to get an acceptable result? Now what is my time worth? How much is a Kell honing guide? I am all for learning to freehand sharpen but one-handed, unless necessity dictates, seems rather silly.

I never cease to be amazed at all the obstacles and difficulties people dream up to make the elementary task of sharpening a basic woodworking tool either difficult, or impossible without unnecessary sharpening aids, guides and other fripperies.

Now here I partly agree with you. There are many ways and systems to get to a sharp edge, people should pick one, get good and use it. It is also quite liberating to be able to freehand sharpen. I can get by with a very basic kit, my 1K, 4K and 8K waterstones plus something to flatten them with which can do double duty to grind away edge damage and I am set. I still believe that honing guides have their place however. They introduce mindless repeatability and ensure consistency. Not a bad thing in my humble opinion. If I get a batch of things that need sharpening at the flea market, I will probably break out the honing guide as I know my mind will eventually wander if I do a marathon session.

This is surely the Hand Tool woodworking forum? Who can really call themselves a hand tool woodworker of any merit if they can't even sharpen their bloody tools without guides, training wheels, jigs and other nonsense.

And this would be the part where you are deliberately kicking the hornet's nest in order to get some life and action into the forum. I believe that this statement is purely intended to be inflammatory on your part.

Nonetheless, I will play along. The merit of a woodworker should surely be measured by the artistry and craftsmanship of his creations. It is what we build that will be used to judge our merit as a woodworker when we have long returned to dust. Were I to tell you the Hall brothers used honing guides, would that take away their value? No, whenever one looks at a piece of Greene and Greene furniture, the beauty of the piece, the craftsmanship and artistry are what we take away.

And again, being a hand-tool woodworker and our merit as it relates to that hinges on how well we use the tools, not whether we use honing guides. It is a given that maintaining edges is of vital importance to being able to successfully use hand tools. However, as long as one can get to that well maintained edge, it does not matter how one got there.

There's a slight hope in this post that I might stir this unusually moribund forum into something slightly reminiscent of life.

Why is it so quiet around here anyway?


That depends, do they usually feed the trolls here?

Guillaume

P.S. Next time you want to kick some activity in here, maybe you can just list a bunch of topics you'd like initiate a fight about rather than hijack my thread on the first reply :)

Also, maybe pick a topic a bit less controversial than honing guides? You know, something tame like politics, religion or sex...

"Should the pope be allowed to keep a string of prostitutes on speed dial to distract him while he is busy fighting to reverse the separation of church and state." would probably be a slightly less controversial topic than honing guides.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#5

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Brian Greene

Guillaume,

Jack has a Kell you could try, if you must. I don't know which size.

As you know, I sharpen absolutely everything freehand. You can too. It's all about: attitude, technique and practice. Equipment is mostly irrelevant.

Don't over analyze this. Just do it. If you don't like the results, re-grind and try again. I'll be back on May 13. Come show me what you've done!

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#6

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Ray

There are two or three other US vendors that carry his guides, but none of them list the the larger wheel variety. I read his blog (I think) a few weeks ago and I got the impression that he has been slow to get his newer products to his vendors. Send an email to him, he normally responds within a day or two.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#7

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Steve Corpstein

Yeah, and I stand in a bed of hot coals while I'm being manly. Give it a break, honing by hand isn't as cool as you make it out to be. It's not like it's a right of passage.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#8

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Guillaume Dery

Dammit, you're right, I seem to be able to do it one handed. I did pick the shortest chisel to make it easier on myself and am still unsure that I can freehand the big sucker but it seems I can do it. It's not perfect, I think I am one or 2 degrees of square but it should be usable.

I still think you were trolling and I still think there is nothing wrong with guides however.


Here's the pigstickers


Next step, rehandling

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#9

It is Kell #1 ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... not the #2 that you are after.

Off Richard's site ...


I used one of these for a few years (now freehand mortice chisels). It is very well made, however the absence of something to grip, other than the chisel, makes it a but cumbersome to use.

Here it is again in a fun shot ...


Guillaume, sorry to hear of the difficulties you are having with your hand. Nevertheless, it is very likely that you will find it as easy to freehand a mortice chisel as use the Kell as the freehand method is similarly push-and-pull. I did outline a technique in an earlier thread, and this is worth a go before outlaying anything on another guide. All you require is a sliding bevel ....

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/2/md/read/id/472378/sbj/honing-a-mortice-chisel/

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#10

BIG Wheels

David Charlesworth

Derek,

You have evidently not seen Richard's new big wheels?

They make for a much more user friendly projection. There is actually something to press down on.

I suggested these in the beginning and am delighted to see them.

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#11

Re: BIG Wheels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I have not seen the new version. I am sure it is a significant improvement.

Having said this, and not meaning to minimise the worth of the new Kell, I still maintain that freehanding is easier, specifically freehanding a rounded secondary bevel of 35 degrees onto the 20 degree primary bevel. Just pull the blade back and lift to 35 degrees (keep a sliding bevel handy). One hand on the handle (support) and the other on the end of the blade (to guide). Hardly any downforce so it does not require much hand strength.


This issue is also about re-sharpening than just sharpening since, as the edge dulls, it is a simple matter to hone on a strop with green compound. A few seconds and the edge is sharp enough to pare endgrain.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#12

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Sgian Dubh

"Dammit, you're right, I seem to be able to do it one handed."

