Re: Chisel follow-up - The Kell honing guide
Guillaume Dery
Tsk, tsk, tsk,
You really are out to stir a hornet's nest aren't you?
If you can do those 'smaller' plane irons and chisels freehand what's really stopping you sharpening those mortice chisels? I am aware that you said something about your arm or wrist being in plaster for at least a month, but you said that near enough a month ago. And if I can, at a bit of a push and if I'm in the mood, freehand sharpen pretty much any chisel or plane iron I use with just one hand, what's stopping you doing something similar ... except perhaps fear itself?
Wrist hasn't been healing well so after my next appointment, it will have spent about 2.5 months in plaster... not fun.
Now as to the sharpening and re-establishing the geometry, never tried one handed and can't imagine that it would work too well for me, I would have control issues (missing digit courtesy of rock climbing accident). Nonetheless, while I may attempt it at some point just for kicks, I believe that it would have a lengthy learning curve for me and that I would need to develop the muscle memory to do it reasonably well with something that had proper geometry to begin with. I don't think that it is a question of fear but just of being intelligent enough to know my imitations and learning process. The idea that I can freehand grind, hone and polish a large chisel that has well over a pound of metal hanging off the back-side, effectively lifting off the stone, one-handed with my non-dominant hand and have any hope of getting an acceptable edge, or not gouge my stones as well as restore geometry and square the chisel is slightly laughable. Even were we to give me unwarranted credit and say that this is possible and that I will get there, there are some factors to take into consideration. How many hours/weeks will it take me to get an acceptable result? Now what is my time worth? How much is a Kell honing guide? I am all for learning to freehand sharpen but one-handed, unless necessity dictates, seems rather silly.
I never cease to be amazed at all the obstacles and difficulties people dream up to make the elementary task of sharpening a basic woodworking tool either difficult, or impossible without unnecessary sharpening aids, guides and other fripperies.
Now here I partly agree with you. There are many ways and systems to get to a sharp edge, people should pick one, get good and use it. It is also quite liberating to be able to freehand sharpen. I can get by with a very basic kit, my 1K, 4K and 8K waterstones plus something to flatten them with which can do double duty to grind away edge damage and I am set. I still believe that honing guides have their place however. They introduce mindless repeatability and ensure consistency. Not a bad thing in my humble opinion. If I get a batch of things that need sharpening at the flea market, I will probably break out the honing guide as I know my mind will eventually wander if I do a marathon session.
This is surely the Hand Tool woodworking forum? Who can really call themselves a hand tool woodworker of any merit if they can't even sharpen their bloody tools without guides, training wheels, jigs and other nonsense.
And this would be the part where you are deliberately kicking the hornet's nest in order to get some life and action into the forum. I believe that this statement is purely intended to be inflammatory on your part.
Nonetheless, I will play along. The merit of a woodworker should surely be measured by the artistry and craftsmanship of his creations. It is what we build that will be used to judge our merit as a woodworker when we have long returned to dust. Were I to tell you the Hall brothers used honing guides, would that take away their value? No, whenever one looks at a piece of Greene and Greene furniture, the beauty of the piece, the craftsmanship and artistry are what we take away.
And again, being a hand-tool woodworker and our merit as it relates to that hinges on how well we use the tools, not whether we use honing guides. It is a given that maintaining edges is of vital importance to being able to successfully use hand tools. However, as long as one can get to that well maintained edge, it does not matter how one got there.
There's a slight hope in this post that I might stir this unusually moribund forum into something slightly reminiscent of life.
Why is it so quiet around here anyway?
That depends, do they usually feed the trolls here?
Guillaume
P.S. Next time you want to kick some activity in here, maybe you can just list a bunch of topics you'd like initiate a fight about rather than hijack my thread on the first reply 
Also, maybe pick a topic a bit less controversial than honing guides? You know, something tame like politics, religion or sex...
"Should the pope be allowed to keep a string of prostitutes on speed dial to distract him while he is busy fighting to reverse the separation of church and state." would probably be a slightly less controversial topic than honing guides.