New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Dutch Tool Chest

Posts

Dutch Tool Chest

#1

Dutch Tool Chest

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

Saw questions from a hand saw noob...

In the Oct. 2013 issue of PWW, Chris Schwarz made the Dutch Tool Chest. In the lid's saw till are two saws.

PWW Christopher Schwarz blog

What are those saws? What do you call them? Just "panel saws" or is there a different term for them? I realize one is likely filed rip and one cross-cut.

I'm trying to learn a bit about hand saws and sharpening. I've been reading archives here, the Articles section (Taran & Smalser articles), ordered the book Ellis just released, and so on.

I have a Disston back saw that was my dad's. Nothing fancy. It's a crosscut saw he used to use around the house. I plan to practice sharpening on it. I've ordered files and so on from Lee Valley.

Last noob saw question. I would like to get a couple saws like shown in the Tool Chest article/blog. I do not go to garage sales, flea markets and so on. I've stumbles across some on-line places that sell refurbished saws. A lot seem to cost more than a bran new LN saw.

I could clean up a used one myself. Does anybody know of a source that sells used saws that maybe still need to be cleaned up? Maybe a trusted Ebay seller that I could keep my eye on?

I don't plan to buy one today. Just searching and learning. Thanks for any input.

Thank you.

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

#2

I have and use a wide variety of saws.

Chuck Nickerson

My saws range from 9" backsaws to a 30" 4ppi rip saw. The terminology (panel vs hand, tenon vs carcass) is slippery. Best to focus on a range of lengths so you can comfortably handle a range of problems.

Those are probably the longest saws that would fit in the chest. His back saws, usually shorter, are down in a till. I have 20" saws (I consider them panel), rip and crosscut, from LN and consider them a great addition. The panel length is not covered by many of the custom saw makers, so it's rehab or LN.

(Disclaimer: I bought the saws because I like buying tools. Once I buy them I do use them though.)

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

#3

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

TomD

I pick up saws like that second hand, I like the details of the old saws better, I suppose there is also the fact that I can handle them before I buy, while with new stuff I usually have to deal mail order.

I would probably call them panel saws, though there are whole crafts that use similar saws, but never touch a panel, so it is really a bit random.

I am reminded of fly nomenclature in Fly fishing, where at one point the insects had charming names (still in use) like Blue Winged Olive (BWO), or Pale Morning Dun. At some point, in an attempt to adopt better scholarship, the names shifted to scientific ones based on taxonomy. These then got clipped so the BWO became a Baetis. One I liked got clipped to Pseudo, which sounded about right to me.

Of course few people who learned the Latin names actually had taken it to a point where these names, either the Latin words or how they fit into the system of classification, meant anything more than the sounds of the words themselves. After a few decades of this stuff, it turned out we were pretty much all using the wrong names. As further members of these insects families had been identified the names had shifted again, and we where parroting back answer to questions that might have been asked on a final in 1985, but not 2005. There is something to be said for keeping it simple.

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

#4

Acquiring saws

Chuck Bjorgen

Hey, Joe, I started the saw restoration and sharpening process last year. Bought the file set from LV along with their saw file holder. I managed to pick up a couple D-8's at local garage sales and also a pair of D-23 cross cuts on the Bay. You'll learn that saw filing is a gradually learned process. I would put aside your Dad's backsaw for now and try to learn on saws with larger tooth patterns, rip at 5 pt. and crosscut at 8 pt. You'll be able to see what you're doing better with these coarser saws.

I have purchased new saws from LN, LV, and TFWW and they work very well. I would point out, however, that none of the vintage saws I've bought cost more than $20 with most of them below $5. Those are the saws I'm practicing on.

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

#5

Saw nomenclature

Patrick Gibbons

Saw- a crosscut saw of 26" length.

Rip saw- a 26" or longer saw with teeth filed for ripping.

Panel saw- a 24" or shorter saw.

Box saw- a short saw, perhaps as short as 12" to 20". Usually filed for crosscut. So-called because it is short enough to fit in a (tool) box.

Panel saws are usually 24" and have teeth filed crosscut at 10 to 12 ppi. Common wisdom used to be that if one could own just one saw, it should be a panel saw because it could do the best job of taking the place of other saws; i.e. One could use it in a pinch to rip, crosscut, take the place of a backsaw.

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

#6

Re: Saw nomenclature

TomD

Ellis' saw dictionary will be on my Xmas list, that should reduce the subject to a ready reference.

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

#7

Re: Dutch Tool Chest

joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the info guys.