Of course you can. It's only a mortice chisel. It doesn't need to be perfect across the width, nor even super sharp. After all, isn't the purpose of a mortice chisel to knock seven bells out of a piece of wood whilst you hack out a mortice? So what would be the point of refining the edge to the same state you might refine a smoothing plane's edge for the final passes in prepping wood just prior to applying polish in the case of a premium piece of furniture, not that I'm suggesting you are aiming for that type of refinement?

"The merit of a woodworker should surely be measured by the artistry and craftsmanship of his creations. It is what we build that will be used to judge our merit as a woodworker when we have long returned to dust. Were I to tell you the Hall brothers used honing guides, would that take away their value? No, whenever one looks at a piece of Greene and Greene furniture, the beauty of the piece, the craftsmanship and artistry are what we take away.

... our merit as it relates to that hinges on how well we use the tools, not whether we use honing guides. It is a given that maintaining edges is of vital importance to being able to successfully use hand tools. However, as long as one can get to that well maintained edge, it does not matter how one got there."

Well, yes, up to a point, but assuming a woodworker is good enough to create high quality furniture using a range of equipment, including a significant amount of hand tool work, then my assumption is that they have pretty good hand to eye coordination, good enough to accurately cut joints and other technically challenging tasks to high standards. Anyone that can do that probably has all the necessary skills in place to simply grab a chisel or plane iron and whisk it up and down some sort of sharpening medium and end up with a sharp tool.

"Also, maybe pick a topic a bit less controversial than honing guides? You know, something tame like politics, religion or sex... "

Nah. Sorry. All too boring. Controversial sharpening threads are much more entertaining. Slainte.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#13

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

Sgian Dubh

"Yeah, and I stand in a bed of hot coals while I'm being manly."

Why would you do that? It seems pretty silly to me.

"Give it a break, honing by hand isn't as cool as you make it out to be. It's not like it's a right of passage."

You're correct on all counts. Freehand sharpening isn't cool: it's a basic skill. It's not a rite of passage either because it's a run of the mill task undertaken whenever needed. Slainte.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#14

Re: BIG Wheels

David Charlesworth

The big wheels are a huge improvement, because the chisel projection is now sufficient to allow pressure to be placed on the chisel tip.

With the original version I had to use a pencil with eraser to achieve this, (on small chisels).

Generally I do not like or use guides with training wheels, but for 1.5, 3, and 4.5mm chisels, the Kell guide is brilliant, producing perfect squareness with little effort. This is particularly useful for my students.

David Charlesworth

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#15

Re: It is Kell #1 ...

Guillaume Dery

Thanks Derek,

I had run through your previous post (and not so proudly lifted the honing technique. I had however missed the fact that you IDed the guide as the number 1. Guess all the pretty pictures distracted me.

It was interesting to do one handed but I managed to grind it pretty well by grasping the chisel fairly low and using my hand to control the angle, then butting the handle against my abs and swaying my body to impart motion. Ungainly as hell but it seemed to work.

Out of general curiosity, when you re-handled your pig-stickers, did you taper the oval from top to bottom or did you do a straight diameter oval? When I looked over your write-up on your site, that wasn't clear to me (or maybe I missed it, just like your explicitly stating that it was the Kell #1...). I know the former is more traditional but I am leaning towards the later. I am unsure of any ergonomic or mechanical advantage one would offer over the other. I may also end up being a heretic and just epoxy the darn thing into a round hole rather then carve out a tapered hole or burn them in (unless there is a good reason for not doing that).

Guillaume

P.S.: I don't know how you find the time to always put up such detailed responses with accompanying pictures and illustrations (I barely have time to hit the shop, much less write) but it is always much appreciated.

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#16

Re: It is Kell #1 ... *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Out of general curiosity, when you re-handled your pig-stickers, did you taper the oval from top to bottom or did you do a straight diameter oval? When I looked over your write-up on your site, that wasn't clear to me (or maybe I missed it, just like your explicitly stating that it was the Kell #1...). I know the former is more traditional but I am leaning towards the later. I am unsure of any ergonomic or mechanical advantage one would offer over the other. I may also end up being a heretic and just epoxy the darn thing into a round hole rather then carve out a tapered hole or burn them in (unless there is a good reason for not doing that).

Hi Guillaume

Gad ... you have to slow down when you read! :)

If you scan down the article you will discover ...

"Keep in mind that the oval tapers toward the bolster."

You can see the taper here - it is not much, so easy to miss (the lower chisel) ..


P.S.: I don't know how you find the time to always put up such detailed responses with accompanying pictures and illustrations (I barely have time to hit the shop, much less write) but it is always much appreciated.

Yeah, I rush out to the shop with my camera ever time someone has a question! ;)

Photobucket is a wonderful storage facility. The photos have been collecting over some years now. The Internet lends itself to visual communication, and I have long believed that it is the best way to communicate the type of information we focus on.

Incidentally, Joel has a series on mortice chisels on his blog, and the recent one deals with rehandling.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Rehandling An Oval Bolstered Mortice Chisel

Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide

#17

Re: It is Kell #1 ...

Guillaume

Doh! Oh for 2 for missing bits of info in your writing. I promise to read twice next time before asking you a question.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go apologize to my 4 year old who I regularly chastise for not listening enough when something is told/explained to her.

She obviously gets it from her mother's side :)

GD